Theme restaurants are usually a bit of a disaster. You know the drill. You pay $25 for a burger that tastes like cardboard just so you can sit in a room that looks like a rainforest or a generic pirate ship. It's gimmicky. It's loud. Mostly, it’s forgettable. But the Jekyll & Hyde Club was different, and honestly, it’s kind of a tragedy that the era of the high-concept, animatronic-heavy dining experience has mostly vanished from Manhattan.
When the flagship closed its doors at 91 Seventh Avenue South in Greenwich Village, and then later its massive Times Square location, a specific kind of weirdness left New York. It wasn't just a place to eat; it was a sprawling, multi-story exercise in Gothic horror theater.
The Weird History of Jekyll & Hyde Club
The whole thing was the brainchild of Eerie World Entertainment and its founder, D.R. Finley. He didn't want a restaurant. He wanted an "eerie" experience. Most people don't realize that the brand started relatively small before exploding into the massive, neon-lit tourist magnet on West 44th Street.
The Times Square spot was a beast. It had multiple floors, each themed around different "societies" of the macabre. You had the Grand Salon, the Library, and the Laboratory. It was designed to feel like a private social club for 19th-century explorers who were obsessed with the occult and the scientific.
One of the coolest parts? The actors. Unlike your local chain where the waiter just wears a funny hat, the staff at Jekyll & Hyde were performers. They had names like "Professor Shroud" or "The Baron." They’d drop from the ceiling. They’d pop out of hidden doors. It was basically immersive theater before that became a buzzy marketing term.
👉 See also: Where to Watch Mall Cop 2: How to Find Paul Blart’s Vegas Adventure Right Now
What Made the Experience Actually Work
It wasn't just the live actors. It was the mechanical stuff. The animatronics were genuinely impressive for the time. You’d be mid-bite into a "Create Your Own Monster" burger, and suddenly a skeleton would start talking to you from the wall. Or a massive Sphinx would blink its eyes and tell a joke.
- The Transformation: Every few minutes, the lights would dim. The Laboratory would come to life. Animatronic figures of Dr. Jekyll would undergo the transformation into Mr. Hyde right in front of you.
- The Secret Entrances: You didn't just walk into a lobby. You often had to find a hidden door or interact with a "gatekeeper" to even get to your table.
- The Atmosphere: It was dark. Intentionally dusty. Smelled like fog machines and old wood.
The Jekyll & Hyde Club thrived because it leaned into the "corny" factor but executed it with high-budget production values. It was a theme restaurant that actually understood its theme. It wasn't just a name on the door; it was a commitment to the bit.
The Problem With Modern Theme Dining
Why don't we see things like this anymore? Money. High-end animatronics are expensive to maintain. Actors need unions. Real estate in Times Square is, frankly, soul-crushing for small or mid-sized entertainment groups. Most modern "themed" spots now rely on "Instagrammable" walls—basically just a neon sign and some fake flowers—because it’s cheaper than building a moving mechanical gargoyle.
But the Jekyll & Hyde Club proved that people crave the physical. They want to be startled. They want a story. Even if the food—let’s be real here—was just okay, the memories of a talking portrait making fun of your outfit stayed with you way longer than a fancy meal at a Michelin-star spot.
The Slow Decline and the Final Move
The downfall of the Jekyll & Hyde Club is a bit of a saga. The Times Square location was massive, which meant the rent was astronomical. In 2012, they moved from that iconic spot to a smaller location near 7th Avenue. It felt different. Smaller. A bit more cramped.
Then came the legal and financial troubles. By 2022, the restaurant was facing a massive eviction notice for hundreds of thousands of dollars in unpaid rent. The COVID-19 pandemic was the final nail in the coffin for a lot of tourist-heavy spots, and Jekyll & Hyde was hit harder than most. People weren't traveling to New York to sit in dark, enclosed spaces with actors shouting at them.
When the West Village location finally shuttered, it marked the end of an era. The props were auctioned off. The animatronics that used to terrify kids were boxed up or sold to collectors. It’s kind of a bummer to think about those pieces of NYC history sitting in someone’s basement.
What People Got Wrong About the Brand
A lot of critics dismissed it as a tourist trap. Sure, it was. But it was a good tourist trap. It offered something that wasn't just a souvenir t-shirt. It offered a collective experience. If you were there with a group of friends, you were all in on the joke.
✨ Don't miss: The Truth About Captain Lewis Nixon: Why Band of Brothers Left Out the Most Interesting Parts
There was a level of craftsmanship in the "Library" section that you just don't see in modern commercial design. Thousands of fake books, intricate wood carvings, and hidden levers. It was a physical manifestation of a Gothic novel.
Actionable Steps for the Themed Entertainment Fan
If you miss the vibe of the Jekyll & Hyde Club, you aren't totally out of luck. New York still has pockets of this weirdness, even if the giant club is gone.
1. Seek Out the Remaining "Eerie" Spots: While Jekyll & Hyde is gone, places like Beetle House in the East Village carry the torch. It’s a Tim Burton-themed bar and restaurant that focuses heavily on costumed characters and dark aesthetics. It's smaller, but the spirit is similar.
2. Visit the Lovecraft Bar: For those who liked the literary horror aspect of the club, Lovecraft (if you can find their latest pop-up or permanent residency) offers that Cthulhu-inspired atmosphere.
3. Watch the Auction Circuits: Occasionally, pieces from the original Jekyll & Hyde Club pop up on sites like eBay or specialized prop auctions. If you want a piece of the Laboratory, you have to be fast.
4. Explore Immersive Theater: If it was the actors you loved, look into shows like Sleep No More. It’s the high-brow version of what the club was doing—non-linear storytelling in a massive, themed building.
The Jekyll & Hyde Club was a chaotic, loud, and slightly overpriced piece of New York City history. It was a place where you could be a kid again, or at least a very entertained adult. It reminded us that dining out doesn't always have to be about the acidity of the wine or the provenance of the kale. Sometimes, it’s just about a guy in a cape scaring you while you eat fries.