Why the lyrics to the 12 days of christmas are actually much weirder than you remember

Why the lyrics to the 12 days of christmas are actually much weirder than you remember

You know the song. You've probably screamed "five golden rings" at the top of your lungs in a crowded room while someone nearby inevitably forgets whether the "ladies dancing" come before or after the "lords a-leaping." It's a festive staple. But if you actually sit down and look at the lyrics to the 12 days of christmas, the whole thing is basically a fever dream of avian hoarding and questionable property management.

Who wants six geese? Honestly. The noise alone would be a nightmare.

Most people think of this as just a repetitive children’s ditty, but the history of these verses is a tangled mess of French origin stories, memory games, and a massive amount of poultry. It isn't just a song; it's a historical artifact that has survived centuries of linguistic shifts and regional tweaks. We’re talking about a piece of music that didn't even have its famous melody until 1909, when Frederic Austin added that iconic flourish on the fifth day. Before that, you were basically just chanting a grocery list of birds at your friends until someone messed up and had to pay a forfeit.

The actual lyrics to the 12 days of christmas (and what they mean)

Let's get the basics down first because everyone mixes up the order. The song builds on itself, a structure known as a cumulative verse. It starts with that lone partridge in a pear tree and ends with a full-blown parade of percussionists.

On the first day of Christmas, my true love sent to me: A partridge in a pear tree.

Then it scales up. Two turtle doves. Three French hens. Four calling birds. Five golden rings. This is where it gets interesting. While we all sing "four calling birds," the original 18th-century version in the book Mirth Without Mischief actually listed them as "colly birds." Colly is an old English term for black as coal. So, you weren't getting songbirds; you were getting four blackbirds. Probably for a pie. It sounds less romantic when you realize the "true love" in this song is basically just dumping a small zoo on your front porch.

The list continues with six geese a-laying and seven swans a-swimming. If you’re keeping track, that is a staggering amount of bird poop. By day seven, your backyard is a swamp. Then the song shifts gears from livestock to human capital. Eight maids a-milking, nine ladies dancing, ten lords a-leaping, eleven pipers piping, and twelve drummers drumming.

Why so many birds?

It seems overkill. But back in the 1700s, when these lyrics were first being codified in England, birds were a status symbol. They were food. They were sport. Having "three French hens" meant you had imported goods. It was the Georgian version of showing off a designer handbag.

There's also a persistent rumor that the lyrics to the 12 days of christmas were a secret coded message for persecuted Catholics in England. The theory suggests the partridge was Jesus and the two turtle doves were the Old and New Testaments.

✨ Don't miss: Why the Cast of Hold Your Breath 2024 Makes This Dust Bowl Horror Actually Work

It’s a cool story. It’s also almost certainly fake.

Secular historians like Hugh Keyte and Andrew Parrott, who edited The New Oxford Book of Carols, point out that there’s zero evidence for this "coding" theory. It didn't pop up until the late 20th century. In reality, the song was a "memory and forfeits" game. You played it at parties. If you forgot a lyric, you had to give up a piece of candy or kiss someone. It was basically a high-stakes drinking game without the booze, though knowing 18th-century social habits, there was probably booze too.

The linguistic shift of the five golden rings

We need to talk about the rings. It’s the emotional peak of the song. Everyone waits for it. But some scholars suggest that "golden rings" might not actually refer to jewelry.

Wait, what?

If the first seven days are all about birds—partridges, doves, hens, colly birds, geese, and swans—why would day five suddenly be about gold jewelry? Some folklore experts argue that "golden rings" actually refers to ring-necked pheasants. This would keep the bird theme consistent for the entire first half of the song. It makes a lot of sense. You go from four blackbirds to five pheasants to six geese.

However, by the time Frederic Austin published his arrangement in the early 1900s, the "jewelry" interpretation was firmly locked in. He’s the one who stretched out the word "five," giving us that dramatic pause we all love today. He changed the rhythm and, in doing so, changed how we visualize the gift. We went from a platter of game birds to a jewelry box.

The sheer cost of this madness

Every year, PNC Bank does a "Christmas Price Index" where they calculate the actual market cost of the items in the lyrics to the 12 days of christmas.

It is wildly expensive.

