Thomas Cromwell was a monster. Or he was a genius. Maybe he was just a man with a very sharp ledger and an even sharper memory. If you’ve spent any time with the Hilary Mantel Wolf Hall trilogy, you know that he was probably all of those things at once. Honestly, it’s ruined the genre for me. After you've lived inside the head of Mantel’s Cromwell, every other historical protagonist feels like a cardboard cutout in a rented costume.
Most historical fiction is obsessed with the "thee" and "thou" of it all. It tries too hard to be old. Mantel did the opposite. She wrote Wolf Hall, Bring Up the Bodies, and The Mirror & the Light in a pulsing, immediate present tense that makes the 1500s feel like a frantic morning at a high-stakes law firm. You aren't looking at a museum exhibit. You’re in the room. You can smell the damp rushes on the floor and feel the vibration of the King’s mood swings. It’s terrifying.
The Thomas Cromwell Nobody Knew
Before Mantel, Cromwell was the villain. History books—and certainly A Man for All Seasons—portrayed him as the cold-blooded bureaucrat who destroyed the "noble" Sir Thomas More. He was the hatchet man for Henry VIII. He was the guy who dissolved the monasteries and paved the way for the English Reformation with a trail of blood and broken icons.
But Mantel looked at the records. She saw a man who was the son of a blacksmith from Putney. A man who was beaten by his father, ran away to Europe, served as a mercenary, learned the banking trade in Italy, and came back to England speaking better French and Italian than the aristocrats who despised him. She saw a self-made man in a world that hated anyone who wasn't born into power.
That’s the hook of the Hilary Mantel Wolf Hall trilogy. It’s a story about work. Cromwell is always working. He’s moving pieces on a chessboard while everyone else is still trying to figure out where the board is. He remembers everything. If you did him a favor twenty years ago in a tavern in Florence, he’ll reward you. If you insulted him in a London alleyway, he’ll wait. He’s patient.
Breaking the Third Wall of History
There’s this weird thing Mantel does with pronouns. In the first book, she constantly refers to Cromwell as "he." Just "he." Often, you have to figure out through context that "he" is Cromwell, even when there are three other men in the scene. Critics called it confusing at first. But once you get the rhythm, it’s brilliant. It mirrors how we experience our own lives. We don't think of ourselves by name; we are just the "I" or the "he" at the center of our own universe.
👉 See also: Ted Nugent State of Shock: Why This 1979 Album Divides Fans Today
By the time she got to The Mirror & the Light, the final, massive volume, she started using "he, Cromwell." It was a subtle shift. It signaled that he was becoming more aware of his own legend, his own precarious place in history. He was no longer just the observer; he was the target.
The Anatomy of a Tudor Power Struggle
People think these books are about Henry VIII’s wives. They are, sorta. Anne Boleyn is a central force in the first two books, and her downfall in Bring Up the Bodies is written like a psychological thriller. It’s claustrophobic. You feel the trap closing around her. But the real meat of the Hilary Mantel Wolf Hall trilogy is the machinery of the state.
It’s about how a rumor becomes a law.
Mantel shows us how Cromwell used the law as a weapon. He didn't just murder people; he made it legal to kill them. He rearranged the world through paperwork.
- Wolf Hall: This covers the rise. The death of Cardinal Wolsey—Cromwell’s mentor and the only man he truly loved—and the slow, methodical infiltration of Henry’s inner circle.
- Bring Up the Bodies: A tighter, faster read. It’s the demolition of the Boleyn faction. It happens over a few weeks. It’s brutal.
- The Mirror & the Light: The long goodbye. It covers the final four years of Cromwell's life, from the aftermath of Anne's execution to his own end on Tower Hill in 1540.
Henry VIII isn't the caricature we see in movies. He isn't just a fat guy shouting for more turkey legs. In Mantel’s hands, he’s a gilded disaster. He’s a man-child with the power of life and death, someone who believes his own lies so thoroughly that they become "truth." Cromwell’s job is to manage the King’s conscience, which is like trying to cage a hurricane.
