Ice cream is weirdly emotional. Think about it. We don't just eat it; we experience it, usually attached to a specific memory of a boardwalk, a breakup, or a sweltering July afternoon. This is why The Ice Cream Show on Vice (and later across various streaming platforms) resonated so much more than your standard, polished Food Network fare. It wasn't just about the dairy. It was a chaotic, sticky, sugar-fueled roadmap of American culture.
Host Isaac Lappert—a third-generation ice cream maker from the legendary Lappert’s family—brought a level of technical street cred that most "food hosts" lack. He knew why the butterfat mattered. He understood the physics of a slow-churned batch. But more importantly, he looked at ice cream as a lens to view cities like Los Angeles, New York, and San Francisco.
Honestly? It's the best travel show that nobody mentions enough anymore.
What Made The Ice Cream Show Different
Most food television feels like a commercial. You know the vibe: high-contrast lighting, a host over-enunciating how "crunchy" something is, and a clean resolution. The Ice Cream Show felt like a road trip with a friend who happens to be obsessed with gelato. It was gritty. It was filmed in the back of cramped kitchens where the floors were probably a bit tacky from spilled syrup.
Isaac’s background is the anchor. If you’ve ever been to Sausalito or Palm Springs and stood in line for a scoop of Kauai Pie, you know the Lappert name. Isaac didn’t just show up to eat; he showed up to talk shop with artisans. When he visited places like Salt & Straw in Portland or Morgenstern’s in NYC, the conversation wasn't just "this tastes good." They talked about stabilizers. They talked about the risk of using real goat cheese in a scoop. They talked about why some flavors fail.
The LA Episode and the "Cool" Factor
Take the Los Angeles episode. LA is a city defined by trends, and ice cream is no exception. We saw the rise of Thai-style rolled ice cream, which, let’s be real, is mostly about the "gram" and less about the texture. Isaac explored the tension between these flashy new-school spots and the institutions that have been there for decades.
It’s about the people behind the counter. The show highlighted that ice cream is one of the few remaining "pure" businesses. It's hard to be a jerk when you're selling a cone. You see the passion in someone like Tyler Malek from Salt & Straw, who treats flavor profiles like a mad scientist. The show captured that specific energy—the intersection of culinary art and childhood nostalgia.
👉 See also: Nothing to Lose: Why the Martin Lawrence and Tim Robbins Movie is Still a 90s Classic
Why We Are Still Obsessed With "Artisan" Scoops
The show aired during a massive shift in how we consume dessert. We moved away from the "big tub" mentality of the grocery store aisle and toward the $12 pint. Why? Because we're looking for an experience. The Ice Cream Show documented this "premiumization" of the industry perfectly.
- Texture is king. Isaac often pointed out the difference between "overrun" (the air whipped into ice cream) in cheap brands versus the dense, rich mouthfeel of high-end batches.
- The savory pivot. We saw flavors like olive oil, bone marrow, and blue cheese. The show didn't mock these; it explained why the fat content in those ingredients actually makes sense in a frozen medium.
- Hyper-locality. Using milk from a specific dairy farm three miles away isn't just marketing—it changes the flavor profile based on what the cows are eating.
It's fascinating. Really.
You’ve got guys like Nick Morgenstern who are basically engineering ice cream from the ground up, rethinking the sugar content so it doesn't mask the actual bean-to-bar chocolate. The show gave these creators a platform to be nerds. It validated the idea that ice cream could be as sophisticated as wine or specialty coffee.
The Cultural Impact of the "Scoop Shop"
One thing The Ice Cream Show nailed was the atmosphere of the shops. In the New York City segments, you see how these spaces act as community hubs. In a city where everyone is rushing, the ice cream shop is a forced pause. You have to eat it before it melts. You can’t really do much else.
It's a "third place." Not home, not work.
