Why the House of Tyrell GoT Arc Still Bothers Fans Seven Years Later

Why the House of Tyrell GoT Arc Still Bothers Fans Seven Years Later

Growing strong. That’s the motto. It sounds like a gardening slogan, doesn't it? But for anyone who actually watched the House of Tyrell GoT journey, those words weren't about roses or fertilizer. They were about a slow-burn, terrifyingly efficient rise to power that almost—almost—won the whole game.

Then came the wildfire.

Most people look back at Highgarden and see the gold, the silk, and the polite smiles. They see Margaery’s low-cut dresses and Loras’s polished armor. But if you really dig into the lore George R.R. Martin built, and the way HBO adapted it, the Tyrells were the only ones playing the game with their brains instead of just their swords. They weren't like the Starks, who were too honorable to live, or the Lannisters, who were too hateful to be loved. The Tyrells were different. They were the masters of the "soft power" pivot.

And then the show just... ended them.


The Reach: More Than Just a Pretty Garden

Let’s be real for a second. Without the Reach, King’s Landing would have starved to death in Season 2. Period.

The House of Tyrell GoT influence didn't come from a magical bloodline or dragons. It came from grain. It came from being the breadbasket of Westeros. While the North was freezing and the Riverlands were being burned to a crisp by the Mountain, the Tyrells were sitting on the most fertile land in the Seven Kingdoms.

Olenna Tyrell, played by the legendary Diana Rigg, knew this better than anyone. She basically admitted that her family were "upjumped stewards." They weren't the original Kings of the Reach; that was House Gardener. When Aegon the Conqueror turned the Gardeners into human barbecue at the Field of Fire, the Tyrells—who were just the guys holding the keys to Highgarden—basically said, "Hey, we’ll take over if that’s cool with you."

It was.

🔗 Read more: All I Watch for Christmas: What You’re Missing About the TBS Holiday Tradition

That history is vital because it explains their insecurity and their ambition. They always felt they had to prove they belonged. They didn't have the 8,000-year history of the Starks. They had money and food. In a world where winter is coming, having the food is a pretty good hand to play. Honestly, it’s the only hand that matters.

Margaery Tyrell: The Queen Who Should Have Been

If you want to talk about the House of Tyrell GoT impact, you have to talk about Margaery. Natalie Dormer brought a nuance to this role that the books (where she's younger and less of a POV focus) didn't always highlight.

Margaery wasn't just a "pretty face" used for a political marriage. She was a PR genius. Think about it. She went into the slums of King's Landing—places Cersei wouldn't touch with a ten-foot pole—and actually talked to the poor. She fed them. She touched the orphans. Was it performative? Probably. Did it work? Absolutely.

She understood that the power of the throne doesn't just come from the person sitting on it, but from the consent of the people underneath it. Cersei ruled by fear; Margaery wanted to rule by adoration. It’s a much more stable way to keep your head.

The dynamic between Margaery and Tommen was actually kind of fascinating. She managed to wrap that boy around her finger not just through sex, but through kindness. She gave him the agency Cersei always denied him. Watching her outmaneuver Cersei in Season 5 was like watching a grandmaster play chess against someone who just wants to flip the board.

And that’s exactly what happened. Cersei flipped the board.

The Great Sept of Baelor: A Narrative Dead End?

We have to talk about the explosion. It’s one of the most stunning sequences in television history. The music, the tension, the green glow. But from a storytelling perspective, was it a mistake for the House of Tyrell GoT storyline?

💡 You might also like: Al Pacino Angels in America: Why His Roy Cohn Still Terrifies Us

A lot of fans think so.

In one single moment, an entire Great House was wiped out. Margaery, Loras, Mace—gone. It felt cheap. You spent six seasons watching these people weave this intricate web, only for it to be solved by a literal "delete" button. Margaery was the only person in that room who knew something was wrong. She saw the trap. She tried to get everyone out. But the High Sparrow’s arrogance kept them there.

There’s a massive irony in the Tyrells being undone by a religious fanatic they helped empower. They funded the crown, they tolerated the faith, and eventually, the faith and the crown’s debt swallowed them whole.

