September 1, 2007. It was supposed to be a coronation. Michigan was ranked No. 5 in the country, boasting a roster dripping with future NFL talent like Chad Henne, Mike Hart, and Jake Long. They paid Appalachian State—a Division I-AA (now FCS) school from Boone, North Carolina—a cool $400,000 just to show up and lose. Everyone in Ann Arbor expected a blowout. Instead, they got a seismic shift that fundamentally broke college football’s hierarchy.
It wasn't just a win. It was a 34-32 reality check.
Most people remember the blocked field goal at the buzzer, but they forget how dominant the Mountaineers actually looked for long stretches of that game. This wasn't a fluke. It wasn't a series of lucky bounces. Appalachian State outplayed Michigan. They were faster. Their spread offense, led by the electric Armanti Edwards, turned the Wolverines' massive defensive line into statues.
The Anatomy of the Michigan Appalachian State 2007 Disaster
Michigan fans still wince at the name Corey Lynch. But before Lynch blocked that final kick, the game was a masterclass in coaching philosophy. Lloyd Carr, Michigan's legendary coach, was a "three yards and a cloud of dust" guy. He liked big bodies. He liked tradition. Jerry Moore, the Mountaineers' coach, brought something Michigan hadn't prepared for: pure, unadulterated speed.
App State's offense was built on the "spread," a scheme that was still considered a bit of a gimmick by the Big Ten elite in 2007. By the time Michigan realized they couldn't catch Edwards or Dexter Jackson, the Mountaineers were already up 28-17 at halftime. The Big House went silent. You could feel the confusion through the television screen.
Honestly, the sheer talent on that Michigan roster makes the loss even more baffling today. You’re talking about a team that would go on to beat Tim Tebow’s Florida Gators in a bowl game later that season. They weren't bad. They were just caught in a prehistoric defensive mindset against a team that was living in the future.
👉 See also: LeBron James Without Beard: Why the King Rarely Goes Clean Shaven Anymore
Why the AP Poll Had to Change
Before this specific Saturday, the Associated Press (AP) had a rule. No lower-division team could receive votes in the Top 25 poll. Period. But after Appalachian State walked into one of the most hostile environments in sports and emerged victorious, the AP had to cave. They changed the rule immediately. The Mountaineers became the first FCS team to ever receive votes in the AP Poll.
It changed the math. Suddenly, the "guarantee games"—those early-season matchups where big schools pay small schools for an easy win—didn't feel so guaranteed. Athletic directors across the country started looking at their schedules with a new kind of anxiety. If it could happen to Michigan, it could happen to anyone.
The Blocked Kick Heard 'Round the World
Let’s talk about that final minute. Michigan had actually clawed their way back. Mike Hart, arguably one of the best running backs in school history, scored to put Michigan up 32-31 with less than five minutes left. It felt like order had been restored. But Armanti Edwards didn't care about the script. He marched the Mountaineers down the field to set up a Julian Rauch field goal. 26 yards. Right through the uprights.
App State led 34-32 with 26 seconds left.
Then came the drama. Chad Henne, a four-year starter, threw a bomb to Mario Manningham. It was a beautiful catch. Suddenly, Michigan was at the App State 20-yard line. With six seconds left, Jason Gingell stepped up for a 37-yard field goal. It was a chip shot. The stadium held its breath.
✨ Don't miss: When is Georgia's next game: The 2026 Bulldog schedule and what to expect
Corey Lynch didn't just block the kick. He scooped it up and started sprinting the other way. He didn't make it to the end zone, but it didn't matter. The clock hit zero. The image of those white jerseys celebrating on the block 'M' at midfield is burned into the collective memory of every sports fan who was alive to see it.
The Fallout for Lloyd Carr and the Program
This game was basically the beginning of the end for the Lloyd Carr era. While he stayed through the end of the season, the aura of Michigan football was permanently dented. The loss exposed a lack of adaptation. The program spent the next decade trying to find its identity, cycling through Rich Rodriguez and Brady Hoke before Jim Harbaugh finally stabilized the ship years later.
It's kinda wild to think about how much one afternoon influenced coaching hires. Teams started looking for "innovators" instead of "program builders." The spread offense became the standard, not the exception.
The Mountaineer Legacy
For Appalachian State, this wasn't just a lucky break. They were in the middle of a dynasty. They won three consecutive national championships in their division from 2005 to 2007. They were, quite literally, the best team in the country that nobody was talking about.
- Armanti Edwards: Finished with 222 passing yards and 62 rushing yards.
- Dexter Jackson: Two touchdowns and a highlight reel that would make most NFL receivers jealous.
- The Defense: They were undersized, but they played with a chip on their shoulders that Michigan simply couldn't match.
People often ask if this is the greatest upset in sports history. In terms of the betting line (Michigan was a 33-point favorite) and the sheer prestige of the loser, it’s hard to find anything that tops it. It wasn't just a win for App State; it was a win for every small school that ever felt overlooked.
🔗 Read more: Vince Carter Meme I Got One More: The Story Behind the Internet's Favorite Comeback
Lessons for Modern Programs
Looking back at the Michigan Appalachian State 2007 box score, a few things stand out that still apply today. First, never underestimate a mobile quarterback. Michigan’s defense was designed to stop the run between the tackles, but they had no answer for a quarterback who could extend plays.
Second, the psychological pressure on a "favorite" is real. You could see the Michigan players tightening up as the game stayed close. They were playing not to lose, while App State was playing to win. There is a massive difference in those two mindsets.
If you're a coach or an athlete today, the "App State Game" is the ultimate cautionary tale. It's the reason why Nick Saban used to scream about "rat poison"—the idea that the media telling you how good you are is a trap. Michigan drank the Kool-Aid in 2007. They paid the price.
What You Should Do Next
If you want to truly understand the impact of this game beyond just the highlights, there are a few things worth exploring.
- Watch the full game replay: Don't just watch the blocked kick. Watch the first two quarters. See how App State's offensive line actually moved Michigan's future NFL defensive tackles.
- Research the 2007 season: This was arguably the most chaotic year in college football history. It featured "The Curse of No. 2" where top-ranked teams fell week after week. The Michigan loss was just the opening act.
- Compare the rosters: Look at the NFL careers of the 2007 Michigan starters versus the App State starters. It reinforces the idea that on any given Saturday, scheme and heart can overcome raw talent.
The 2007 upset wasn't a tragedy for football; it was a gift. It proved that the giants are vulnerable and that the "little guys" belong on the big stage. Every time an unranked team walks into a stadium full of 100,000 screaming fans today, they do it knowing that what happened in Ann Arbor is possible.
To apply this to your own sports analysis, start looking for teams with high-efficiency spread offenses going up against traditional, heavy-set defenses. The "speed gap" is still the most common way upsets happen in the modern era. Keep an eye on the Sun Belt and MAC teams during the early weeks of the season—they're the spiritual successors to that 2007 Mountaineer squad.
Next Steps for Deep Diving:
- Analyze the "Spread Revolution": Research how coaches like Rich Rodriguez and Chip Kelly utilized the same concepts Jerry Moore used to dismantle Michigan.
- Review the 2007 AP Poll History: See how the "App State Rule" changed the way FCS teams are perceived in national rankings.
- Follow the Mountaineers today: Appalachian State successfully transitioned to the FBS and remains one of the most consistent programs in the country, proving 2007 was a foundation, not a fluke.