Finding a decent seat on the Upper West Side during a rainy Tuesday shouldn't be a mission. Yet, here we are. If you’ve spent any time walking up Amsterdam Avenue, you know the vibe changes block by block. Some spots feel like they’re trying too hard to be downtown cool, while others are basically cafeterias for the stroller set. Then there’s the Mermaid Inn NYC Upper West Side. It’s been a staple for years, but honestly, it’s one of those places that people sort of take for granted until they’re craving a very specific kind of oyster happy hour.
It’s cozy. It’s loud in a good way. It feels like a Cape Cod escape dropped right into a Manhattan zip code.
The Mermaid Inn has lived a few lives. If you’re a long-time local, you might remember their previous spot on Amsterdam. They moved. They expanded. They weathered the absolute chaos of the 2020s restaurant scene. Now located at 335 Columbus Avenue, the "new" space is bigger than the original hole-in-the-wall, but it managed to keep that nautical, weathered-shingle charm without feeling like a theme park. It’s a delicate balance.
The Happy Hour That Basically Built the Neighborhood
Let’s be real. Most people talk about the Mermaid Inn NYC Upper West Side because of the happy hour. It’s legendary for a reason.
While other places are charging $18 for a mediocre cocktail and $4 per oyster, Mermaid Inn keeps it accessible. They generally run it from 4:30 PM to 6:30 PM. It’s the kind of deal where you see people hovering near the door at 4:25 like they’re waiting for a concert to start. You get the East Coast oysters—usually chef's choice—for a price that actually lets you order a dozen without checking your bank balance first.
But it's not just the price.
It's the atmosphere of the happy hour. You've got Columbia professors arguing about tenure next to young couples on a first date trying to look sophisticated while slurping shells. The staff doesn't treat you like a second-class citizen just because you're ordering the "cheap" stuff. That matters. The house wines and the "Mermaid Mary" are solid, but honestly, the Fish Tacos are the sleeper hit of the small plates menu. They’re blackened, served with a crunchy slaw, and they have just enough kick to make you order another beer.
🔗 Read more: Monroe Central High School Ohio: What Local Families Actually Need to Know
What Most People Miss About the Menu
Beyond the raw bar, there's a lot of technical skill in the kitchen that gets overshadowed by the "seafood shack" branding. Danny Abrams and Cindy Smith, the owners, have been in this game a long time. They know that to survive on the UWS, you need consistency. You can't just have a gimmick.
Take the Lobster Roll. Every place in NYC claims to have the "best" or the "most authentic." Mermaid Inn does it "Mermaid Style." It’s served on a toasted brioche bun with just enough mayo to coat the lobster, not drown it. It comes with these thin, salty fries that are dangerously addictive. Is it the cheapest lobster roll in the city? No. But it’s consistent. You know exactly what you’re getting every single time you sit down.
The Signature Touches
- The Salmon Tartare: It’s usually served with a bit of avocado and some crispy wonton-style chips. It’s light.
- The Calamari: Not that rubbery stuff you find at a diner. It’s crisp, seasoned well, and usually comes with a spicy tomato sauce.
- Old Bay Fries: Seriously, don't skip these.
Then there’s the "Chocolate Pudding." At the end of every meal, they bring out a tiny little cup of chocolate pudding with a fortune telling fish. It’s a gimmick, sure. But it’s a good gimmick. It’s that little bit of "extra" that makes the Mermaid Inn NYC Upper West Side feel like a neighborhood spot rather than a corporate chain. It’s these small, tactile memories—the way the red plastic fish curls in your palm to tell your fortune—that keep people coming back for a decade.
The Layout: Surviving the UWS Rush
The Columbus Avenue location is a significant upgrade in terms of sheer elbow room. The old spot was charming but, man, it was tight. You were basically dining with the people at the table next to you. The current space has a much better flow. There’s a massive bar area which is perfect if you’re flying solo or just want a quick drink and a snack.
The back dining room is a bit more "serious." It’s got these deep booths and soft lighting that makes everyone look better than they actually do after a long day at the office.