The show also didn't shy away from the history. It touched on the African American contribution to ice cream history—like Augustus Jackson, the "Father of Ice Cream," who was a White House confectioner in the 1830s. This isn't just fluffy TV; it’s a look at how a luxury for the elite became the most democratic dessert in the world.
✨ Don't miss: How Old Is Paul Heyman? The Real Story of Wrestling’s Greatest Mind
The Reality of Running an Ice Cream Business
Let’s talk shop for a second because the show actually touched on the brutal reality of the business. It’s not all sprinkles.
- Seasonality is a killer. If you’re in a climate like Chicago or New York, you have to make your entire year’s profit in four months. The show subtly highlighted how shops pivot to coffee or hot desserts to survive January.
- The Supply Chain. High-quality vanilla is expensive. Like, "should I get a loan for this" expensive. When the show visited producers, you saw the stress of sourcing real ingredients versus artificial extracts.
- Labor. Hand-scooping is physically exhausting. It’s a repetitive motion injury waiting to happen.
Isaac’s empathy for the workers made the show feel grounded. He’s been in the pits. He knows what it’s like when the compressor breaks at 2:00 AM and you’re about to lose $5,000 worth of product. That "insider" perspective is what gave the series its E-E-A-T (Experience, Expertise, Authoritativeness, and Trustworthiness) before that was even a buzzword people cared about.
Why It Ended and Where to Find That Vibe Now
Vice went through a lot of changes, and many of their niche food shows got lost in the shuffle. The Ice Cream Show was a casualty of a shifting media landscape. But the "food travel" genre it helped refine lives on. You see its DNA in shows like Somebody Feed Phil or The Bear, where the setting and the process matter just as much as the final plate.
If you’re looking to scratch that itch today, you basically have to go to the source. Follow the makers.
The industry has moved toward transparency. People want to see the "back of house." They want to see the mess. They want to see the 50-gallon drum of fresh strawberries being prepped. That’s what the show gave us—a backstage pass to the most joyful industry on earth.
Real-World Insights for the Ice Cream Enthusiast
If you want to eat like Isaac Lappert, you have to stop ordering the same old vanilla. Look for shops that do their own base from scratch. Most "artisan" shops actually buy a pre-made mix from a large dairy and just add flavors. The real ones? They pasteurize their own milk and cream.
🔗 Read more: Howie Mandel Cupcake Picture: What Really Happened With That Viral Post
Ask the person behind the counter: "Do you make your own base?"
If the answer is yes, you're in the right place. Look for "low overrun." If the ice cream feels heavy and hard to scoop, that’s actually a good sign. It means you’re getting more dairy and less air.
Also, don't sleep on the "weird" flavors. A shop that can make a balsamic strawberry or a sweet corn ice cream taste balanced is a shop that knows its chemistry. It’s easy to hide bad technique behind chocolate chips. It’s impossible to hide it in a delicate herbal infusion.
Actionable Steps for Your Next Scoop
Next time you’re traveling, skip the Yelp "Best Of" lists for a minute. Do what the show did:
- Find the institution. Every city has that one shop that’s been there for 60 years. Go there first to establish a baseline.
- Find the disruptor. Look for the shop that’s doing something "wrong"—maybe they’re using liquid nitrogen, or maybe they’re focused entirely on vegan nut-based milks.
- Talk to the scooper. Ask them what flavor they’re actually proud of, not just what sells the most.
- Check the temperature. Ice cream should be served at about 6°F to 10°F. If it’s rock hard, it’s too cold; if it’s soupy, the freezer is struggling.
The Ice Cream Show reminded us that food is a story. It’s a story of immigration, of family legacies, and of pure, unadulterated chemistry. Even if we don’t get new episodes, the blueprint is there. Get out, find a local maker, and ask them why they do it. The answer is usually more interesting than the topping.
Go support your local creamery. Buy a pint of something that sounds slightly intimidating. Taste the butterfat. That’s how you keep the spirit of the show alive.