It was weird.
If you grew up in the Tri-State area during the early 2000s, you probably remember the black-and-purple jerseys. You remember the "He Hate Me" jerseys from the Las Vegas Outlaws, sure, but for local fans, it was all about the New York New Jersey Hitmen. This wasn't just another football team. It was a chaotic, short-lived experiment that tried to blend the gritty reality of North Jersey with the theatrical absurdity of the WWE.
Honestly, it shouldn't have worked. And in many ways, it didn't.
But looking back at the 2001 XFL season, the Hitmen occupied a specific, strange corner of sports history that people are still obsessed with today. They played at Giants Stadium. They were coached by a guy who looked like he’d rather be anywhere else. And they represented a version of New York sports that was unapologetically loud, even when the scoreboard didn't justify the noise.
The Identity Crisis of the New York New Jersey Hitmen
Vince McMahon wanted "Smashmouth" football. He wanted the New York New Jersey Hitmen to embody the toughness of a construction site in Newark. The logo was literally a silhouette of a guy in a trench coat and fedora—which, let’s be real, felt more like a 1940s mob movie than a modern sports franchise.
Marketing was everything back then. The XFL wasn't competing with the NFL; it was trying to be the "cool older brother" who stayed out late and got into fights.
But here’s the thing: while the marketing promised carnage, the actual product was often just... messy. The Hitmen struggled early on. They lost their first three games. Fans in East Rutherford weren't exactly known for their patience, and they let the team hear it. It’s kinda funny to think about now, but the league actually had to dial back the "attitude" because the quality of play was so erratic.
🔗 Read more: Who Won the Golf Tournament This Weekend: Richard T. Lee and the 2026 Season Kickoff
The roster was a fascinating mix. You had guys like Charles Puleri, who struggled at quarterback before being replaced by Wally Richardson. You had players who were NFL castoffs, CFL stars, and young guys just trying to stay relevant. It wasn't "bad" football in the way people remember it, but it certainly wasn't the polished product fans were used to seeing on Sunday afternoons.
Rusty Tillman and the Conflict with NBC
If you want to understand the New York New Jersey Hitmen, you have to talk about Rusty Tillman.
Tillman was a traditional football guy. He was a longtime NFL special teams coach who didn't care about "sports entertainment." This created a massive problem for the XFL’s producers. During the broadcasts, the announcers—specifically Jesse "The Body" Ventura—would openly criticize Tillman’s conservative coaching style.
Ventura would be up in the booth calling Tillman a "wuss" or a "coward" for punting on fourth down. It was bizarre.
"I’m not a cheerleader, I’m a football coach." — Rusty Tillman (often cited as his unofficial mantra during that 2001 season).
This tension between the league's desire for drama and Tillman’s desire for fundamental football defined the Hitmen's existence. It was a clash of cultures. On one side, you had the WWE-style hype machine. On the other, you had a coach trying to win games 10-6.
💡 You might also like: The Truth About the Memphis Grizzlies Record 2025: Why the Standings Don't Tell the Whole Story
The Atmosphere at Giants Stadium
Imagine a cold Saturday night in February in New Jersey. The wind is whipping through the Meadowlands. You’re sitting in a massive stadium that feels mostly empty because, while the Hitmen had decent attendance for the XFL (averaging about 28,000 fans), it was still rattling around in a venue built for 80,000.
The fans who did show up were exactly who you’d expect.
They were loud. They were skeptical. They wore the merchandise because it looked cool, not necessarily because they believed in the team’s playoff hopes. The "Hitmen" name was controversial from the jump—mostly because of the obvious mob connotations—but in North Jersey, that kind of notoriety was a badge of honor.
Interestingly, the New York New Jersey Hitmen actually started to get good toward the end of the season. They won three of their last five games. By the time they figured out how to move the ball, the league was already hemorrhaging money and losing its TV deal with NBC.
Why the Hitmen Brand Still Sells
Go on eBay right now. Search for an original 2001 New York New Jersey Hitmen jersey.
They aren't cheap.
📖 Related: The Division 2 National Championship Game: How Ferris State Just Redrew the Record Books
The "dead" brand of the Hitmen has actually outlasted the team’s on-field record. People love the aesthetic. The combination of black, purple, and silver was ahead of its time for sports branding. It was aggressive. It looked like something out of a comic book.
Moreover, there’s a deep nostalgia for the "Wild West" era of sports. This was before every league was hyper-sanitized. This was when a cameraman would run onto the field during a play to get a "Cooler" angle. This was when the New York New Jersey Hitmen could exist without being a billion-dollar corporate entity.
Lessons from the Hitmen's Failure
The XFL folded after just one season (the first time around). Most people blame the football, but that’s not entirely fair. The football was fine by the end. The real failure was the expectations.
- The league promised "extreme" action but delivered a sport where the rules were mostly the same as the NFL.
- The crossover with wrestling fans didn't happen as smoothly as Vince McMahon anticipated.
- The New York market is notoriously hard to break into if you aren't winning immediately.
The New York New Jersey Hitmen were caught in the middle of these issues. They weren't "pro-wrestling" enough for the WWE fans, and they weren't "pro-football" enough for the Giants/Jets fans.
What We Learned from the Meadowlands Experiment
If you’re a sports marketing nerd or just someone who misses the 2000s, the Hitmen story is a masterclass in what happens when you prioritize "vibes" over "infrastructure."
The team's legacy isn't about stats. Nobody remembers how many yards Wally Richardson threw for (it was 801, by the way). People remember the feeling of that era. They remember the pyrotechnics. They remember the feeling that, for one weird year, New Jersey had a team that didn't care about being "prestigious."
Actionable Takeaways for Modern Spring Leagues
- Identity is everything. The Hitmen had a name that resonated with the local "tough guy" culture, even if it was a bit cliché. Modern teams in the UFL or USFL should lean into local grit rather than generic names like "The Defenders."
- Don't fight your own talent. The feud between the broadcast booth and Rusty Tillman was funny for a week, but it ultimately made the team look like a joke. Alignment between the league's message and the coaches' reality is crucial.
- Merchandise is the long game. The fact that people still wear Hitmen hats 25 years later proves that if you design a "cool" brand, it can survive even if the team doesn't.
The New York New Jersey Hitmen were a flash in the pan. A weird, loud, slightly confusing flash in the pan. But in the history of New York sports, they remain one of the most interesting "what if" stories ever told. They were the team that tried to make the Meadowlands feel like a backyard brawl, and for a few Saturday nights in 2001, they actually succeeded.
To dive deeper into the rosters and game logs of this era, check out the archives at XFLBoard or the historical databases on StatsCrew, which keep the specific play-by-play data of the 2001 season alive. If you’re lucky enough to find an old "Tillman" or "Richardson" jersey at a thrift store, buy it. You're holding a piece of the strangest season in football history.