You’ve seen them. Walk onto a backyard patio in the South or step into a rustic taco stand in Mexico, and you’ll likely see a clear plastic bag filled with water hanging right over the door. Sometimes there’s a penny at the bottom. It looks like a bizarre DIY art project or maybe some weird superstition passed down through generations. Honestly, it looks kind of ridiculous.
But people swear by it.
The hanging water bag for flies is one of those rural legends that persists because, for a lot of folks, it actually seems to do the trick. No chemicals. No sticky strips that look like a crime scene. Just a Ziploc and some tap water. If you’re tired of swatting at houseflies while trying to enjoy a burger, you’ve probably wondered if this is legit science or just a placebo for frustrated homeowners.
The truth? It’s complicated. It’s about light, anatomy, and how a fly's brain processes the world around it.
The Weird Science of Fly Eyes
To understand why a hanging water bag for flies might scare off a pest, you have to stop thinking like a human. We have two eyes. They see one cohesive image. Houseflies (Musca domestica) have complex compound eyes. We’re talking about 3,000 to 6,000 individual lenses per eye.
These lenses don’t create a high-resolution "picture" like a 4K TV. Instead, they are incredibly sensitive to motion and light patterns. This is why you can almost never swat a fly; they see your hand coming in slow motion because their flicker-fusion frequency is much higher than ours.
When you hang a clear bag of water in the sunlight, it acts like a massive magnifying glass and a prism at the same time. The water refracts light. It bends it. It scatters it.
For a fly buzzing toward your doorway, that bag isn't just a bag. It’s a chaotic, shimmering explosion of light. Because their eyes are designed to detect movement to avoid predators, the way light dances through the water mimics the movement of something large and threatening. Basically, it’s visual overload. It’s like walking into a room filled with strobe lights and mirrors—you’d probably turn around and leave, too.
What About the Penny?
You’ll often see a copper penny dropped into the bottom of the bag. Some people say it’s the copper. Others say it looks like a predator.
If we’re being real, there isn’t a single peer-reviewed study that proves a copper penny adds any chemical repellent to the water. However, the penny does add another reflective surface. From a fly's perspective, that shiny, distorted copper shape inside a refracting bag of water might look like a huge, multi-faceted eye of a larger predator—think a dragonfly or a bird.
Dragonflies are the apex predators of the insect world. They have massive eyes. If a fly thinks it sees a giant eye staring back at it, it’s going to bug out. Pun intended.
Does It Actually Work? The Great Debate
Here is where things get sticky. If you ask a group of entomologists, they’ll likely roll their eyes.
A famous 2007 study by Mike Stringham, an associate professor of entomology at North Carolina State University, looked into this at a commercial egg farm. He found that bags of water actually increased fly activity in some areas or had no effect. The theory was that the bags might provide a dark spot for flies to rest once the sun shifted, or perhaps they just didn't care about the light refraction in a high-density environment like a farm.
But there’s a gap between laboratory/industrial settings and your back porch.
Context matters. In a controlled study with thousands of flies, a few bags won't do much. But for a homeowner with a moderate fly problem, the "refraction theory" holds more weight. It requires direct sunlight to work effectively. If you hang a bag in a dark, shaded garage, it’s just a bag of water. It won’t do a thing. It needs that light to create the "dazzle" effect.
Setting It Up the Right Way
If you’re going to try the hanging water bag for flies, don't just slap a bag on a nail and hope for the best. There’s a bit of a technique to it if you want to maximize the visual disruption.
- Use a Heavy-Duty Bag: Don't use the cheap sandwich bags. You want a gallon-sized freezer bag with a strong seal. Water is heavy. A gallon of water weighs about 8.3 pounds. You don't want that bursting on your guests.
- Clear Water Only: Don't add soap or dye. You want maximum transparency so the light can bend properly.
- The Sunlight Factor: This is the most important part. Hang the bag in an area where it will catch the sun for most of the day. Entryways, porch eaves, and near outdoor dining tables are the sweet spots.
- Height Matters: Hang it at eye level—not your eye level, but the height where flies usually cruise. Usually, 5 to 7 feet off the ground is the "no-fly zone."
Why People Prefer Bags Over Sprays
Chemical pesticides are gross. Nobody wants to spray a cloud of "Instant Death" over a bowl of potato salad.
The hanging water bag for flies is favored because it’s incredibly cheap and totally non-toxic. It costs maybe five cents in materials. If it doesn't work for your specific patio setup, you’ve lost nothing but five minutes of your time.
There’s also the "neighbor factor." It’s a conversation starter. It signals that you’re using "old school" methods. But honestly, the best reason to use them is that they don't kill the flies; they just discourage them from entering. You don't have to clean up a pile of dead insects at the end of the night.
The Limitations You Need to Know
This isn't a magic spell. It won't work at night. Flies aren't very active at night anyway, but if you have porch lights on, the bag's effectiveness drops significantly because the light source isn't strong enough to create that blinding refraction.
📖 Related: Why Your Jar With Lid Clear Glass Strategy Is Probably Messing Up Your Pantry
Also, if you have a source of attraction—like a trash can that hasn't been cleaned in a month or a pile of pet waste nearby—a bag of water isn't going to stop a hungry fly. Their sense of smell is powerful. If the "smell of food" outweighs the "scary light show," the fly is going in.
You have to manage your expectations. A bag of water is a deterrent, not an exterminator.
Better Ways to Keep Flies Away
If the water bag isn't cutting it, or you think it looks tacky, you've got other options that are still "natural."
- Oscillating Fans: This is the most underrated fly hack. Flies are weak fliers. A simple pedestal fan on your porch creates enough turbulence that they can't land. It’s like trying to land a Cessna in a hurricane.
- Essential Oils: Peppermint, eucalyptus, and lemongrass. Flies hate them. Mixing these with water in a spray bottle and misting your outdoor furniture can help, though you have to reapply often.
- Cleanliness: It’s boring, but it’s true. Keep your outdoor drains clear and your trash lids tight.
Actionable Next Steps
Ready to give it a shot? Don't just do one.
Hang three bags. Space them out about 3 to 4 feet apart across the main opening of your patio or deck. This creates a "wall" of refracted light. If you’re feeling extra, drop two shiny, new pennies into each bag. Even if the science is debated, the anecdotal evidence from thousands of restaurants across the Southern United States and Central America suggests there is something to the visual disruption.
Check the bags every week. If the water gets cloudy or algae starts to grow inside, dump it and refill. You need that crystal-clear transparency for the light to bend.
The hanging water bag for flies is a low-stakes experiment. Worst case scenario? You have a weird-looking bag of water on your porch. Best case? You finally get to eat your ribs in peace without a fly trying to share the sauce.
Give it a try during the next bright, sunny day. Watch the flies as they approach the bag. You might see them zip toward the door, hit that "light wall," and veer off in a panic. That’s the refraction at work.
Pro Tip: If you're hanging these on a wooden beam, use a sturdy screw hook. A gallon of water is heavy enough to pull a simple thumbtack or weak nail right out of the wood after a few hours of swaying in the wind.
Keep your trash cans far from the seating area, turn on a fan, and hang your bags. It’s the multi-layered defense that actually keeps a summer BBQ from becoming a bug fest.