Why The League of Gentlemen remains the most unsettling comedy on British TV

Why The League of Gentlemen remains the most unsettling comedy on British TV

You’ll never forget the first time you saw Tubbs and Edward. It’s that visceral, "what on earth am I watching?" moment that defines the League of Gentlemen show. One minute you’re looking at a quaint, foggy Northern town, and the next, a shopkeeper with a pig-nose is screaming about "precious things" while her husband threatens to kidnap you. It’s weird. Honestly, it’s deeply messed up. But that’s exactly why we’re still talking about Royston Vasey twenty-five years after it first crawled onto BBC Two.

The show didn’t just push boundaries; it relocated them to a dark, damp cellar in the middle of nowhere. Created by Jeremy Dyson, Mark Gatiss, Steve Pemberton, and Reece Shearsmith, the series was a hand grenade lobbed into the middle of the late-90s sitcom landscape. While Friends was busy being bright and caffeinated in New York, these four guys were exploring the grotesque underbelly of the English countryside.

Welcome to Royston Vasey: You’ll never leave

The genius of the League of Gentlemen show lies in its geography. It’s a fictional town, sure, but anyone who has ever driven through a remote village in Derbyshire or Lancashire knows it’s real. That feeling of being an "outsider" isn't just a plot point; it's the entire atmosphere. The show captures that specific British anxiety of being trapped in a place where the locals have their own language, their own rules, and a very specific way of looking at your car's license plate.

Most people think of it as a sketch show. It isn't. Not really. It’s more of a serialized nightmare with punchlines. Unlike Little Britain, which relied on repetitive catchphrases to the point of exhaustion, the League built a living, breathing (and occasionally dying) ecosystem. Characters didn't just appear; they collided. The local vet, Mr. Chinnery, would accidentally explode a domestic pet in one scene, and by the next episode, that failure would ripple through the town’s fragile social fabric. It was dark. Like, pitch-black dark.

The art of the grotesque

Why does the makeup still hold up? Because it was never about looking "funny." It was about looking wrong. Think about Papa Lazarou. He’s arguably one of the most terrifying creations in television history. He doesn't have a catchphrase so much as a haunting rasp. "You’re my wife now." It’s a line that still gets shouted at the creators in the street today.

What’s interesting is how the troupe—Gatiss, Pemberton, and Shearsmith—played almost every role themselves. This wasn't just a budget-saving measure. It created a strange, incestuous feeling in the town. Everyone looked a bit like everyone else because, fundamentally, they were the same three actors. It added to the claustrophobia. You couldn't escape the faces.

✨ Don't miss: Temuera Morrison as Boba Fett: Why Fans Are Still Divided Over the Daimyo of Tatooine

The League of Gentlemen show and the "Local" obsession

"This is a local shop for local people. There's nothing for you here."

It’s the most famous line from the series, but it’s often misunderstood as a simple joke about xenophobia. In reality, it was a satire of the dying British high street and the desperate, violent grip people hold onto "the way things used to be." Tubbs and Edward Tattsyrup weren't just monsters; they were tragic figures trapped in a crumbling building, terrified of a road that might actually connect them to the rest of the world.

The writing was surgical. Jeremy Dyson, the only member of the quartet who didn't perform on screen, was often the one keeping the internal logic airtight. He ensured that even the most absurd scenarios—like a man obsessed with toads or a Job Centre worker who forces people to draw "the pens"—felt like they were happening in a real place. The comedy didn't come from the situation being wacky; it came from the characters taking their insanity completely seriously.

From the stage to the screen

Before the TV cameras arrived, they were a fringe act. They won the Perrier Award at the Edinburgh Festival in 1997. If you go back and listen to the original BBC Radio 4 series, On the Town with The League of Gentlemen, you can hear the bones of what was to come. But it needed the visual filth. It needed the rainy hills and the sickly yellow lighting of the local pharmacy to really land.

They didn't stop at three seasons, either. We got a movie, The League of Gentlemen's Apocalypse, which was a meta-textual mess in the best way possible. It saw the characters breaking into "our" world to confront their creators. It was polarizing. Some fans loved the ambition; others just wanted more sketches in the shop. But the League was never about giving people what they wanted. They were about giving people what made them uncomfortable.

🔗 Read more: Why Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy Actors Still Define the Modern Spy Thriller

The 20th Anniversary specials: Did it still work?

