Why The Imitation of Christ Still Bothers People 600 Years Later

Why The Imitation of Christ Still Bothers People 600 Years Later

Thomas à Kempis didn't write a self-help book. He wrote a manual for spiritual survival that feels like a cold bucket of water to the face. Honestly, it’s a bit jarring. You pick up The Imitation of Christ expecting some gentle, Hallmark-style encouragement, but what you get is a ruthless deconstruction of the human ego. It’s the second most-read book in Christian history after the Bible. That isn't an accident. People keep coming back to it because it addresses the one thing we usually try to ignore: our obsession with ourselves.

The book emerged from a 14th-century movement called the Devotio Moderna. This wasn't about flashy miracles or complex theology. It was about "the modern devotion," a push toward interior depth and practical humility. While the world around the authors was dealing with the literal plague and the Great Schism of the Church, these guys were sitting in cells in the Netherlands, writing about how to stop caring what your neighbors think of you. It's incredibly relevant today. We live in a digital panopticon where every move is tracked and performed. Thomas à Kempis is basically over in the corner whispering, "None of that matters."

What The Imitation of Christ Gets Right About Our Ego

Modern life is loud. We are constantly told to build our brand, find our voice, and stand out. The Imitation of Christ says the exact opposite. It tells you to "love to be unknown." That is a radical, almost offensive idea in 2026. If you aren't known, do you even exist? According to the Devotio Moderna, that’s exactly when you start to exist in a way that actually counts.

Most people think of humility as having a low opinion of yourself. That’s a mistake. True humility, according to this text, is simply having a realistic opinion of yourself. It’s about seeing yourself without the filters. Thomas à Kempis argues that we spend so much energy defending our reputation that we have no energy left for actual growth. It's exhausting.

Think about the last time someone criticized you. Your heart rate probably went up. You started rehearsing a defense in your head. You wanted to prove them wrong. The Imitation of Christ suggests a different path: just let it go. It’s a sort of spiritual stoicism. If what they say is true, fix it. If it’s false, it doesn't change who you are before God anyway. It sounds simple. It is actually the hardest thing in the world to do.

The Problem With Learning and Intellectual Pride

We value knowledge. We spend thousands of dollars on degrees and hours scrolling for "insights." But the book hits us with a stinging reminder: "A humble peasant who serves God is better than a proud philosopher who studies the courses of the stars while neglecting himself."

Ouch.

👉 See also: Sport watch water resist explained: why 50 meters doesn't mean you can dive

The point isn't that being smart is bad. It’s that knowledge without character is a trap. It creates a "smoke of the mind" that makes us feel superior to others. Thomas warns that on the day of judgment, we won't be asked what we've read, but how we've lived. We won't be asked how eloquently we spoke, but how holy we were. This isn't just religious fluff; it's a psychological reality. We often use "learning" as a way to avoid doing the actual work of being a better person. It’s easier to read a book about patience than it is to be patient with a difficult co-worker.

Why the Authorship Was a Massive Controversy

For a long time, people weren't even sure who wrote The Imitation of Christ. For centuries, it was attributed to various figures, including Saint Bernard of Clairvaux or a mysterious "Abbot John Gersen." Eventually, the consensus landed on Thomas à Kempis, a monk from the Mount Saint Agnes monastery.

This uncertainty is actually poetic.

The book preaches anonymity, so the fact that its author remained a mystery for so long fits the theme perfectly. Thomas was a copyist. He spent his days hand-writing manuscripts. You can see that influence in the rhythm of the prose. It’s repetitive in the way a heartbeat is repetitive. It’s meant to be chewed on, not swallowed whole. It’s "rumination," a term the monks used to describe the way a cow chews its cud. You take a sentence, you think about it all day, you let it sink into your bones.

Life in the "Devotio Moderna"

To understand the text, you have to understand the environment. The Brothers of the Common Life, the group Thomas belonged to, were unique. They didn't take monastic vows in the traditional sense. They lived together, worked together, and pooled their money. They were practical.

They weren't interested in the scholastic debates happening at the University of Paris. They didn't care about how many angels could dance on the head of a pin. They cared about whether or not you were kind to the person sitting across from you at dinner. This "practicality" is what makes the book so accessible. It doesn't use jargon. It uses the language of the heart.

