Why The Heart of Rock and Roll Still Beats (and Why the Broadway Musical Didn't)

Why The Heart of Rock and Roll Still Beats (and Why the Broadway Musical Didn't)

Huey Lewis and the News. For a long time, mentioning that name was basically shorthand for 1980s "uncool" or corporate pop. But if you actually listen to The Heart of Rock and Roll, you realize something pretty fast. It’s not just a song about a beat. It’s a mission statement. Huey wasn't trying to be edgy; he was trying to be timeless.

Most people think rock and roll is a sound. They think it's distorted guitars and leather jackets. Huey Lewis argued it was a spirit that lived in Detroit, L.A., and "the heart of Saturday night." He was right. That’s why, decades later, we’re still talking about this specific anthem, even after the high-profile Broadway musical based on his catalog took a bit of a tumble in 2024.

The Sound of 1984: More Than Just Synths

In 1983 and 1984, the charts were getting weird. You had the synth-pop explosion of the Second British Invasion. Everything sounded like a computer. Then you had Huey. He showed up with a harmonica, a horn section, and a blue-collar vibe that felt like a bridge between the 1950s and the MTV era.

The Heart of Rock and Roll was the lead-off track for the Sports album. It’s a weirdly constructed song if you analyze it. It starts with that thumping "heartbeat" sound—which was actually produced by a synthesizer, ironically enough—and then transitions into a chugging, mid-tempo groove. It’s not fast. It’s not heavy. But it is relentless. Johnny Colla’s guitar work and the Tower of Power horns gave it a soul-infused backbone that most of their contemporaries lacked.

Honestly, the song is a travelogue. Huey name-checks D.C., San Antone, Liberty Town. It was a calculated move to show that rock wasn't dead in the "flyover states." While critics in New York were obsessing over the newest post-punk band, Huey was singing to the people who were actually buying the records. And they bought millions of them. Sports went 7x Platinum. Think about that. Seven million people in the U.S. alone had this record in their house.

The Lyrics Nobody Really Analyzes

"They say the heart of rock and roll is still beating."

It’s a simple line. But look at the context of 1984. People were literally claiming rock was dead. Disco had "died" five years earlier, and the "New Wave" was seen as a temporary plastic replacement. Huey’s lyrics weren't just catchy; they were defensive. He was standing up for the genre. He mentions "the new sound" in the lyrics, but he’s quick to point out that it’s all built on the same foundation.

He was also one of the first guys to really lean into the music video era without looking like he was trying too hard. In the video for The Heart of Rock and Roll, he looks like a guy you’d see at a bar. He’s wearing a blazer with the sleeves rolled up. He’s sweating. It felt authentic in a way that the overly stylized videos of the time didn't.

💡 You might also like: Why This Is How We Roll FGL Is Still The Song That Defines Modern Country

The Broadway Gamble: What Happened?

Fast forward forty years. Every major artist from the 80s wants a "jukebox musical." We saw it with ABBA (Mamma Mia!), we saw it with Billy Joel (Movin' Out). So, it made sense to bring the Huey Lewis catalog to the stage. The Heart of Rock and Roll musical opened at the James Earl Jones Theatre in April 2024.

It had a lot going for it. The book was written by Jonathan A. Abrams, and it wasn't a biopic. Instead, it was a romantic comedy set in the 1980s about a guy named Bobby who has to choose between his corporate job and his garage band. It was light. It was fun. It featured "The Power of Love," "Hip to Be Square," and of course, the title track.

But it closed in June 2024. Only two months.

Why? It’s a tough question with a complicated answer. Some critics felt the "nostalgia bait" wasn't enough to sustain a Broadway audience that is increasingly looking for "high-concept" shows. Others pointed out that the 1980s aesthetic has been done to death on stage (see: Rock of Ages or The Wedding Singer).

The real tragedy is that the cast was actually incredible. Corey Cott and McKenzie Kurtz were powerhouses. The arrangements of the songs were clever. They managed to take "Workin' for a Livin'" and turn it into a massive ensemble piece that felt fresh. But Broadway is a brutal business. If you aren't a massive "brand" like The Lion King or a critical darling like The Outsiders, it's hard to keep the lights on.

The Huey Lewis Factor

We have to talk about Huey’s health, too. In 2018, he was diagnosed with Ménière's disease. It’s a disorder of the inner ear that causes vertigo and, most devastatingly for a singer, hearing loss. He can’t hear music well enough to sing with a band anymore.

