You’re standing in the chip aisle. It’s 2012. Suddenly, among the sea of yellow bags, something weird catches your eye. Chicken and Waffles? In a potato chip bag? It felt like a fever dream or a dare. That was the magic of the Lay’s chip flavor competition, officially known as "Do Us a Flavor." It wasn't just about snacks; it was a cultural moment that turned ordinary people into amateur food scientists for a shot at a million dollars.
Honestly, we all thought it was a gimmick at first. Frito-Lay, the titan of the snacking world, basically handed the keys of the R&D department to the public. They asked us to pitch the next great flavor, and boy, did we deliver some chaos. From the genuinely delicious to the "who thought this was a good idea?" entries, the competition changed how we think about the stuff we eat while binge-watching Netflix.
The Viral Engine Behind Do Us a Flavor
The Lay’s chip flavor competition didn't succeed because of fancy commercials. It worked because it tapped into our collective desire to be heard. And, let's be real, our desire to get rich off a random thought we had while eating brunch.
The stakes were high. The winner didn't just get bragging rights; they got a cool million bucks or 1% of the flavor's net sales—whichever was higher. That’s life-changing money for thinking about potatoes. Karen Weber-Mendham, a children’s librarian from Wisconsin, took home the first grand prize for Cheesy Garlic Bread. It sounds simple now, but back then, it was a revelation. It beat out Sriracha and the aforementioned Chicken and Waffles.
People got competitive. Social media was flooded with suggestions. Some were legit, like Wasabi Ginger (which won in 2014), while others were clearly just people trolling the system. Ever heard of the "Toothpaste and Orange Juice" meme entries? Lay's had to filter through millions of submissions to find the ones that wouldn't actually make people sick. It was a massive undertaking for their culinary team in Plano, Texas. They had to take a vague concept like "Southern Biscuits and Gravy" and figure out how to make a dehydrated powder taste like actual pork fat and flour.
Why Some Flavors Flopped Hard
Not everything was a hit. Far from it.
Remember Cappuccino?
📖 Related: Bates Nut Farm Woods Valley Road Valley Center CA: Why Everyone Still Goes After 100 Years
In 2014, as part of the second US installment of the Lay’s chip flavor competition, a coffee-flavored potato chip hit the shelves. It was polarizing, to put it mildly. Most people hated it. It was a dessert-flavored chip that didn't know if it wanted to be salty or sweet, and the result was a confusing mess that tasted like burnt beans and starch. But here’s the thing: it didn't matter if it tasted good. It got people talking. That’s the secret sauce of the "Do Us a Flavor" campaign. It’s "stunt food" at its finest. Even if you bought a bag just to spit it out and tell your friends how gross it was, Lay’s still got your $4.29.
The competition shifted the brand's image from a "safe" legacy product to something experimental and edgy. They leaned into the weirdness. They knew that for every ten people who loved Kettle Cooked Wasabi Ginger, there would be five who were offended by the mere existence of Mango Salsa chips.
The Science of "Craving" a Contest
Frito-Lay uses a "sensory experience" lab. They measure things like "vanishing caloric density"—that feeling where a chip melts in your mouth and tricks your brain into thinking you haven't eaten anything, so you keep reaching for more. When you add a fan-submitted flavor into that mix, it adds a layer of psychological engagement. You aren't just eating a chip; you're participating in a nationwide experiment.
You've probably noticed that the winners often lean toward "savory-plus."
- Cheesy Garlic Bread (Butter, garlic, cheese)
- Southern Biscuits and Gravy (Peppery, creamy, meaty)
- Crispy Taco (Cumin, lettuce-freshness, beef)
These flavors work because they ground the novelty in something familiar. The outliers, the ones that try to be too "gourmet" or too sweet, usually end up in the clearance bin of history.
The Global Impact You Probably Missed
While Americans were arguing over Fried Green Tomatoes, the Lay’s chip flavor competition was actually a global phenomenon. It didn't start in the US. The "Walkers" brand in the UK (which is just Lay's with a different name) pioneered this way back in 2008.
👉 See also: Why T. Pepin’s Hospitality Centre Still Dominates the Tampa Event Scene
The UK version gave us "Builder’s Breakfast," which allegedly tasted like eggs, bacon, sausage, and beans. It sounds aggressive. It won.