🔗 Read more: Is Steven Weber Leaving Chicago Med? What Really Happened With Dean Archer

In recent years, the total cost for all 364 items (because you count every repetition) has climbed well over $45,000. The seven swans a-swimming are consistently the most expensive part of the bill. Apparently, swans aren't cheap to maintain. And the "lords a-leaping"? You're basically hiring high-end acrobats or dancers. If you actually tried to give these gifts today, you’d need a massive plot of land, a specialized staff of milkmaids, and a very good lawyer to handle the noise complaints from the twelve drummers.

The logistics are a nightmare. Imagine the 40 gold rings you'd accumulate by the end of the twelve days. That's a lot of equity, sure, but you also have 42 swans to deal with. It's a logistical catastrophe disguised as a romance.

A breakdown of the human elements

When the song hits day eight, it moves away from the avian obsession.

  • Eight maids a-milking: This implies you also now own eight cows. The song doesn't mention the cows, but you can't milk the air.
  • Nine ladies dancing: Usually interpreted as refined socialites or performers.
  • Ten lords a-leaping: High-society men showing off their athletic prowess.
  • Eleven pipers piping and twelve drummers drumming: A full military-style band.

By day twelve, you have a household staff and an entertainment troupe of 70 people. This isn't a gift; it's a small kingdom.

The French connection and forgotten verses

There is a very strong chance the song started in France. The earliest printed versions are English, but similar "count-up" songs existed in French traditions much earlier. In some versions, the gifts are different. Instead of a partridge, you might get a "good fat capon." In other variations, the "four calling birds" are "four ducks."

The "pear tree" might even be a linguistic accident. In French, a partridge is a perdrix. Some believe that "a partridge, une perdrix" (pronounced a-per-dree) was misheard by English ears as "a partridge in a pear tree." It’s a classic case of "mondegreen"—where a word or phrase is misheard as something else that makes more sense to the listener. A bird in a tree feels right. A bird followed by its own French name feels like a glitch.

How to actually remember the order

If you're tired of being the person who mumbles through the "maids a-milking" section, there is a trick. Group them.

First, you have the "tree birds" (the partridge). Then the "small birds" (doves, hens, colly birds). Then the "big birds" (geese and swans). After the "gold rings" break, it’s all people. Working people (maids), then fancy people (ladies and lords), then the band (pipers and drummers).

💡 You might also like: Is Heroes and Villains Legit? What You Need to Know Before Buying

It’s a progression of scale. It moves from the garden to the pond to the ballroom to the parade ground.

Most people mess up the 9, 10, and 11 spots. Just remember that the ladies dance before the lords jump. It’s a bit of Victorian-era etiquette frozen in a song. The ladies take the floor, the men show off their "leaping" (which was a specific type of fancy dance move back then), and then the music kicks in full force with the pipes and drums.

Making the song useful today

We don't live in a world where giving someone 224 birds is considered a grand romantic gesture. If you did that today, you'd probably get a restraining order. But the lyrics to the 12 days of christmas still hold a lot of weight in pop culture.

  • Gift Themes: Many people use the song to give twelve small, themed gifts leading up to Christmas or starting on December 25th.
  • The True Twelve Days: Remember, the twelve days actually start on Christmas Day and end on January 5th (Epiphany). The song is meant to be sung after the big day, not before it.
  • Memory Games: It remains one of the best ways to test cognitive recall during a holiday party. Try singing it backwards if you really want to challenge your brain.

The song is a endurance test. It’s meant to be exhausting. By the time you get to day twelve, your breath is short, your memory is strained, and you’ve said the word "partridge" twelve times. That’s the point. It’s a communal experience designed to be a little bit ridiculous and a lot of fun.

Instead of just singing the words, try looking into the "Christmas Price Index" or the "Colly Bird" history the next time you're at a holiday dinner. It makes for much better conversation than just arguing about whether a partridge actually likes pear trees (spoiler: they are ground-nesting birds, so the tree is actually a terrible place for them).

To get the most out of the tradition this year, try these steps:

  • Check the calendar: Start your "Twelve Days" celebration on December 25th to be historically accurate.
  • Vary the gifts: If you're doing a 12-day gift exchange, use the lyrics as inspiration but keep it modern. Five gold rings could just be five glazed donuts.
  • Host a "forfeit" game: Sing the song in a circle. Each person takes a day. If someone stumbles, they have to do a funny task or wear a silly hat for the rest of the night.

The lyrics to the 12 days of christmas are more than just a list of gifts. They are a weird, wonderful remnant of how we used to entertain ourselves before screens took over. They’re chaotic, expensive, and poultry-heavy. And honestly? Christmas wouldn't feel the same without them.