If you’re a 90s kid, you probably remember the yellow slicker. You remember the hook. And honestly, you definitely remember the absolute panic of Jennifer Love Hewitt screaming at the sky. For decades, the slasher genre lived on VHS tapes and late-night cable reruns, but things have changed. Collectibles are the new king of the box office. Specifically, the I Know What You Did Last Summer popcorn bucket is becoming a focal point for horror fans as Sony Pictures gears up for a massive franchise revival.
It's weird, right? Popcorn buckets used to be cheap plastic tubs you threw away immediately. Now, they're high-art commodities that people flip on eBay for three times the retail price.
The Slasher Revival and the Merch Craze
We've seen the Scream buckets. We saw the viral frenzy over the Dune sandworm. It was only a matter of time before the Fisherman got his due. With the new I Know What You Did Last Summer sequel officially slated for a 2025 release, the marketing machine is leaning heavily into nostalgia. Jennifer Kaytin Robinson is directing, and both Jennifer Love Hewitt and Freddie Prinze Jr. have been in talks to return. This isn't just a reboot; it’s a legacy sequel. That means the merch has to hit that sweet spot between 1997 aesthetics and 2026 collector demands.
Collectors are obsessive. They want texture. They want specific references. A basic bucket with a sticker won't cut it anymore. Fans are speculating on designs that incorporate Ben Willis’s iconic hook or perhaps a translucent "water" effect to mimic the docks of Southport.
What Makes a Great Horror Bucket?
Think about what makes a collectible actually "viral." It’s usually something slightly tactile or even a bit grotesque. For an I Know What You Did Last Summer popcorn bucket, the most obvious design choice is the Fisherman’s hat. Imagine a molded lid shaped like a weathered, black sou'wester rain hat. Underneath? Your popcorn.
But there's more potential here. Some early whispers in collector circles suggest a "trunk" design. Remember the scene where Max’s body is covered in crabs in the back of the car? A bucket shaped like a vintage 90s car trunk, complete with a "scare" feature, would be a holy grail for slasher fans.
The industry has shifted. Cinema chains like AMC and Regal aren't just selling snacks; they’re selling "event" containers. For a film like this, which relies so heavily on atmospheric Northwest gloom, the bucket needs to feel damp, dark, and dangerous.
💡 You might also like: Disney Tim Burton's The Nightmare Before Christmas Light Trail: Is the New York Botanical Garden Event Worth Your Money?
Why the Fisherman Design is Crucial
Ben Willis is an underrated slasher icon. He doesn't have the mask of Michael Myers or the burnt skin of Freddy. He has a silhouette. That silhouette—the long coat and the hook—is what needs to translate to the I Know What You Did Last Summer popcorn bucket.
If the studio goes with a "Hook" handle, it changes the utility of the bucket. It becomes a display piece.
I’ve talked to vendors who handle movie theater supplies, and they say the lead time for these custom molds is nearly a year. That means if we're seeing the movie in the summer of 2025 or early 2026, those designs are being finalized right now in a boardroom somewhere. They’re looking at Pantone shades of "Slicker Yellow" and "Deep Sea Black."
History of Horror Collectibles
Horror fans are the most loyal spenders in the industry. Look at the Terrifier 3 popcorn buckets or the Ghostface lanterns. They sell out in pre-orders. I Know What You Did Last Summer hasn't had a major theatrical presence in a long time. The 2021 Amazon series was a blip. This new film is a return to the roots.
The bucket is a bridge. It connects the 1997 original movie to the modern theater-going experience.
Where to Buy and How to Avoid Scalpers
If you want the I Know What You Did Last Summer popcorn bucket, you have to be fast. Usually, these drop a week before the premiere.
📖 Related: Diego Klattenhoff Movies and TV Shows: Why He’s the Best Actor You Keep Forgetting You Know
Don't wait for opening night. By the time the 7:00 PM Thursday preview rolls around, the "Pro-collectors" (scalpers) have usually cleaned out the inventory. Most theaters allow you to buy the bucket at the concession stand without a movie ticket.
- Check the App: Regal and AMC often list their "Limited Edition" vessels in the "Rewards" or "Merchandise" section of their apps.
- Early Arrival: Go to the theater on a Tuesday or Wednesday afternoon before the film opens.
- Online Exclusives: Sometimes, Cinemark drops a variant online that you can't get in person.
The secondary market is brutal. A bucket that costs $25 at the counter will be $85 on Mercari by midnight. If you miss the initial drop, wait about three weeks. The hype usually cools off, and prices stabilize once the "must-have" dopamine hit wears off for the general public.
The Technical Side of the Mold
Creating these isn't just about "plastic." High-end buckets use food-grade ABS plastic with matte finishes. For the I Know What You Did Last Summer popcorn bucket, designers have to worry about the "Hook." If it's too sharp, it's a safety hazard. If it's too blunt, it looks like a toy.
The balance is tricky. You want something that looks like it could belong on a rain-slicked pier but won't poke a hole in your leg while you're sitting in a recliner seat.
Real Talk: Is it Worth the Hype?
Look, it’s a plastic container. Let’s be real. But it’s also a piece of nostalgia. For people who grew up with Julie James and Ray Bronson, this is a way to reclaim a piece of their childhood. The original movie was a massive hit, grossing over $125 million on a tiny budget. It defined the post-Scream era of horror.
Getting a high-quality I Know What You Did Last Summer popcorn bucket feels like a victory for a fandom that was ignored for two decades. We’ve had endless Halloween and Friday the 13th merch. It’s finally time for the hook.
👉 See also: Did Mac Miller Like Donald Trump? What Really Happened Between the Rapper and the President
Future of the Franchise
This bucket is just the start. If the 2025/2026 film performs, expect a wave of 90s slasher merch. We’re talking Urban Legend collectibles, maybe even a Final Destination Rube Goldberg-style drink cup.
The "vessel" trend isn't slowing down. It's the only way theaters can compete with streaming. You can't get a physical, molded Fisherman's hook bucket on Netflix. You have to go to the cinema for that.
Practical Steps for Collectors
If you are serious about snagging this piece of horror history, here is exactly what you need to do:
Follow the official social media accounts for AMC Theatres and Regal Movies. They usually post a "teaser" video of the bucket rotating on a pedestal about 14 days before the movie drops. Set a calendar alert for the "Early Access" screenings. Most importantly, call your local theater manager two days before the film opens and ask if they’ve "checked in" the promotional inventory yet. Sometimes they’ll sell them early if you ask nicely and the POS system allows it.
Once you get it, keep the receipt. If you ever decide to sell it, having the original theater tag or a clean bottom-stamp proves it isn't one of the inevitable knock-offs that will pop up on overseas retail sites. Keep it out of direct sunlight to prevent the "Slicker Yellow" or black paint from fading. Use it for your home movie nights, or just put it on the shelf and let the Fisherman watch over your living room.