✨ Don't miss: Mike Judge Presents: Tales from the Tour Bus Explained (Simply)
Why Accuracy Matters More Than You Think
Mantel spent years researching. She had index cards for every character—and there are hundreds. If the historical record says it was raining on a Tuesday in 1535, it’s raining in the book. But she fills the gaps with such profound psychological insight that you forget where the record ends and the fiction begins.
Take Thomas More. In most accounts, he’s a saint. In the Hilary Mantel Wolf Hall trilogy, he’s a brilliant but terrifying fanatic who enjoys the smell of burning heretics. It’s a jarring flip, but it’s grounded in More’s own writings. Mantel doesn't do "good guys" and "bad guys." She does people with agendas.
The Weight of the End
When The Mirror & the Light was released in 2020, it was over 800 pages long. Some people thought it was too much. Too many ghosts. Cromwell spends a lot of time remembering his past. He sees his dead wife, his dead daughters, and the ghost of Wolsey everywhere.
But that’s what happens when you reach the top of the mountain. The air gets thin. You start looking back because looking forward is too scary.
The ending of the trilogy is one of the most devastating pieces of prose ever written. We know what happens. It’s history. Cromwell loses his head. But the way Mantel writes the final moments—the sensory input, the fading light, the final thoughts of a man whose brain was a library of England’s secrets—is breathtaking.
🔗 Read more: Big Brother 27 Morgan: What Really Happened Behind the Scenes
She managed to make a 500-year-old execution feel like a surprise.
How to Actually Tackle These Books
If you haven't started the Hilary Mantel Wolf Hall trilogy, don't be intimidated by the page count. It’s a lot, but it moves. Here is the best way to handle it:
- Don't Google the secondary characters. Just let them wash over you. If they're important, Cromwell will remind you who they are. There are a lot of "Thomases." Thomas Wyatt, Thomas Howard, Thomas Audley. You’ll get used to it.
- Listen to the audiobooks if you get stuck. The narration by Ben Miles (who played Cromwell on stage) for the final book is a masterpiece. He understands the dry, sarcastic wit Mantel gave to Cromwell.
- Watch the BBC adaptation. Mark Rylance played Cromwell in the first series, and it’s one of the few times a TV show actually captures the internal mood of a book. It’ll help you visualize the spaces.
- Pay attention to the objects. Mantel focuses on things. A piece of fabric. A ring. A bowl of peaches. These aren't just descriptions; they are markers of wealth, power, and the passage of time.
The Hilary Mantel Wolf Hall trilogy isn't just a history lesson. It’s a study in how power works, how it corrupts even the smartest person in the room, and how the things we build eventually come for us.
If you want to understand the modern world—how bureaucracy functions, how "spin" is created, and how a person rises from nothing to the height of government only to fall in an afternoon—you have to read these. They are the gold standard. Everything else is just a costume drama.
To get the most out of your reading, start with Wolf Hall and keep a family tree of the Tudors nearby. It helps to track the various Dukes of Norfolk and Suffolk, who are almost always plotting someone's demise. Once you finish the first book, move immediately to Bring Up the Bodies while the tension is still fresh. The shift in pace between the two is one of the greatest technical achievements in modern literature. After that, take a breath before diving into The Mirror & the Light. It’s a marathon, but the view from the end is something you won't forget.
Practical Next Steps
- Acquire the "Wolf Hall" Companion: If you find the political maneuvering dense, Mary Robertson’s The Wolf Hall Companion provides the historical context for the real-life figures Mantel dramatizes.
- Visit the Locations: If you're in the UK, many of the settings—The Tower of London, Hampton Court Palace, and even the site of Austin Friars—are accessible. Seeing the physical scale of these places adds a heavy layer of reality to Mantel’s descriptions.
- Contrast with the Sources: Read a few of Thomas Cromwell’s actual surviving letters. You’ll see exactly where Mantel found the "voice"—that brisk, efficient, and surprisingly modern tone that defines the entire trilogy.