You’re driving down Main Street. The elm trees are heavy with leaves, and the air starts to smell like salt and expensive hedge trimmings. Then you see it. The white pickets. The big, wraparound porch. Most people call it the Maidstone Inn in East Hampton, though the sign out front technically says The Maidstone Hotel these days. Honestly, it doesn't matter what you call it. What matters is that it’s one of the few places left in the Hamptons that hasn't been scrubbed of its soul by corporate minimalism.
It's old. Like, 19th-century old.
While the rest of the East End is busy turning into a sea of beige linen and "quiet luxury" that feels more like a hospital ward than a vacation, the Maidstone stays weird. In a good way. It’s got this DNA that mixes classic American Shingle-style architecture with a heavy dose of Scandinavian design, thanks to owner Jenny Ljungberg’s influence over the years. You walk in and see taxidermy next to high-end photography. It's a vibe.
The Reality of Staying at the Maidstone Inn in East Hampton
Let’s get the elephant out of the room first: parking is a nightmare. If you’re coming from the city on a Friday afternoon, expect to circle the block or hand your keys over and just pray. But once you’re inside, the chaos of the 27 fades. The Maidstone isn't a massive resort. It has 19 rooms. That’s it. That small scale is why people get obsessed with it. You aren't "Guest in 402." You’re the person who likes the specific Swedish roast coffee in the morning.
The rooms are named after famous Scandinavians. Think Hans Christian Andersen or Roald Amundsen. It’s not just a name on a plaque, either. Each room is actually designed to reflect that person’s life or work. It’s quirky. Sometimes the floors creak. If you’re looking for a soundproof, hermetically sealed glass box, go to a Marriott. You come here because you want to feel like you’re staying in the guest wing of a very wealthy, very eccentric aunt’s coastal estate.
Most rooms come with Hästens beds. If you know, you know. These are the blue-checkered mattresses that cost more than a mid-sized sedan. They are made of horsehair and magic. You will probably oversleep. You will definitely miss your yoga class at the beach. And honestly? That’s sort of the point of being here.
👉 See also: Flights from San Diego to New Jersey: What Most People Get Wrong
That Porch and the Social Gravity of Main Street
The porch is the heart of the property. It’s the best people-watching spot in the world. Period. You sit there with a glass of rosé—usually a Sancerre or something local from Wölffer—and watch the parade of Range Rovers and vintage Defenders crawl toward the beach.
It’s public but private.
There’s a specific kind of magic in the late afternoon when the light hits the white wood. The hotel provides these colorful Adirondack chairs on the lawn. You’ll see kids running around, dogs lounging (the place is famously pet-friendly, arguably the most pet-friendly spot in the village), and deals being made over oysters. It’s the Hamptons at its most authentic. It isn't trying too hard. It just is.
What About the Food?
The restaurant situation at the Maidstone Inn in East Hampton has flipped a few times over the last decade. Recently, they’ve leaned into the "L’Avenue at Saks" partnership, bringing a bit of that French-Italian flair to the garden. The menu usually hits the hits: spicy tuna tartare, some version of a truffle pasta, and local fish that was probably swimming in the Atlantic six hours ago.
Is it expensive? Yes.
✨ Don't miss: Woman on a Plane: What the Viral Trends and Real Travel Stats Actually Tell Us
Is it worth it? When you're sitting in the garden under the string lights, and the humidity has finally dropped, you won't care about the price of the frites. The service is typically "Hamptons casual," which is code for "it might take a minute, but everyone is very good-looking."
The Location Loophole
The real reason the Maidstone dominates the conversation is geography. You are steps away from Town Pond. You can walk to the Guild Hall or the Clinton Academy. But more importantly, you can walk to the beach. Well, it’s a long walk, maybe 15-20 minutes, but the hotel gives you beach passes and bikes.
In East Hampton, a beach pass is gold.
If you aren't staying at a place like this, getting onto Main Beach or Two Mile Hollow is a logistical crusade involving permits, shuttle buses, and a lot of swearing. At the Maidstone, they just hand you a bag with towels and a permit and send you on your way. It removes the friction from the weekend.
Misconceptions and the "Old Money" Myth
There’s this idea that you need to be a Vanderbilt to walk through the front door. Not true. While the price point is definitely "luxury," the atmosphere is surprisingly inclusive. You’ll see surfers who just finished a session at Ditch Plains sitting next to guys in bespoke suits.
🔗 Read more: Where to Actually See a Space Shuttle: Your Air and Space Museum Reality Check
The hotel has leaned away from the stuffy, velvet-rope vibe of the early 2000s. It’s more about "hygge" now—that Danish concept of coziness and soulfulness. They want you to kick your shoes off. Just make sure your socks don't have holes in them because, well, it is still East Hampton.
Common Questions People Ask
- Is it loud? It can be. It’s an old house. If there’s a wedding on the lawn, you’re going to hear the music. Ask for a room on the top floor if you’re a light sleeper.
- Can I bring my dog? Yes, and they actually treat the dog like a guest. They have "yappy hour" menus sometimes. It’s a whole thing.
- When should I go? Fall. September in East Hampton is the best kept secret. The water is still warm, the crowds are gone, and the Maidstone lowers its rates just enough to make you feel like you’re getting a deal.
Actionable Steps for Your Visit
If you’re planning a trip to the Maidstone Inn in East Hampton, don’t just wing it. The village is small and the demand is high.
Book the "Karin Larsson" room. It’s bright, airy, and arguably has the best vibe for a summer stay. If that’s gone, aim for any of the cottages if you want more privacy and a break from the main house chatter.
Secure your dinner reservation three weeks out. If you wait until you check in to ask for a table on the porch Friday night, you’ll be eating at 10:00 PM. Use Resy or just call the front desk directly—they often hold a few spots for in-house guests.
Utilize the bikes early. The hotel has a fleet of designer bicycles. They go fast. Grab one at 9:00 AM, ride down to Main Beach, and beat the heat. Don't forget to ask the staff for a packed lunch; they can usually put together a picnic that beats anything you'll find at a deli on the way.
Check the Guild Hall schedule. Since you’re right across the street, see what’s playing or showing. It’s one of the best cultural spots in the country, and you can literally walk home in three minutes after a show.
Walk the Town Pond path at dusk. It’s right across the street. The way the light hits the historic cemetery and the water is pure Americana. It’s the best free thing to do in the Hamptons and it’s right at your doorstep.