✨ Don't miss: Pink White Nail Studio Secrets and Why Your Manicure Isn't Lasting

  1. It focuses on the interior life.
  2. It emphasizes the "via negativa"—stripping away distractions.
  3. It demands radical honesty with oneself.
  4. It centers everything on the person of Jesus as a living template, not just a historical figure.

The "Hard Sayings" That Make Readers Cringe

Let's be real: some parts of The Imitation of Christ are tough to swallow. It talks a lot about "contempt for the world." To a modern ear, that sounds like being a hater. It sounds like someone who doesn't appreciate art, or food, or friendship.

But that's a surface-level reading.

When Thomas talks about "contempt," he’s talking about priority. He’s saying that if you look for ultimate satisfaction in a promotion, or a relationship, or a vacation, you are going to be disappointed every single time. Those things are "passing." They are "vanity." The word vanity here isn't about looking in the mirror; it’s the Latin vanitas, meaning "vapor" or "mist." It’s something that looks solid but disappears when you try to grab it.

  • "Great tranquility of heart is his who cares for neither praise nor blame."
  • "He is truly great who has great charity."
  • "Without the way, there is no going; without the truth, there is no knowing; without the life, there is no living."

The book is divided into four parts. The first two deal with the "purgative" stage—getting rid of the junk in your soul. The third part is a long, intimate dialogue between "The Voice of Christ" and "The Disciple." It’s deeply emotional. The fourth part focuses on the Eucharist, or Holy Communion. Even if you aren't Catholic or even religious, the psychological insights in the third book are staggering. It maps out the inner tug-of-war between our desires and our conscience with surgical precision.

Is it too "Gloomy"?

Critics often say the book is too focused on suffering. It does talk about the "Royal Road of the Holy Cross." It doesn't promise that following a spiritual path will make your life easy. In fact, it suggests it might make it harder.

But there’s a strange joy in it.

🔗 Read more: Hairstyles for women over 50 with round faces: What your stylist isn't telling you

It’s the joy of someone who has stopped trying to control the world. There’s a massive relief in realizing you don't have to be the protagonist of every story. When you stop trying to be "the man" or "the woman" of the hour, you can finally just be yourself. It’s a paradox. By dying to the "self," you actually find a more authentic version of who you are.

How to Actually Read This Without Getting Depressed

If you try to read this book like a novel, you’ll quit by page twenty. It’s too dense. It’s like eating a jar of bouillon cubes instead of making soup. You have to dilute it with your own life.

The best way to approach it is one "chapter" at a time. Some chapters are only half a page long. Read it in the morning. Let it annoy you. Let it challenge that defensive posture you take when you check your emails.

Actionable Insights for the Modern Reader

  • Practice "Hiddenness": Try to do something good today that absolutely nobody will find out about. No social media post. No mentioning it in conversation. Just do it and let it stay secret. See how that feels.
  • Audit Your "Learning": Are you consuming information to grow, or just to feel superior? Try cutting out one "intellectual" pursuit that is actually just a source of pride and replace it with a manual task or an act of service.
  • The 24-Hour Silence Rule: When someone says something that hurts your feelings or attacks your reputation, wait 24 hours before defending yourself. In most cases, you’ll realize the defense isn't even necessary.
  • Focus on the "Interior Cell": Thomas says, "The cell, if stayed in, becomes sweet." Create a space in your day—even just ten minutes—where there is no noise, no phone, and no agenda. Just sit with your own thoughts and the presence of something bigger than you.

The Imitation of Christ isn't about becoming a perfect, robotic saint. It's about becoming human again. It’s about stripping away the layers of performance and pretension that we’ve spent years building up. It’s uncomfortable, it’s demanding, and it’s arguably the most honest book you’ll ever read. If you’re tired of the constant noise of "self-optimization," maybe it’s time to try self-denial instead. It’s a much shorter path to peace.

Start with Book One, Chapter One. Don't worry about the 15th-century language. Focus on the intent. The human heart hasn't changed in 600 years. We still want the same things—peace, meaning, and a sense of belonging—and we still look for them in all the wrong places. This book is just a very old, very reliable map back to the right place.