The expectations were sky-high. Honestly, "sky-high" doesn't even cover it. Coming off a 2014 National Championship run where Urban Meyer’s squad basically dismantled Alabama and Oregon with a third-string quarterback, the ohio state football calendar 2015 was supposed to be a victory lap. We’re talking about a team that returned almost every major playmaker, including Ezekiel Elliott, Michael Thomas, and Joey Bosa. On paper, it was the greatest college football roster ever assembled in the modern era. But if you actually followed that season, you know it felt less like a dominant march and more like a weekly soap opera.
It was weird.
Every Saturday felt like the Buckeyes were playing against themselves as much as the opponent. They spent months ranked number one in the country despite looking sluggish against teams like Northern Illinois and Indiana. The ohio state football calendar 2015 serves as a fascinating case study in what happens when a program has too much talent and not enough clarity at the most important position on the field.
The Quarterback Carousel That Defined the Schedule
You remember the "problem" everyone talked about in August. Urban Meyer had three legitimate Heisman-caliber quarterbacks: Braxton Miller (the former Big Ten Player of the Year), J.T. Barrett (the 2014 sensation), and Cardale Jones (the "12-Gauge" who won the ring). Miller eventually moved to H-Back, which was a selfless move that probably saved the season from total locker room chaos, but the battle between Jones and Barrett lingered far too long.
When the ohio state football calendar 2015 kicked off on Labor Day night against Virginia Tech, Cardale got the nod. It looked brilliant for about two hours. Jones was throwing bombs, and Miller had that iconic spin move that broke the internet. But as the weeks rolled on, the rhythm just wasn't there.
By the time the Buckeyes hit the mid-September stretch against Northern Illinois and Western Michigan, the offense was a mess. They beat NIU 20-13, a score that felt like a loss to a fan base expecting 50 points a game. The schedule was arguably too soft in the first half, allowing the coaching staff to tinker and hesitate rather than picking a "guy" and sticking with him. It wasn't until the October 24th game against Rutgers that J.T. Barrett finally took over the starting role full-time.
💡 You might also like: NFL Pick 'em Predictions: Why You're Probably Overthinking the Divisional Round
Looking Back at the Key Dates on the Ohio State Football Calendar 2015
Let’s be real about the strength of schedule. People complained about it then, and looking back, they were right. The Buckeyes didn't play a ranked opponent until November. That’s a long time to keep a team focused when they know they are more talented than everyone they line up against.
The ohio state football calendar 2015 was back-loaded in a way that proved fatal.
- September 7: The revenge game at Virginia Tech. Buckeyes win 42-24. High point of the early season.
- September 19: The Northern Illinois scare. Cardale Jones throws two picks, and the Buckeyes barely survive.
- October 17: Penn State visits the Shoe. This was the "Blackout" game where the Buckeyes wore all-black uniforms. They won 38-10, mostly because J.T. Barrett came in as a "red zone" specialist.
- November 21: The Michigan State disaster. This is the date burned into the brain of every Ohio State fan.
The Rainy Afternoon Everything Fell Apart
It was cold. It was raining. It was the game that broke the ohio state football calendar 2015. Michigan State came into Columbus without their starting quarterback, Connor Cook. The Buckeyes were favored by two touchdowns. It should have been the final hurdle before The Game and the playoffs.
Instead, the play-calling went completely stagnant. Ezekiel Elliott, arguably the best running back in school history, only got 12 carries. Twelve. In a monsoon. He finished with 33 yards. The image of Michael Geiger, the MSU kicker, windmills-wheeling across the field after hitting the game-winning field goal as time expired is still a trigger for many in Columbus.
Elliott didn't hold back after the game. He basically called out the coaching staff, saying there was no chance he was coming back for his senior year and that he was frustrated by the lack of touches. It was raw, it was honest, and it exposed the internal friction that had been bubbling under the surface of the 2015 season.
📖 Related: Why the Marlins Won World Series Titles Twice and Then Disappeared
The Michigan Game and the "What If" Factor
The most frustrating part of the ohio state football calendar 2015 is what happened exactly one week after the Michigan State loss. The Buckeyes went to Ann Arbor and absolutely destroyed Jim Harbaugh's first Michigan team 42-13.
Everything finally clicked. The offensive line moved people. Zeke ran for 214 yards. The defense, led by Bosa and Darron Lee, was suffocating. It was the performance everyone had been waiting for all year. But it was too late. Because of the loss to the Spartans, Ohio State didn't even make the Big Ten Championship game.
They ended up in the Fiesta Bowl against Notre Dame. They won that game handily, 44-28, finishing the season 12-1. On paper, it’s a great year. In reality, it felt like a missed opportunity for a repeat. That 2015 team sent 12 players to the 2016 NFL Draft, including five first-rounders. It was a roster of professionals playing a college schedule, yet they missed the playoff because of one bad afternoon in the rain.
Why This Calendar Still Matters for Today's Buckeyes
The 2015 season changed how Urban Meyer approached his roster. It showed that having "two starting quarterbacks" usually means you have zero. It also highlighted the difficulty of the "complacency trap." When you're the defending champ and everyone tells you how great you are, the edge starts to dull.
If you look at the ohio state football calendar 2015, you see a team that was bored for two months and then panicked when things got real. It’s a lesson that Ryan Day and future coaches still have to manage. You can't just "show up" with five-star recruits and expect the scoreboard to do the work for you.
👉 See also: Why Funny Fantasy Football Names Actually Win Leagues
Actionable Takeaways from the 2015 Season Analysis
If you're a die-hard looking back or a sports historian trying to understand why that team didn't repeat, here are the three things you need to remember about the ohio state football calendar 2015:
- The Schedule Trap: The lack of a Top 25 opponent in September and October allowed bad habits to form. Without a "litmus test" early on, the Buckeyes didn't realize their offensive identity was broken until it was too late to fix it for the Michigan State game.
- The QB Conflict: Don't believe the hype about "platoon" systems. The constant switching between Cardale Jones and J.T. Barrett prevented the wide receivers—including future NFL star Michael Thomas—from ever getting into a consistent rhythm with their passer.
- The "Zeke" Lesson: In high-stakes November games, you feed your best player. The 12-carry anomaly against MSU remains one of the biggest "what-if" coaching decisions in Big Ten history.
The 2015 Buckeyes were arguably more talented than the 2014 championship team. They just ran out of time. If you want to dive deeper into the stats, go look at the defensive numbers from that year—the unit only gave up more than 20 points three times. They were elite. They just needed an offense that knew who it was before the rain started falling in late November.
To truly understand the 2015 season, you have to look at it as a bridge between the old-school power football Meyer loved and the high-flying spread systems that would eventually define the late 2010s. It was a year of transition, tension, and immense talent that ultimately fell one field goal short of a dynasty.
To apply these insights today, watch how modern coaches handle "quarterback battles" in the spring. If a starter isn't named by the end of fall camp, the 2015 season tells us that a mid-season collapse is almost inevitable. True success requires a clear hierarchy and a schedule that tests a team before the stakes become "win or go home."