Wait, did that actually just happen? Honestly, if you blinked during the last few months of 2025, you might have missed one of the weirdest legal standoffs in D.C. history. We’re talking about the time the Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE) literally marched into a building, changed the locks, and tried to delete an entire organization.
But then, a judge stepped in.
U.S. District Judge Beryl Howell recently dropped a 102-page hammer on the administration. She ruled that the judge overturns USIP takeover wasn't just a suggestion—it was a full-blown reversal of what she called a "gross usurpation of power." Basically, the government tried to treat a congressionally created institute like a failing lemonade stand they could just shutter overnight.
It didn't fly.
The Day the Locks Changed at USIP
Let’s back up. On February 19, 2025, Executive Order 14217 hit the desk. It labeled the U.S. Institute of Peace (USIP) as "unnecessary."
A month later, things got physical.
Imagine showing up to your office and finding FBI agents and D.C. Metro Police blocking the door. That’s what happened to Ambassador George Moose, the acting president of USIP. DOGE representatives, backed by law enforcement, forced their way in. They didn't just ask for the keys; they took the whole building. They fired almost 300 people via one-sentence emails.
"DOGE has broken into our building," Moose said at the time. He wasn't exaggerating. They even tried to transfer the $500 million headquarters over to the General Services Administration (GSA). It was a total blitz.
🔗 Read more: Senate Majority Leader: Who Really Runs the Upper Chamber in 2026?
Why the Judge Overturns USIP Takeover Matters
So, why did Judge Howell pull the plug on this? It comes down to a boring-sounding but massive legal question: Who actually owns the USIP?
The administration argued that since the President appoints the board, it’s an executive branch agency. If it’s executive, the President can fire everyone. Simple, right?
Not quite.
Howell looked at the 1984 law that created USIP. She found that the institute is a "weird" hybrid. It’s a government entity, sure, but it’s not part of the executive branch. It’s an independent think tank designed to serve both the White House and Congress.
The Legal Three-Step
To decide if USIP was "government" enough to be controlled, the court looked at three things:
- Was it created by a special law? (Yes, in 1984).
- Does it do government work? (Yes, international peace).
- Does the government pick the board? (Yes, mostly).
But—and this is the big "but"—just because it’s a government entity doesn't mean it sits under the President's thumb. Howell compared it to the Smithsonian or a Grand Jury. You can’t just fire a Grand Jury because you don't like their vibe.
By bypassing Congress and using "brute force," the administration overstepped. The judge ruled that the firings were "null and void." It’s like a giant "undo" button for the last two months of chaos.
The Fallout: Empty Desks and Deleted Websites
When DOGE took over, they didn't just stop at the front door. They wiped the USIP website. They cut off staff access to years of research on conflict zones like Iraq and Papua New Guinea.
🔗 Read more: The Triangle Shirtwaist Factory Fire 1911: Why 146 People Had to Die for Modern Labor Laws
When George Moose finally walked back into the building after the ruling, it was eerie. He was escorted by private security and lawyers instead of federal agents. He told reporters that "externally, things look to be in pretty good shape," but the damage to the mission was already done.
The White House isn't happy. Spokeswoman Anna Kelly called Howell a "rogue judge." They’ve already filed an appeal.
What This Means for Other Agencies
This isn't just about one building in D.C. It’s a roadmap for other groups like the Inter-American Foundation and the U.S. African Development Foundation. They’re also in the crosshairs of DOGE.
If USIP can win by proving they aren't "executive," others will try the same move. It’s a massive check on the idea that an Executive Order can dissolve anything with a federal paycheck.
Honestly, the whole situation is a mess. You have one branch of government saying "you're fired" and another saying "actually, no they aren't." For the employees, it’s been a rollercoaster of getting fired by email and then getting "un-fired" by a 100-page legal opinion.
Practical Steps Following the Ruling
If you're following this case or work in the public sector, here is what is actually happening on the ground:
- Reinstatement is Real: The court ordered all staff who want to return to be allowed back. Human resources and IT teams are currently trying to rebuild the digital infrastructure that was wiped during the takeover.
- Asset Recovery: The $500 million headquarters is legally back in the hands of the USIP board, though the GSA transfer remains a point of contention in the ongoing appeals.
- Watch the D.C. Circuit: The administration has already asked for a stay. This means a higher court could pause Howell's ruling, which would put everyone back in legal limbo.
- Audit Your Status: For those in "independent" agencies, now is the time to look at your founding statutes. The specific wording of how board members are removed is now the most important text in Washington.
The battle over the judge overturns USIP takeover is far from over. It’s heading to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit, and potentially the Supreme Court. For now, the lights are back on at the Institute of Peace, but the front door remains a very tense place to be.