Shaker Heights is perfect. Or, at least, that’s what the residents want you to believe. If you’ve watched the Little Fires Everywhere TV show, you know that "perfect" is usually just a code word for "repressed." It has been a few years since the limited series dropped on Hulu, but the conversation around it hasn't cooled off. Honestly, it's one of those rare adaptations that actually dares to change the source material in ways that make the audience deeply uncomfortable.
Elena Richardson is the queen of this curated world. Reese Witherspoon plays her with this terrifying, brittle politeness that feels like a paper cut. Then you have Mia Warren, played by Kerry Washington, who shows up in a beat-up Chevy and flips the whole social ecosystem upside down. It’s not just a "rich vs. poor" story. It’s a "my way of being a mother is better than yours" story.
The Massive Changes From Celeste Ng’s Novel
Most people who loved the book were shocked by the show. In Celeste Ng's original 2017 novel, the tension between Elena and Mia is mostly about class and lifestyle. The showrunners, led by Liz Tigelaar, decided to make the racial subtext of the book the literal text of the series. By casting Kerry Washington as Mia, the dynamic shifted from two women of different classes to two women of different races navigating a "progressive" white suburb in the 90s.
It changed everything.
In the book, Mia’s backstory is complicated, but in the show, her identity as a Black mother adds a layer of systemic fear that Elena—in all her blonde, organized glory—cannot even begin to comprehend. Some critics argued this made the show "too loud" compared to the book’s quiet prose. Others felt it was the only way to make the story feel urgent for a modern audience.
Then there’s the ending.
No spoilers if you’re just starting, but the person who actually sets the "little fires" is different in the show. This wasn't just a random twist for the sake of a cliffhanger. It felt like a commentary on how trauma is passed down through generations. Elena’s obsession with rules ultimately burns her own house down, figuratively and literally.
👉 See also: The Entire History of You: What Most People Get Wrong About the Grain
Why the 1990s Setting Actually Matters
It’s easy to dismiss the 90s setting as just an excuse for a great soundtrack (and the soundtrack is excellent, featuring covers of Alanis Morissette and Annie Lennox). But the setting is a character itself. The Little Fires Everywhere TV show takes place in a pre-smartphone era where you couldn't just Google someone’s dark past. Elena has to go to the library. She has to make phone calls. She has to do "detective work" that feels increasingly invasive and creepy.
Shaker Heights, Ohio, is a real place. It was one of the first planned communities in the country. The show nails the specific brand of 90s liberalism that thinks it’s "post-racial" because it has integrated neighborhoods, while still enforcing rigid social codes. You see it in the way the school counselors talk to Pearl, or the way the neighbors look at Mia’s art. It’s subtle. It’s nasty. It’s very 1997.
The Bebe Chow Subplot is the Heart of the Show
While Elena and Mia are the stars, the legal battle over baby Mirabelle (or May Ling) is what actually anchors the ethics of the show. Linda McCullough is Elena’s best friend. She’s struggled with infertility for years. She finally gets a "miracle" baby that was left at a fire station. Then comes Bebe Chow, the biological mother who left the baby in a moment of postpartum despair and poverty.
Who deserves the child?
- The wealthy parents who can provide a stable, "perfect" life?
- The biological mother who has found her footing but has no resources?
The show doesn't give you an easy out. It makes you hate and love both sides. You feel Linda’s grief and Bebe’s desperation. It’s messy. Life is messy. The Little Fires Everywhere TV show thrives in that mess.
Performance Breakdown: Witherspoon vs. Washington
Watching these two act together is like watching a tennis match where the ball is on fire. Reese Witherspoon has perfected the "Type A woman on the verge of a breakdown" archetype. If you liked her in Election or Big Little Lies, this is the final evolution of that character. She uses her smile like a weapon.
