Why the Lyrics of Song Imagine by John Lennon Still Make People Uncomfortable

Why the Lyrics of Song Imagine by John Lennon Still Make People Uncomfortable

John Lennon once called it "virtually the Communist Manifesto," even though it’s played at every New Year’s Eve celebration and Olympic ceremony. That’s the weird thing about the lyrics of song imagine by john lennon. They’ve been sanitized by time. People hear the piano—that iconic, rolling C-major melody—and they think of peace, love, and soft-focus unity. But if you actually read the words, they’re pretty radical. Lennon wasn't just asking us to be nice to each other. He was asking us to dismantle the entire structure of modern civilization. No heaven? No countries? No possessions? Honestly, if a major pop star released those exact lyrics today, half the internet would try to cancel them for being too "woke," and the other half would call them a dangerous anarchist.

It’s a paradox.

The song is a lullaby for a revolution. It’s also arguably the most famous set of lyrics in the history of rock music, written on a brown Steinway upright piano in a bedroom at Tittenhurst Park in 1971. But the story of how those lyrics came to be—and what they actually mean—is way more complicated than just Lennon sitting in a white room thinking happy thoughts.

The Secret Influence Most People Miss

We give John all the credit. He’s the face of the song, the voice of the era. But for decades, we ignored the woman standing right next to him. In 2017, the National Music Publishers Association finally added Yoko Ono as a co-writer, and it’s about time. The lyrics of song imagine by john lennon are basically a musical adaptation of her 1964 book Grapefruit.

Go back and look at her instructional poems. She wrote things like "Imagine the clouds dripping," or "Imagine a raindrop." That "Imagine" framework was her conceptual art style. Lennon later admitted he was a bit too "macho" and selfish at the time to give her the credit she deserved. He just took the concept and ran with it.

Breaking Down the Verse: Religion and the Afterlife

The song starts with a massive swing: "Imagine there's no heaven."

In 1971, that was a heavy lift. It still is. Lennon wasn't trying to be edgy just for the sake of it; he was arguing that the promise of an afterlife makes us treat the present like a waiting room. If you believe there’s a "better place" waiting for you, maybe you don’t work as hard to fix the garbage world you’re currently living in. It's a call for radical presence. "No hell below us, above us only sky." It sounds peaceful, but it’s a total rejection of religious institutional power.

💡 You might also like: Songs by Tyler Childers: What Most People Get Wrong

He’s basically saying: Stop looking at the clouds and look at the person next to you.

Why Governments Hate the Middle Verse

The second verse is where the lyrics of song imagine by john lennon get truly political. "Imagine there's no countries." Think about how much of our identity is wrapped up in a flag or a border. Then he adds, "Nothing to kill or die for."

War is usually fueled by two things: "my land" and "my god."

By suggesting we erase borders, Lennon was hitting at the heart of the Vietnam War era. He was being watched by the FBI at the time. J. Edgar Hoover wasn't a fan. To the establishment, these lyrics weren't a pretty poem; they were a threat to national security. If people stopped believing in the "sanctity" of the nation-state, how would you get them to fight in a jungle 8,000 miles away? You wouldn't.

The "No Possessions" Problem

Then comes the line that everyone loves to throw back in Lennon's face: "Imagine no possessions."

Critics love to point out that Lennon was a multimillionaire living in a massive estate when he sang this. "Easy for you to say, John, while you're eating caviar." And yeah, the hypocrisy is there. Lennon knew it, too. He called it "sugar-coated." He knew that if he made the song too abrasive or "heavy," nobody would play it on the radio. So he wrapped these incredibly challenging ideas—giving up your stuff, your country, and your religion—in a gorgeous, digestible melody.

📖 Related: Questions From Black Card Revoked: The Culture Test That Might Just Get You Roasted

It’s the ultimate Trojan Horse.

The Controversy That Never Went Away

It’s not just 1970s conservatives who had a problem with the song. Even today, the lyrics of song imagine by john lennon cause friction. When CeeLo Green performed it in 2012, he changed the line "and no religion too" to "and all religion’s true."

People lost their minds.

The internet exploded because by changing that one line, he missed the entire point of the song. Lennon wasn't looking for a "coexist" bumper sticker. He was looking for the removal of the barriers that cause the conflict in the first place. You can't just add more labels and hope it works out; the song is about the absence of labels.

Even Gal Gadot’s infamous 2020 celebrity montage of the song felt "off" to most people. Why? Because the song is about shared struggle and a collective vision, and seeing a bunch of wealthy actors sing "Imagine no possessions" from their mansions during a global lockdown felt tone-deaf. It proved that the lyrics are still sharp. They still have the power to make us feel uncomfortable when the person singing them doesn't match the message.

How to Actually Apply the "Imagine" Philosophy

So, what do we do with this? Is it just a nice song to hum along to, or is there a "to-do list" hidden in the verses?

👉 See also: The Reality of Sex Movies From Africa: Censorship, Nollywood, and the Digital Underground

If you want to take the lyrics of song imagine by john lennon seriously, you have to look at your own "borders." We all have them. We have mental borders between us and people who vote differently. We have "possessions" we value more than people.

  1. Audit your attachments. Look at the things you think you "need" to be happy. Lennon’s point wasn't that we should all live in a cave, but that our obsession with owning things creates a "hunger" that never ends.
  2. Question the "Us vs. Them" narrative. Every time you feel a surge of tribalism—whether it's sports, politics, or nationality—remember the line about "no countries." Is the border real, or is it just something we agreed to believe in?
  3. Focus on the "Now." The "Imagine there's no heaven" bit is really just a prompt to be a better human being today. Don't wait for a reward in the afterlife. Do the work now.

The song isn't a blueprint for a perfect world. Lennon wasn't a politician; he was an artist. He was asking a "What if?" question. He called himself a "dreamer," and he was self-aware enough to know he wasn't the only one.

The genius of the song is that it doesn't give you a 10-point plan for world peace. It just asks you to hold the thought for three minutes and three seconds. It asks you to stop seeing the world as it is—full of walls and gates—and start seeing it as it could be.

If you're looking for a way to really honor the legacy of those lyrics, stop treating the song like a museum piece. Don't just listen to the piano. Listen to the challenge. It’s a call to strip away the "labels" we use to protect ourselves. It’s about being vulnerable enough to believe that a world without "greedy" or "hungry" people is actually possible, even if it feels like a pipe dream in the middle of a 24-hour news cycle.

Next time it comes on the radio, don't just hum. Actually think about what it would mean to live without those safety nets. It’s a lot scarier—and a lot more beautiful—than we give it credit for.


Actionable Insight:
To truly understand the song’s impact, listen to the 2018 "Ultimate Mix" which strips away some of the heavy reverb. It makes Lennon’s voice sound like he’s standing right in front of you. Read the lyrics as a poem without the music playing. It changes the experience entirely. You’ll notice the "bite" in the words that the beautiful piano melody usually hides. Study the "Imagine" art installations worldwide, like the Strawberry Fields memorial in Central Park, to see how these words have become a physical space for collective grieving and hope.