In Canada, they had "Maple Moose." Imagine a chip that tastes like smoky meat and maple syrup. It was apparently a nightmare for some, but a nostalgic dream for others. This localized approach allowed the brand to dominate different markets by playing into regional pride. People in the South want different things than people in the Pacific Northwest. By letting the "crowd" decide, Lay's essentially outsourced their market research to the very people buying the bags.
The Logistics of a Million-Dollar Chip
It's not as simple as just picking a name. Once a flavor is shortlisted in the Lay’s chip flavor competition, it goes through a rigorous development phase.
First, the "seasoning houses" get involved. These are the shadowy companies that create the chemical profiles for everything we eat. They have to break down the flavor of a "Greektown Gyro" into its constituent parts: lamb, tzatziki, red onion, and pita. Then, they have to make sure that dust sticks to a fried potato slice without falling off in the bag.
Then comes the production run. Lay's has to clear space in their massive factories to produce millions of bags of a flavor that might be discontinued in three months. It's a logistical headache. They have to design the packaging, clear the legal hurdles of the "inspired by" recipes, and coordinate with retailers like Walmart and Target to ensure "The Finalists" displays are front and center.
The marketing spend is astronomical. We're talking Super Bowl-level visibility. But the ROI (return on investment) is massive because of the earned media. When a morning talk show host tries a Wavy Fried Green Tomato chip on air, that's free advertising worth millions.
✨ Don't miss: Human DNA Found in Hot Dogs: What Really Happened and Why You Shouldn’t Panic
How to Spot a Winner Before It's Announced
If you're following the latest iterations or looking back at the hall of fame, there are patterns.
Winners usually have a "bridge." A bridge is a flavor component that already exists in the standard Lay's lineup. Cheesy Garlic Bread bridged off the success of Cheddar and Sour Cream. Wasabi Ginger bridged off the growing popularity of spicy snacks like Flamin' Hot Cheetos.
The "weird for the sake of weird" entries—like the 2017 finalist Everything Bagel with Cream Cheese—often struggle because the texture of a chip doesn't match the creamy expectations of the flavor profile. If your brain expects "creamy" and gets "crunchy," it creates sensory dissonance. It's a "no" from the subconscious.
The Future of Snacking Competitions
We've seen the "Do Us a Flavor" format evolve. Recently, Lay’s shifted toward "Flavor Swap," where they mash up their chips with other brands like Doritos or Funyuns. They've also done the "Flavor Icons" series, mimicking famous restaurant dishes like Kettle Cooked New York Style Pizza.
But the heart of the Lay’s chip flavor competition remains the same: the power of the people. In an era where we're skeptical of big corporations, there’s something weirdly charming about a multibillion-dollar company saying, "Yeah, we'll try your weird idea for a Reuben-flavored chip."
It’s about community, even if that community is just a bunch of people on Reddit debating if a chip can truly capture the essence of a "West Coast Truffle Fries."
Step-by-Step: How to Evaluate the Next Big Flavor
If you want to be a pro-level snack critic when the next contest drops, don't just eat the chips. Analyze them. It makes the experience way more interesting.
- Check the "First Hit": Does the flavor hit you immediately, or is there a delay? A good chip should have an "upfront" saltiness followed by the specific flavor profile.
- The Aftertaste Test: Does it leave a chemical film on your tongue? This was the big complaint with the Cappuccino chips—a lingering, artificial sweetness that didn't belong on a potato.
- Aroma Check: Open the bag and take a whiff. About 80% of what we perceive as "flavor" is actually smell. If it doesn't smell like the description, the seasoning is off.
- Texture Pairing: Notice which potato "vehicle" they used. Wavy chips are meant for heavy, creamy flavors (like dip). Thin chips are for sharp, acidic flavors. Kettle cooked is for "premium" or complex profiles like Truffle or Ginger.
- The "Bowl Test": Would you actually eat a whole bowl of these, or is one chip enough? Many competition finalists are "one-hit wonders"—interesting for a bite, but exhausting for a snack session.
Keep an eye on the official Lay's social media channels and their dedicated contest websites. When the submission window opens, usually announced via major press releases, you'll need a flavor name, a brief inspiration story, and a "flavor profile" selection. Focus on "savory-plus" combinations and regional favorites that haven't gone national yet. Avoid anything that requires the chip to be cold or overly sweet; those rarely make it past the initial screening. Your best bet is to find a dish that everyone loves but no one has dared to turn into a powder yet. That’s where the million dollars lives.