✨ Don't miss: Shamea Morton and the Real Housewives of Atlanta: What Really Happened to Her Peach
Kerry Washington, on the other hand, plays Mia with a vibrating intensity. She rarely screams, but you can see the muscles in her jaw working. She’s defensive. She’s secretive. Some viewers found her performance a bit too "stiff," but if you look at Mia’s history—always running, always hiding—the stiffness makes perfect sense. She’s a woman who has spent her life being a moving target.
The supporting cast is also stacked. Joshua Jackson plays the "nice guy" husband who is actually just checked out. The kids—especially Lexie and Izzy—perfectly mirror the flaws of their parents. Izzy Richardson is the "black sheep," and her relationship with her mother is the most painful part of the entire series. It’s a visceral depiction of what happens when a mother doesn't "see" her child because the child doesn't fit the aesthetic of the family.
The Production Design of Perfection
The houses in this show tell a story. The Richardson house is huge, white, and full of expensive things that nobody is allowed to touch. It feels like a museum. Mia’s apartment is sparse, filled with art supplies and shadows.
The lighting changes depending on whose "world" we are in. In Elena’s world, everything is bright, over-exposed, and clinical. In Mia’s world, the colors are deep, earthy, and chaotic. This visual storytelling is why the show works so well as a binge-watch. You don't just hear the conflict; you see it in the wallpaper.
Dealing With the Backlash
Not everyone loved it. A common criticism was that the show was "too heavy-handed" compared to the nuanced themes of the book. By amping up the drama, some felt the characters became caricatures. Elena becomes a borderline villain by the end, whereas in the book, she’s more of a tragic figure of her own making.
However, the ratings don't lie. It was a massive hit for Hulu. It tapped into the cultural zeitgeist of motherhood, privilege, and the secrets we keep to protect our reputations.
🔗 Read more: Who is Really in the Enola Holmes 2 Cast? A Look at the Faces Behind the Mystery
Real-World Lessons from Shaker Heights
What can we actually take away from the Little Fires Everywhere TV show? It’s a cautionary tale about the "White Savior" complex. Elena thinks she’s helping Mia by giving her a job and a place to stay, but she’s actually just trying to control her. She wants to feel like a good person without actually doing the work of understanding someone else's reality.
If you’re a fan of domestic thrillers or social commentaries, this show is a blueprint. It teaches us that:
- Rules don't make you a good person. They just make you a person who follows rules.
- Motherhood isn't a competition. There are many ways to love a child, and none of them are perfect.
- The past always catches up. You can’t outrun your secrets, even in a beautiful house in Ohio.
How to Approach a Rewatch
If you’ve already seen it once, watch it again and focus entirely on Izzy and Pearl. The show is marketed as a battle between the mothers, but it’s actually a story about how the daughters are collateral damage. Look at the way Pearl starts to mimic the Richardson kids' behavior to fit in. Look at how Izzy desperately searches for a "mother figure" in Mia because her own mother treats her like a glitch in the system.
The show is currently available on Hulu in the US and Disney+ or Amazon Prime in other territories. It’s eight episodes. Each one feels like a slow-motion car crash—you want to look away, but you just can't.
Stop looking for a hero. There isn't one. Every character in this show is "the villain" in someone else's story. Once you accept that, the ending hits much harder. Go back and check out the early episodes to see the foreshadowing of the fire; it’s hidden in the dialogue from the very first scene. Pay attention to the recurring motif of butterflies and cages. It explains more about the finale than any monologue ever could.
Next Steps for Fans:
- Read the book: If you’ve only seen the show, the novel offers a much more internal, psychological look at the characters without the heightened TV drama.
- Listen to the Soundtrack: Find the "Little Fires Everywhere" official playlist to hear how those 90s covers mirror the specific emotional beats of the episodes.
- Explore Shaker Heights: Look up the history of the town; the real-life regulations on everything from lawn height to house colors are even more intense than the show depicts.
- Watch 'Big Little Lies': If the domestic tension and Reese Witherspoon's performance were your favorite parts, this is the logical next step for your watchlist.