But the real tragedy wasn't just the deaths. It was what happened after.

The Fall of Highgarden and the "Bad" Strategy

Season 7 saw the final end of the House of Tyrell. This is where the writing gets a bit shaky for some. Olenna is back at Highgarden, and the Lannister army just... walks in?

Jamie Lannister leads a force that takes the seat of the Reach in what feels like a ten-minute montage. Olenna herself notes that her people were never great at fighting. "Flowers on our shields," she says. But come on. Highgarden is a fortress. The Tyrells had the largest army in the Seven Kingdoms.

The idea that they would fall that easily felt like the showrunners were just rushing to clear the board for the final showdown between Dany and Cersei. It’s one of those moments where the logic of the world takes a backseat to the needs of the plot.

📖 Related: Adam Scott in Step Brothers: Why Derek is Still the Funniest Part of the Movie

However, we did get the "Tell Cersei it was me" scene.

If there is any scene that justifies the existence of the House of Tyrell GoT arc in the later seasons, it’s Olenna’s death. Chugging poisoned wine and then casually admitting she murdered the King (Joffrey) while the guy who loved that King is standing right there? That is some top-tier spite. It showed that even in defeat, the Tyrells were sharper than the Lannisters. They won the moral and intellectual war, even if they lost the physical one.

What We Can Learn From the Tyrell Strategy

When you look at the House of Tyrell GoT history, there are actually some pretty legit real-world takeaways about power. They weren't just fictional characters; they represented a specific type of political philosophy.

  1. Soft Power Trumps Hard Power (Usually): Being loved makes you harder to kill. If Cersei hadn't been a literal Queen with wildfire, she never could have touched Margaery because the people would have rioted.
  2. Diversify Your Assets: The Tyrells didn't just have gold; they had the supply chain. In any crisis, the person who controls the food wins.
  3. The Danger of Proxies: They tried to use Joffrey, then Tommen, then the High Sparrow to get what they wanted. Eventually, one of those proxies is going to bite you.

The Tyrells are often overlooked because they don't have the "cool" factor of the direwolves or the dragons. They're just people. Wealthy, smart, slightly manipulative people. But in the context of Westeros, they were the most "modern" house. They weren't obsessed with ancient prophecies or blood magic. They were obsessed with the future.

Why the Books Might Be Different

It's worth noting that in the A Song of Ice and Fire books, the House of Tyrell is in a much stronger position. There are more Tyrell brothers (Willas and Garlan) who are actually quite competent. Willas is a brilliant scholar and Garlan is one of the best swordsmen in the realm.

In the books, the Tyrells aren't nearly as close to extinction as they were in the show. This is a classic example of "adaptation pruning." The show didn't have time for five Tyrell kids, so they focused on two. This made the house much more vulnerable. If you’re a fan of the Tyrells, the books offer a lot more hope that the "Growing Strong" motto actually leads somewhere.


Moving Forward: How to Experience the Tyrell Legacy

If you're looking to dive deeper into the lore of the Reach and the Tyrells, don't just stop at the HBO show. There’s a lot more "human-quality" storytelling to find.

  • Read "Fire & Blood": It gives the backstory of how the Tyrells took over Highgarden and their role in the Dance of the Dragons. They weren't always the "nice" guys.
  • Check out the "World of Ice and Fire" sourcebook: The art of Highgarden in this book is breathtaking. It makes you realize how much of a loss that castle was to the culture of Westeros.
  • Analyze the Costume Design: If you rewatch the show, look at Margaery’s clothes. The way her style shifts from "Renly’s wife" to "King’s Landing socialite" is a masterclass in visual storytelling. She uses her body and her fashion as a literal shield and a weapon.

The House of Tyrell GoT story is a reminder that in the game of thrones, you can do everything right and still lose if your opponent is willing to burn the whole world down. It’s a cynical lesson, but a very "Thrones" one. They were the house of summer, and they simply weren't built for the winter that Cersei brought upon them.

Ultimately, the Tyrells were the most relatable house. They wanted their kids to succeed, they wanted to be comfortable, and they wanted to be respected. They weren't trying to save the world from ice zombies; they were just trying to live their best lives. And honestly? Same.