Imagine someone digging up your bathroom in four thousand years. They find a plastic seat, a porcelain bowl, and a roll of white paper. They don't see a toilet. No, they see a "Sacred Urn" used for ceremonial washing, and that white paper? It’s obviously "parchment for recording holy thoughts."
That is the hilarious, slightly uncomfortable premise of David Macaulay’s Motel of Mysteries book. It was published back in 1979, but honestly, it feels more relevant now than ever. We live in an era of "curated" history, where we constantly guess what ancient people were thinking based on a few shards of pottery. Macaulay flips the script. He asks: what if we are the "ancients" and the people of the year 4022 get everything spectacularly wrong?
The story follows Howard Carson, an amateur archaeologist in the year 4022. He accidentally falls through a shaft and discovers "Tomb 26"—which is actually just a room at a generic American motel.
The Brilliant Satire of Archaeology
Archaeology is usually seen as this noble, exact science. We trust the experts when they tell us a stone circle was a calendar or a carved figure was a fertility goddess. But Macaulay suggests that maybe, just maybe, archaeologists are just making very educated guesses that could be totally off-base.
In the Motel of Mysteries book, Carson finds a "Do Not Disturb" sign hanging on a door handle. Does he think it's a sign for privacy? Of course not. To him, it’s a sacred seal intended to ward off evil spirits from the burial chamber. It’s a genius bit of satire. It mocks the human tendency to over-intellectualize things we don't understand. We want everything to have a deep, spiritual meaning. Sometimes, a sign is just a sign.
The book is filled with these "re-interpretations." A television set becomes a "Great Altar," and the remote control is a "sacred obliterator" used to change the images on the altar's face. If you've ever looked at a museum exhibit and wondered if the curators were just winging it, this book is for you.
📖 Related: Isaiah Washington Movies and Shows: Why the Star Still Matters
Why the Art Still Holds Up
Macaulay is a master of architectural drawing. You might know him from The Way Things Work or Cathedral. His style is precise, detailed, and black-and-white. This works perfectly for the Motel of Mysteries book because the "scientific" nature of the drawings makes the absurdity even funnier.
He draws a toilet with the same reverence and technical detail that a scholar would use to document the Parthenon. There's a specific illustration of the "Internal Components of the Sacred Urn" (the toilet tank) that is legitimately beautiful. The contrast between the high-brow art style and the low-brow subject matter—a suburban motel—is where the comedy lives.
It’s a quick read, but you’ll spend more time staring at the drawings than reading the text. You start looking for the little details. The way the "Body" (a skeleton in a bathtub) is positioned. The "Sacred Pointed Cap" which is actually just a sanitized paper strip on the toilet seat. It’s a masterclass in visual storytelling.
The Legend of the "Great Toilet Paper Shortage"
In the world of 4022, the North American civilization (dubbed "the Us") came to an end in 1985 because of a mysterious "catastrophe." Macaulay implies it was an overwhelming amount of junk mail and pollution. It's a bit of a 1970s environmentalist trope, sure. But in a post-2020 world, the idea of a society collapsing under the weight of its own consumption hits a little different.
When Carson finds the bathroom—or the "Inner Chamber"—he treats every item as a religious artifact. He wears the toilet seat around his neck like a ceremonial collar. It's absurd. It's ridiculous. But it also makes you think about the objects you use every day. If your house was buried tomorrow, what would people think of your air fryer? Or your Ring doorbell?
👉 See also: Temuera Morrison as Boba Fett: Why Fans Are Still Divided Over the Daimyo of Tatooine
Misinterpreting the "Us" Civilization
One of the most famous bits in the Motel of Mysteries book is the "Headband of the Gods." Carson finds a woman’s skeleton wearing plastic hair rollers. He concludes these were symbols of high status, possibly used to amplify telepathic signals.
It's a jab at how we view the Egyptians or the Mayans. We see their elaborate headpieces and assume they were all about ritual and gods. Macaulay reminds us that maybe they were just trying to look good for a party. Or maybe it was just a practical solution to a mundane problem.
- The Television: "The Great Altar."
- The Remote: "The Sacred Command."
- The Bathtub: "The Sarcophagus."
- The Shower Curtain: "The Translucent Veil."
The logic is airtight, which is the scary part. If you didn't know what a motel was, Carson’s explanations would actually make a lot of sense. Everything is consistent. It’s a closed loop of wrongness.
The Cultural Impact of Howard Carson
While the book is a parody, it’s actually used in real archaeology and anthropology classrooms. Professors assign the Motel of Mysteries book to teach students about "interpretive bias." It’s a tool to remind future scientists that their own cultural lens can distort the truth.
It teaches humility.
✨ Don't miss: Why Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy Actors Still Define the Modern Spy Thriller
When we look at the past, we are looking through a mirror. We see our own preoccupations. If we are obsessed with religion, we see temples. If we are obsessed with war, we see fortifications. Macaulay shows us that if a future society is obsessed with ritual, they will see a Howard Johnson’s as a cathedral.
Honestly, the book is a bit cynical, but in a lighthearted way. It suggests that history is a game of telephone played over thousands of years. The message gets garbled. The "truth" is lost, replaced by a narrative that fits the current era's worldview.
Is it still worth reading?
Absolutely. Especially since we are now living in the "future" that Macaulay was sort of hinting at. We are more surrounded by disposable plastic junk than the people of 1979 ever were. Our "tombs" will be even more confusing to Howard Carson. Imagine him trying to explain an iPhone or a fidget spinner.
The book is out of print sometimes, but you can usually find used copies or library editions. It’s a staple of school libraries for a reason. It’s one of those rare books that makes you laugh and then makes you sit quietly and look at your sink for five minutes.
How to Approach the Book Today
If you’re picking up the Motel of Mysteries book for the first time, don’t rush it. Treat it like a real archaeological report. Look at the diagrams. Read the captions carefully.
The real magic is in the deadpan delivery. Macaulay never winks at the camera. He stays in character as the future historian the entire time. That commitment to the bit is what makes it a classic.
Actionable Steps for the Curious Reader
- Check your local library's "Graphic Novel" or "Architecture" section. Surprisingly, it's often shelved in weird places because librarians don't know if it's a kids' book, a comic, or a serious art book.
- Compare it to modern "ruin porn." Look at photos of abandoned malls or theme parks today. Notice how we already romanticize these places, much like Howard Carson did with his motel room.
- Try the "Carson Exercise." Pick up a random object in your kitchen—a garlic press or a whisk. Try to explain its "ceremonial purpose" to someone who has never seen one. It’s harder than it looks to stay logical.
- Look for Macaulay’s other work. If you enjoy the style, Black and White is another mind-bender that plays with perspective and narrative in a similar way.
The Motel of Mysteries book isn't just a parody of the discovery of King Tut's tomb (though it definitely is that, specifically referencing Howard Carter). It’s a mirror held up to our own vanity. We think we’re so important that our trash will be studied as treasure. And the joke is, we’re probably right. But not for the reasons we think.