Knowing When to Go
If you show up at 7:00 PM on a Friday without a reservation, you’re going to be waiting. A long time. The UWS crowd is loyal and they move in packs.
💡 You might also like: What Does a Stoner Mean? Why the Answer Is Changing in 2026
However, if you can swing a late lunch or a "shoulder hour" meal around 3:00 PM on a weekend, the place is a dream. It’s quiet enough to actually hear your companion talk, and the light coming through the front windows is fantastic. It’s one of the few places in the area that feels equally appropriate for a "I don't want to cook tonight" Monday and a "Let's celebrate your promotion" Thursday.
Addressing the "Is It Too Touristy?" Question
People ask this a lot about any successful NYC restaurant. Because the Mermaid Inn has locations in Chelsea and the East Village (and has had others over the years), some purists think it’s lost its soul.
They’re wrong.
The Mermaid Inn NYC Upper West Side feels distinctively Upper West Side. It’s tailored to the demographic. You’ll see grandmothers taking their grandkids for their first taste of a clam strip. You’ll see the local "power brokers" in zip-up vests talking shop. It hasn't become a tourist trap because it relies so heavily on the people who live within a ten-block radius. The staff recognizes regulars. That’s the litmus test for any real NYC institution.
Technical Excellence in Seafood
Seafood is hard. It’s expensive to source, it spoils fast, and people are incredibly picky about it. The Mermaid Inn manages its supply chain brilliantly. The oysters are fresh—you can taste the brine, the liquor is clear, and they’re shucked cleanly. No shell fragments. That sounds like a low bar, but you’d be surprised how many mid-range seafood spots fail at basic shucking.
The menu also evolves. While the staples (like the Linguine with Clams) stay put, they rotate fish specials based on what’s actually good at the market. They aren't trying to serve you out-of-season swordfish just because it's on the printed menu.
📖 Related: Am I Gay Buzzfeed Quizzes and the Quest for Identity Online
Why the UWS Location Just Works
The Upper West Side can be a weird neighborhood for food. It’s either incredibly high-end (think Jean-Georges) or it’s a sea of unremarkable bagel shops and mediocre Italian joints. There isn't a lot of "middle ground" that feels special.
The Mermaid Inn NYC Upper West Side fills that gap perfectly. It’s "attainable luxury." You feel like you’re treating yourself, but you don't feel like you're being ripped off. The price point is fair for the quality of the ingredients and the prime real estate.
Actionable Tips for Your Visit
If you're planning to head over, don't just wing it. A little strategy goes a long way in Manhattan dining.
- Use the Resy App: They use Resy for bookings. Check it early in the week. If it looks full, try the "Notify Me" feature—cancellations happen all the time, especially on weeknights.
- The Bar is First-Come, First-Served: If you’re solo or a duo, skip the host stand and look for an opening at the bar. You get the full menu there and usually much faster service.
- Order the "Near & Far": This is their signature oyster sampler. It gives you a mix of East and West Coast varieties. It’s the best way to understand the flavor profiles if you aren’t an oyster geek.
- Mind the Noise: If you’re looking for a whisper-quiet romantic spot for a proposal, this might not be it during peak hours. It gets buzzy. It’s energetic.
- Check the Daily Specials: They often have a "Catch of the Day" that isn't on the main menu. Ask the server. Sometimes it’s a whole roasted fish that is significantly better than the standard entrees.
The Mermaid Inn has survived the test of time because it doesn't try to reinvent the wheel. It just gives people what they want: fresh seafood, cold drinks, and a place that feels like home. Whether you're a local or just passing through after a trip to the Museum of Natural History, it’s a reliable, high-quality choice that reminds you why we live in this crazy city in the first place.
Final Practical Takeaways
- Address: 335 Columbus Ave, New York, NY 10023.
- Best For: Happy Hour, casual dates, and family dinners with older kids.
- Price Range: $$to$$$ (depending on how many oysters you knock back).
- Pro Move: Get the "Grand Platter" if you’re with a group of four. It’s a showstopper and actually ends up being a decent value for the amount of shellfish you get.
Don't overthink it. Just go. Grab a stool, order a dozen, and enjoy the fact that for an hour or two, you’re exactly where you need to be.