This added a layer of poignancy to the musical. Huey was heavily involved in the production, even though he couldn't perform. For him, the show was a way to keep the music alive while his own ability to perform it was taken away. When the show closed early, it felt like a bit of a gut punch to a guy who had already lost so much of his livelihood.

📖 Related: The Real Story Behind I Can Do Bad All by Myself: From Stage to Screen

Why the Song Outlives the Show

The failure of the musical doesn't diminish the song. In fact, it might prove Huey’s original point. The Heart of Rock and Roll isn't about a scripted story in a theater. It’s about the feeling you get when you’re driving down a highway at 11:00 PM and a certain riff comes on the radio.

It’s about the "beat" he keeps mentioning.

Musicologists often point to the "backbeat" as the defining characteristic of rock. Huey’s song is literally a tribute to the 4/4 time signature. It’s the most basic element of Western popular music, and he turned it into a Top 10 hit.

There's a reason you still hear this song in grocery stores, at baseball games, and in movie trailers. It’s safe, sure. But it’s also incredibly well-constructed. The "heartbeat" intro is iconic. The bridge is a masterclass in tension and release. And that saxophone solo? It’s pure 80s joy.

Regionalism and Rock

One of the most interesting things about the song is the "shout-out" section. Depending on which version you heard, Huey would change the cities he mentioned.

  1. The album version had the standard list.
  2. Live versions would often swap in the name of whatever city they were playing in.
  3. Radio edits were sometimes customized for specific markets.

This was a genius marketing move before "algorithms" existed. If you were in Cleveland and you heard Huey Lewis say "Cleveland!" in the middle of a hit song, you felt seen. You felt like your city was part of the "heart" he was talking about. It created a sense of community.

Debunking the "Corporate Rock" Myth

For years, Huey Lewis and the News were dismissed as "corporate rock." This is basically a lie.

👉 See also: Love Island UK Who Is Still Together: The Reality of Romance After the Villa

Before they were famous, these guys were a hard-working bar band from the Bay Area called Clover. They backed up Elvis Costello on his debut album, My Aim Is True. They were "musician’s musicians." They didn't have a svengali manager creating their image. They were just guys who had played thousands of gigs in dive bars before they ever saw a red carpet.

When you listen to The Heart of Rock and Roll, you aren't hearing a manufactured product. You’re hearing a band that actually knows how to play together. There’s no Auto-Tune. There are no programmed drums. It’s a live band in a room, hitting their marks.

In 2026, where so much music is "content" created by AI or bedroom producers using loops, the organic thud of Huey’s rhythm section feels more radical than it did in 1984. It’s "real" in a way that is becoming increasingly rare.

How to Appreciate the Legacy Today

If you want to dive back into this era, don't just stick to the Greatest Hits. The Sports album is actually a great front-to-back listen. It’s a snapshot of a moment when rock was trying to figure out how to survive the digital age.

  • Listen to the bass line: Mario Cipollina’s work on the track is underrated. He stays in the pocket but adds these little melodic flourishes that keep the song moving.
  • Watch the live footage: Check out their performance at Live Aid. They were one of the few bands that didn't need a bunch of backing tracks to sound good in a stadium.
  • Ignore the "Patrick Bateman" effect: Yes, American Psycho made Huey Lewis a meme. But the joke in the movie is that Bateman is obsessed with the commercial success, not the music. Don't let a fictional serial killer ruin a good tune for you.

The Heart of Rock and Roll is ultimately a song about survival. It’s about the idea that trends come and go—whether it’s hair metal, grunge, EDM, or whatever we’re calling music today—but the "heartbeat" remains the same.

Huey Lewis might not be able to hear the music the way he used to, but he gave us a roadmap for what makes a song last. It’s not about being the coolest person in the room. It’s about finding a groove that everyone can feel, from San Antone to Liberty Town.

What You Can Do Next

Go find the original music video on a high-quality platform. Look past the 80s hair and the baggy suits. Focus on the chemistry of the band. If you're a musician, try to cover the song without using any MIDI. You'll quickly realize how tight those horn arrangements actually are.

If you’re ever in San Francisco, take a drive across the Golden Gate Bridge and put this track on. It was written in that environment, and it makes sense there. The "heart" isn't just a metaphor; it’s the physical energy of a band that refused to let the genre fade away. Check out the documentary work Huey has done recently regarding his hearing loss—it gives a whole new meaning to the "beating" heart he sang about so long ago.

To truly understand why this song matters, you have to stop listening to it as a "throwback" and start listening to it as a masterclass in pop-rock construction. The production is clean, the hooks are undeniable, and the message is universal. Rock and roll didn't die; it just changed its clothes. And Huey was the one who made sure we noticed.