The 10/6 tag. You’ve seen it. It’s tucked into the brim of that oversized, slightly chaotic piece of headwear everyone wears at Halloween or cosplay conventions. But honestly, most people think that little slip of paper is just a price tag or some weird Alice in Wonderland nonsense. It isn't. It's actually a sizing instruction—ten shillings and sixpence. That’s the cost of the hat in pre-decimal British currency.
If you want to understand the mad hatter top hat, you have to look past the Disney cartoons and the Johnny Depp makeup. The hat isn't just a costume prop. It is a symbol of a very real, very grim occupational hazard that literally melted the brains of nineteenth-century tradesmen. We call it "madness," but back then, it was just the cost of doing business.
The Toxic Reality Behind the Felt
The phrase "mad as a hatter" didn't start with Lewis Carroll. He just popularized the aesthetic. The reality was much darker. Hatters in the 1800s used mercuric nitrate to turn cheap fur—usually rabbit or hare—into the smooth, matted felt used for high-end headgear. This process was called "carroting" because the mercury turned the fur a weird, sickly orange color.
Imagine breathing that in every day.
Working in poorly ventilated rooms, these craftsmen inhaled mercury vapors for twelve hours a day, six days a week. The mercury crossed the blood-brain barrier. It caused "erethism," a neurological disorder that basically destroyed a person's personality. They got the "hatter’s shakes." Their limbs would tremble uncontrollably. They became pathologically shy, prone to outbursts of anger, and suffered from hallucinations. When you see a mad hatter top hat today, you’re looking at a tribute to a group of people who were quite literally poisoned by their own craft.
It's kinda wild how we've turned a medical tragedy into a quirky fashion statement. But that’s history for you. It’s messy.
Why the Shape Matters
A classic mad hatter top hat is usually depicted as "flared." It’s wider at the top than at the base. This wasn't just a stylistic choice by the original illustrator, John Tenniel. It was a caricature of the exaggerated styles of the Victorian era. Real top hats were generally sleek, straight, and covered in silk plush. The Hatter’s hat was different because he was a "common" hatter—a tradesman. He wouldn't have been wearing the sleek, expensive silk versions worn by the aristocracy. His was likely felt, which is why it looks so much bulkier and more eccentric in the drawings.
People often ask why the hat is so tall. Fashion in the mid-1800s was all about height. The taller the hat, the more status you supposedly had. But the Hatter is a subversion of that. He’s wearing a hat that looks like it belongs to a gentleman, yet he’s clearly not one. He’s stuck in a perpetual tea party, trapped in a loop of time. The hat is his identity, but it's also his cage.
Real Victorian Hat Construction
If you were to handle a real 19th-century top hat, you'd be surprised by how heavy they are. They weren't made of flimsy felt. They had a "buckram" frame—linen soaked in shellac. This made the hat stiff and durable. If you’re looking for a high-quality mad hatter top hat today, you should avoid the cheap polyester versions. They don't have the "bloom." That’s the slight sheen that real silk or high-quality fur felt has when it catches the light.
- Check the brim. A real Victorian style has a "pencil curl." This is a tight, hand-sewn edge that gives the hat structural integrity.
- Look at the lining. Genuine period hats used white or cream silk inside. It kept the mercury (ironically) and sweat away from the wearer's hair.
- The 10/6 Card. If you're going for authenticity, don't just tape a piece of paper to the side. In the original Tenniel illustrations, the card is tucked into the "hatband"—the silk ribbon tied around the base.
The Modern Obsession with the Tapered Silhouette
Why do we still care about this specific hat? Honestly, it’s probably because of the 2010 Tim Burton movie. Colleen Atwood, the costume designer, took the mad hatter top hat and turned it into a piece of wearable art. She used lace overlays, burnt edges, and a much more pronounced "flare" than we see in historical records. This "Steampunk" influence changed how we perceive the character. It moved from a Victorian caricature to a gothic icon.
But there’s a nuance people miss. In the book, the Hatter is actually quite rude and anxious. He’s not "wacky" in a fun way; he’s stressed. He tells Alice that "Time" is a person, and he’s had a falling out with him. The hat represents his attempt to maintain some semblance of professional dignity while his world—and his mind—is falling apart.
Choosing the Right Material for Your Hat
If you're buying one for a collection or a high-end costume, material is everything. Wool felt is the most common "affordable" option. It’s sturdy, but it attracts lint like crazy. Fur felt (usually rabbit) is what the pros use. It’s softer, more water-resistant, and holds its shape for decades. Then there’s "moleskin," which isn't actually made from moles. It's a heavy cotton fabric with a sheared surface that mimics the look of silk plush.
If you want the authentic "Mad Hatter" look, you want something with a slight "distressed" finish. You don't want it looking brand new. You want it to look like it’s been through a few hundred years of tea parties.
The 10/6 Mystery Explained
Let’s talk about that number again. 10/6. In 1865, when Alice's Adventures in Wonderland was published, ten shillings and sixpence was a decent amount of money. It wasn't a "cheap" hat, but it wasn't a luxury item for the ultra-rich either. It was a middle-class price point. This tells us a lot about the Hatter’s social standing. He’s a guy trying to move up in the world, selling hats to the aspiring middle class, while the mercury slowly destroys his ability to actually function in society.
It's a bit of a tragic irony. He’s selling the very thing that’s killing him.
How to Style a Mad Hatter Top Hat Without Looking Like a Cheap Costume
If you're going to wear one, don't do the full "spirit halloween" look. It’s tacky. Instead, treat the mad hatter top hat as a focal point.
- Contrast textures. If the hat is rough felt, wear a smooth velvet coat.
- The Angle. Never wear a top hat straight on your head. It looks like a bucket. Tilt it slightly forward and to the side. This is called "the rake." It’s how Victorian men showed personality.
- Accessorize the band. Don't just use the 10/6 card. Add a peacock feather, some vintage hat pins, or even a bit of antique lace. It adds depth.
The goal is to make it look like an heirloom, not something you pulled out of a plastic bag. Real hatters take pride in the "crown" (the top part) and the "tip" (the very top surface). If those are sagging, the hat is dead.
Actionable Steps for the Aspiring Hatter
If you’re serious about getting or making a mad hatter top hat, don't just wing it. Start by looking at the work of professional milliners like Lock & Co. Hatters in London—the oldest hat shop in the world. They’ve been making these since 1765.
First, measure your head properly. Use a soft tape measure and go about one centimeter above your ears. If you’re between sizes, always go up. You can add a "hat reducer" (a foam strip) inside the sweatband, but you can’t make a small hat bigger without ruining the shape.
Second, decide on your "flare." A "John Bull" style top hat has a flat top and a slight flare, which is a great middle ground if you want something that looks "Hatter-esque" but still classy.
👉 See also: Chick-fil-A Charlotte Hall: What Most People Get Wrong
Third, take care of it. Never rest a top hat on its brim. It will flatten the curl over time. Always rest it upside down on its crown. Use a soft horsehair brush to clean it, always brushing in the direction of the "nap" (the way the fur lays down). Usually, this is counter-clockwise.
The mad hatter top hat is more than a movie prop. It’s a piece of social history, a reminder of the industrial revolution's dark side, and a masterpiece of Victorian design. Respect the 10/6. It cost the original hatters a lot more than just ten shillings.