When the group reunited in 2017 for three anniversary specials, there was a lot of nervousness. Could Royston Vasey exist in the modern era? The world had changed. Sensitivity had changed. But the League of Gentlemen show survived because its horror was universal. They leaned into the passage of time. Tubbs and Edward were now living in a makeshift flat in a derelict block, still clutching onto their "local" ideals while the world literally moved on around them.

It was a masterclass in how to revive a cult classic. They didn't reboot it; they checked in on the rot. Seeing Mark Gatiss back as Les McQueen, the failed glam-rocker, was heartbreaking. That’s the secret ingredient: pathos. Behind the prosthetics and the screaming, there was a genuine sadness for these losers. Except for Papa Lazarou. He’s just pure evil.

Why it's harder to watch now

Let's be real. Some parts of the show are tough to sit through today. The use of blackface for Papa Lazarou has been a point of massive contention, leading to the show being pulled from certain streaming platforms like Netflix in 2020. The creators have defended the character as being based on a specific, nightmarish memory of a circus performer, rather than a racial caricature, but the conversation around it remains heated.

It’s a perfect example of how the "edge" of 1999 comedy can become a "ledge" in the 2020s. Whether you think it's an essential piece of folk-horror satire or a relic that should stay in the past, you can't deny its influence. You see its DNA in The Mighty Boosh, Psychoville, and Inside No. 9.

The Legacy of the Quartet

You can’t talk about British TV in the last decade without mentioning what the League members did next.

💡 You might also like: The Entire History of You: What Most People Get Wrong About the Grain

  • Mark Gatiss went on to co-create Sherlock and write for Doctor Who.
  • Reece Shearsmith and Steve Pemberton created Inside No. 9, which is essentially the spiritual successor to the League’s anthology-style madness.
  • Jeremy Dyson co-wrote the terrifying stage play and film Ghost Stories.

They proved that there was a massive audience for "dark." They showed that you could blend Hammer Horror aesthetics with Monty Python absurdity and people would actually tune in. They made the grotesque mainstream.

How to watch it properly

If you’re diving back in, don't just look for the highlights on YouTube. The League of Gentlemen show is designed to be watched in chunks. The way the background details in season one pay off in season three is genuinely impressive. Watch the way the "New Road" project slowly encroaches on the town. It’s a slow-burn disaster movie disguised as a sitcom.

Also, pay attention to the music. Joby Talbot’s score is doing a lot of the heavy lifting. It’s orchestral, grand, and slightly "off," much like the town itself. It tells you that what you’re seeing is important, even when it’s just a man accidentally killing a dog with a toy plane.

Actionable steps for the budding Royston Vasey fan

If you want to truly appreciate the depth of this series, you need to look beyond the TV screen. The layer of references is deep, and the craftsmanship is specific.

  1. Track down the Radio 4 series. It’s fascinating to hear how the characters evolved. Some characters, like Benjamin’s friend who disappears, have much more prominent roles in the audio version.
  2. Watch 'Inside No. 9' alongside it. Specifically the episode "The Trial of Elizabeth Gadge." You can see exactly how Shearsmith and Pemberton refined the "folk-horror" comedy they started in Royston Vasey.
  3. Read the scripts. The League published their scripts with extensive notes. It reveals just how much of the "weirdness" was planned and how many of the characters were based on real people they met while growing up in the North.
  4. Look for the 'folk horror' tropes. To understand the show, you should watch The Wicker Man (1973) and Blood on Satan’s Claw. The League is essentially a love letter to these films. When you see the parallels, the jokes get even better.
  5. Check out the live tour DVDs. The chemistry between the three performers on stage is electric. You realize that a lot of the show's energy comes from three friends trying to make each other laugh by being as disgusting as possible.

The League of Gentlemen show isn't for everyone. It’s cruel, it’s dirty, and it’s frequently upsetting. But it’s also one of the most original pieces of art ever broadcast. It reminds us that comedy doesn't always have to be "nice" or "relatable." Sometimes, the best comedy is the kind that makes you want to lock your front door and never visit a local shop ever again.

For those looking to explore the roots of British dark comedy, starting with the first episode "Welcome to Royston Vasey" is essential. Note the pacing—it’s much slower than modern sitcoms, allowing the dread to build naturally. Pay close attention to the recurring characters in the background of the Job Centre scenes; the world-building is densest in the periphery. Finally, seek out the Christmas Special (2000), which is widely considered one of the best horror-comedy crossovers ever filmed, structured as a portmanteau film paying homage to Amicus Productions.