Walk into 132 West 44th Street and the humidity of Midtown just... vanishes. It’s replaced by the scent of expensive gin and old wood. You’re at The Lambs Club Times Square, a place that feels like it shouldn't exist in 2026, yet here it is, thriving while other "power lunch" spots have faded into history. It’s located inside the Chatwal Hotel, but calling it a "hotel restaurant" is like calling a Ferrari "just a car."
It's deep. It's red.
The history here isn’t some marketing fluff written by a PR agency last week. The building was originally the home of The Lambs, America’s first professional theatrical club, founded back in 1874. Think of the names that used to pace these floors: Fred Astaire, Charlie Chaplin, Milton Berle. When you sit in those oversized red leather booths today, you’re basically occupying the same air space where the "Rat Pack" energy was born decades before the Rat Pack even had a name.
The Architecture of a Stanford White Masterpiece
Let’s talk about the fireplace. It’s massive. It was a gift from Stanford White, the legendary architect who basically designed Gilded Age New York before meeting a rather dramatic end himself. This 18th-century French limestone hearth is the anchor of the room. On a rainy Tuesday in November, there is nowhere else in Manhattan you’d rather be than tucked near that stone, sipping something stiff.
Most people don't realize that the restaurant we see now is the result of a massive restoration by architect Thierry Despont. He didn't just paint the walls; he resurrected the Art Deco soul of the place. The Empire-style chairs and the subtle nautical touches—like the chrome railings that look like they belong on a 1930s ocean liner—create a vibe that is aggressively "Old New York." It’s a stark contrast to the neon chaos of Broadway just a few yards away.
Honestly, the transition is jarring. One second you're dodging Elmo impersonators and tourists with selfie sticks, and the next, a tuxedoed captain is guiding you toward a table where the lighting is so perfectly calibrated it makes everyone look like they just closed a three-picture deal at Paramount.
What Actually Happens During a Power Lunch at The Lambs Club Times Square?
People wonder if the "Power Lunch" is dead. It's not. It just moved here.
🔗 Read more: Why Everyone Is Still Obsessing Over Maybelline SuperStay Skin Tint
At The Lambs Club Times Square, the midday meal is a choreographed dance. You’ll see Broadway producers whispering with agents, and hedge fund guys from Hudson Yards trying to look like they aren't checking their Bloomberg terminals every six seconds. The menu, currently overseen by Chef Jack Logue, manages to be sophisticated without being annoying.
You’ve got the Stanford White Burger. It’s pricey. It’s also probably one of the best burgers in the zip code, topped with Gruyère and caramelized onions. But the real pros often go for the more delicate stuff. The Dover Sole is a classic move here. Why? Because it shows you have time. It shows you aren't in a rush to get back to a cubicle.
Breaking Down the Menu Reality
- The Breakfast Scene: Surprisingly quiet and the best place for a high-stakes meeting where you don't want to be overheard. The lemon ricotta pancakes are legendary, but the smoked salmon bagel is what the regulars order.
- The Cocktail Program: This is where the bar team shines. They treat a Martini like a religious rite. It’s served cold—dangerously cold—and usually with a sidecar so you get every last drop.
- The Supper Club: On certain nights, the mezzanine comes alive with jazz. It’s not that "background elevator music" jazz either. It’s real, soulful stuff that makes the room feel even more like a time capsule.
The Stanford White Connection and The Ghosts of Broadway
The Lambs Club wasn't always a restaurant. In its original incarnation, it was a social club for "Thespians." The name actually comes from a group in London, named after Charles and Mary Lamb. It was a place where actors, who were then considered somewhat scandalous members of society, could congregate without judgment.
If these walls could actually talk, they’d probably tell you about John Barrymore stumbling in at 3:00 AM or the countless Broadway hits that were mapped out on the back of cocktail napkins. When the building was converted into the Chatwal and the restaurant opened in 2010, the goal was to preserve that "clubby" feel. They succeeded. It still feels exclusive, even though anyone with a Resy account can get a table if they’re fast enough.
Why the Service Feels Different Here
Service in Times Square is usually a nightmare. It’s fast, it’s impersonal, and the staff is often exhausted by the sheer volume of humanity. The Lambs Club Times Square is the exception to the rule.
The staff doesn't hover. They anticipate.
💡 You might also like: Coach Bag Animal Print: Why These Wild Patterns Actually Work as Neutrals
If you're there for a pre-theater dinner, they know the curtain times for Hadestown or Hamilton. They’ll get you out the door by 7:40 PM without making you feel rushed. It’s a delicate balance. If you’re there for a long-haul dinner, the pace slows down. The wine list is deep, particularly in Burgundies and Cabernets, and the sommelier won't judge you if you're looking for a "hidden gem" that doesn't cost as much as a month's rent in Queens.
The Mezzanine vs. The Main Dining Room
There is a hierarchy to the seating, whether they admit it or not.
The main dining room is where you want to be for the "see and be seen" vibe. Those red booths are the prime real estate. However, the Mezzanine Bar offers a different perspective. It overlooks the dining room, providing a bird's-eye view of the social theater below. It’s a bit more casual, a bit more shadowy. It’s where you go when you’re on a date that you don’t necessarily want to broadcast to the entire world.
The bar itself is a work of art. The chrome, the glass, the precision of the pours—it’s very "Mad Men" without the blatant misogyny.
Actionable Tips for Your Visit
If you’re planning to head to The Lambs Club Times Square, don't just wing it. This is a venue that rewards a little bit of foresight.
1. The "Secret" Breakfast Meeting
If you need to close a deal in Midtown and need absolute privacy, book a table for 8:30 AM on a Wednesday. The room is cavernous, the tables are spaced well apart, and the caffeine is high-quality. You’ll have the undivided attention of your client and the staff.
📖 Related: Bed and Breakfast Wedding Venues: Why Smaller Might Actually Be Better
2. Handling the Pre-Theater Crunch
If you are going for dinner before a show, aim for a 5:30 PM reservation. By 6:30 PM, the room is at capacity and the energy shifts from "relaxed luxury" to "efficient glamour." Mention your showtime when you check in; the kitchen is incredibly adept at timing the mains so you aren't sprinting down 44th Street with a mouthful of dessert.
3. The Dress Code Reality
While New York has become increasingly casual, this isn't the place for your gym clothes or a tattered hoodie. You don't need a tuxedo, but a sharp blazer or a well-cut dress fits the "vibe" of the room. You’ll feel more comfortable if you lean into the elegance.
4. Order the Classics
While the seasonal specials are usually great, The Lambs Club is defined by its ability to execute the classics perfectly. The Tartare, the Wedge Salad (elevated, obviously), and the Delmonico Steak are the pillars of the menu for a reason.
5. Check the Jazz Schedule
If you want the full "Supper Club" experience, call ahead or check their digital calendar for live music nights. The acoustics in the room are surprisingly good given the high ceilings and stone fireplace, and it transforms the dinner from a meal into an event.
Ultimately, the reason this place persists in the middle of the most commercialized square mile on earth is simple: it offers a sense of permanence. In a city that changes every fifteen minutes, those red leather booths and the glow of the Stanford White fireplace offer a rare moment of continuity. You aren't just eating dinner; you're participating in a New York tradition that spans three different centuries.
Don't rush the coffee. Stay for one last look at the hearth. The Elmos can wait.