If you’ve ever found yourself driving down a deserted highway at 2:00 AM with nothing but the hum of the tires and a hazy radio signal, you’ve probably felt the pull of the Isley Brothers. Specifically, that velvet-draped, slow-motion masterpiece: Choosey Lover.
It’s a song that doesn’t just play; it lingers. It’s the sonic equivalent of a silk robe or a glass of expensive bourbon. But while we all know the hook, most people don’t realize that this track was actually a desperate "hail mary" from a band that was literally falling apart at the seams.
The High Stakes of 1983
By the early '80s, the Isley Brothers were in a weird spot. They were legends, sure. They’d conquered the '60s with "Shout" and the '70s with "That Lady." But the "3+3" lineup—the legendary configuration of the three older brothers (Ronald, Rudolph, Kelly) and the three younger ones (Ernie, Marvin, Chris Jasper)—was hitting a wall.
Their previous two albums, Inside You and The Real Deal, hadn’t exactly set the world on fire. In fact, they kind of flopped. Music was changing. Prince was rising. Michael Jackson was moonwalking. The Isleys felt like they were becoming "your uncle’s favorite band," which is a death sentence in the industry.
They needed a hit. Badly.
So, they retreated to Bearsville Studios in Woodstock, New York. They weren't looking for a "vibe." They were looking for survival. What came out was the Between the Sheets album, and while the title track became the monster hit, Choosey Lover was the soul of the record.
That "Devotion" Connection
Here is a bit of trivia that usually shocks casual fans: Choosey Lover wasn't a totally original idea. Honestly, the melody is a massive nod—some might say a total borrow—from Earth, Wind & Fire’s 1974 classic "Devotion."
🔗 Read more: How Old Is Paul Heyman? The Real Story of Wrestling’s Greatest Mind
Chris Jasper, the keyboard wizard of the family, has been open about this. The band was listening to what their peers were doing. They saw how Philip Bailey’s falsetto and those lush harmonies were working, and they decided to refine that sound into something darker and more intimate.
While "Devotion" feels like a spiritual awakening in a church, Choosey Lover feels like a private conversation in a dimly lit bedroom. It’s slower. It’s heavier. Ernie Isley’s guitar work on this track isn't the Hendrix-style fire he usually brought; it’s restrained, punctuated with those clean, weeping notes that define the "Quiet Storm" genre.
The Secret History of the Lyrics
For decades, fans wondered who Ronald Isley was singing about. Who was this "friend" who tried to steal his lady? Who was the person that made him "kinda choosey" about who he gives his heart to?
Fast forward to April 2025. Ron Isley finally dropped the bombshell during a viral clip that set the internet on fire. He admitted that the song was inspired by none other than Bobby Womack.
Yeah. Bobby Womack.
Apparently, Womack—a legendary singer in his own right but also a notorious "stealer of hearts"—had been a bit too friendly with a woman Ron was seeing. Ron wrote those lyrics as a direct warning. When he sings, "Thought I had a lover, but I was kiddin' myself," he’s not just being poetic. He was talking about a real-life betrayal. Knowing that it’s a diss track hidden inside a love song makes every listen hit a little differently.
💡 You might also like: Howie Mandel Cupcake Picture: What Really Happened With That Viral Post
Aaliyah and the Hip-Hop Handover
You can't talk about the Isley Brothers Choosey Lover without talking about the 90s. If the Isleys invented the vibe, the 90s hip-hop and R&B generation perfected the worship of it.
Aaliyah’s 1996 cover on her One in a Million album is probably how half the people reading this discovered the song. She split it into "Old School" and "New School," starting with a near-perfect recreation of the Isley original before Timbaland’s production kicked in for the flip.
But it didn't stop there.
- Nas sampled it for the remix of "Street Dreams" with R. Kelly.
- Bone Thugs-n-Harmony slowed it down for "Buddah Lovaz."
- Keith Sweat basically built a career on the vocal blueprints Ron Isley laid down in this track.
It became the gold standard for "cool." If you were a rapper and you wanted to show you had a sensitive side (or just wanted to get played on the radio after midnight), you sampled the Isleys.
Why the Song Ended an Era
The irony of Choosey Lover is that it was the last time this version of the band would ever truly click.
Shortly after the album dropped and the song climbed to #6 on the R&B charts, the "3+3" lineup shattered. Taxes, internal ego clashes, and creative differences boiled over. Ernie, Marvin, and Chris Jasper left to form Isley-Jasper-Isley (giving us "Caravan of Love"). Ronald, Rudolph, and Kelly were left to carry the name.
📖 Related: Austin & Ally Maddie Ziegler Episode: What Really Happened in Homework & Hidden Talents
It was the end of the greatest run in R&B history.
Looking back, you can almost hear the tension in the track. It’s so polished, so precise, because they knew they were at a crossroads. They weren't just making a song; they were documenting a legacy before the lights went out.
How to Listen Properly
If you really want to appreciate the genius of the Isley Brothers Choosey Lover, you have to stop listening to it on tinny phone speakers.
- Find the Original Vinyl or a High-Res Stream: You need to hear the separation between Chris Jasper’s synthesizers and Marvin’s bass.
- Focus on the Background Vocals: The Isleys were masters of the "choir of one" technique. Those "oohs" and "aahs" aren't just filler; they are layered to create a wall of sound that feels like a warm blanket.
- Listen for the Drum Machine: This was 1983. They were moving away from live drums toward the LinnDrum and programmed beats. Notice how the mechanical "thwack" of the drum machine contrasts with the organic soul of Ron’s voice. It shouldn't work, but it does.
Actionable Insight:
Next time you're building a playlist for a dinner party or a late-night drive, don't just throw on the "top hits." Contrast the original 1983 Isley version of Choosey Lover with Aaliyah’s 1996 version and Nas’s "Street Dreams" remix. You’ll hear thirty years of Black music history unfolding in the exact same four-bar loop. It’s the ultimate lesson in how great songwriting never actually dies; it just changes clothes.
Next Steps for Your Collection:
Compare the production of Between the Sheets to their earlier work like The Heat Is On. You'll notice a distinct shift from "Rock-Funk" to "Digital Soul" that defined the entire 1980s R&B landscape. This transition is exactly why the Isleys managed to stay relevant while their contemporaries faded into the "oldies" bin.