You’re driving home, some random song comes on the radio, and suddenly you’re back in 2017. It’s a physical weight in your chest. That specific person—the one who felt like the "click" but somehow slipped through your fingers—is back. We call him the man that got away, a phrase that carries a weirdly heavy amount of cultural baggage. It’s romantic. It’s tragic. It’s also, quite often, a total lie our brains tell us to avoid dealing with the messy reality of our current lives.
Why do we do this?
Psychology suggests it isn’t usually about the person themselves. Honestly, if you were with them right now, you’d probably be arguing about whose turn it is to take out the trash or why they never text back in a reasonable timeframe. But since they aren't here, they stay frozen in time. They’re a museum exhibit of "what if," and that makes them impossible to compete with for any real-world partner.
The Zeigarnik Effect: Why Your Brain Won't Let Go
Blame Bluma Zeigarnik. She was a Soviet psychologist who noticed something weird in a Vienna restaurant back in the 1920s. Waiters could remember complex, unpaid orders perfectly, but the second the bill was settled, the information vanished from their heads. This is the Zeigarnik Effect. Our brains are hardwired to obsess over unfinished tasks.
📖 Related: What's Open Good Friday: The Truth About Store Closings and Services
The man that got away is the ultimate unpaid bill.
Because the relationship didn’t reach a natural "expiration date"—where you both realized you actually hate how the other person chews or realized your values are totally misaligned—it feels unfinished. You didn't get the "the end" credits. You got a "to be continued" that never actually continued. This creates a cognitive loop. Your brain keeps scanning for a resolution that isn't coming, which keeps the emotional wound fresh, even years later.
Romanticizing the Ghost
We tend to filter out the bad stuff. It’s called "rosy retrospection." You remember the way he looked in that one specific light at that one specific concert, but you conveniently forget the three hours he spent ignoring you to talk to his friends.
When people talk about the man that got away, they’re usually talking about a version of a person that doesn't actually exist. They’re talking about a projection. Dr. Helen Fisher, a biological anthropologist who has spent decades studying the brain in love, found that rejection can actually trigger the same parts of the brain associated with physical pain and addiction. We literally crave the person more because they are unavailable. It’s a dopamine trap.
Think about the timing. Usually, these "got away" stories happen during transitional periods—college, right after a big move, or during a "wild" era. The person becomes a symbol of that time in your life. You don’t just miss him; you miss who you were when you were with him.
The Danger of the "One Who Got Away" Narrative
There's a real cost to keeping this ghost around. It’s a safety mechanism. If you’re busy pining for someone from your past, you don’t have to be fully vulnerable with the person sitting across from you at dinner tonight. It’s a way to keep one foot out the door.
Relationship expert and author Logan Ury, who wrote How to Not Die Alone, often discusses how "The One" is a destructive myth. If you believe there is only one person meant for you and they "got away," you’ve basically decided your romantic life is over. That’s a heavy burden to put on a memory. It prevents you from seeing the value in "The One Who Is Right Here."
Real Talk: Was He Really That Great?
Let's look at the facts. If he was truly the perfect match, he wouldn’t have "gotten away." Relationships that are meant to work require two people who are both capable and willing to stay. If one person left, or if circumstances made it impossible, then the "fit" wasn't as perfect as you remember.
- Circumstance is part of compatibility. If you wanted different things, you weren't compatible.
- Distance is a factor. If neither of you would move, the relationship wasn't the priority.
- Timing is a pillar. If the timing was wrong, the relationship was wrong.
How to Finally Close the File
You have to stop feeding the ghost. Every time you check his Instagram or ask a mutual friend how he’s doing, you’re hitting the "reset" button on your healing. You’re keeping the Zeigarnik loop open.
- De-mythologize him. Write a list of every annoying thing he ever did. The time he was late. The way he was rude to a waiter. The fact that he didn't choose you. Read it when you start feeling nostalgic.
- Accept the Lack of Closure. Closure is something you give yourself; it’s not something you get from someone else. You don't need a final conversation. The fact that it ended is the message.
- Audit Your Current Satisfaction. Often, we focus on the man that got away when we are bored or unhappy in our current situation. Are you using him as an escape? Address the boredom in your present instead of seeking refuge in the past.
- Change the Narrative. He isn't the "man that got away." He’s the man you had a great chapter with, and that chapter ended so a better one could start.
The "what if" is a fantasy world where everything is perfect because it isn't real. Real love is messy, it's boring sometimes, and it shows up every day. A ghost can't do that. A memory can't hold your hand at a funeral or tell you that your hair looks fine when it clearly doesn't.
Stop looking in the rearview mirror. You’re going to hit something in front of you. The most important person in your romantic history isn't the one who left—it's the one who stays, or the one you are becoming while you're single. Honor the memory for what it was, then let it go so you can actually be present for your own life.