Christian Bale is a shapeshifter. We know this. But even for a guy who once lived on apples and tuna for The Machinist, his transformation into the primary antagonist of the Gorr the God Butcher movie—better known as Thor: Love and Thunder—was something else entirely. He looked like a nightmare birthed from a marble slab.
The hype was massive. Marvel fans had spent years reading Jason Aaron’s run on the Thor comics, specifically the 2012 God of Thunder series. They wanted the black necrosword. They wanted the god-bomb. They wanted the terrifying, nihilistic zealot who made Thor Odinson feel truly, deeply small. What we got was... complicated. Taika Waititi brought his signature humor, but he also brought a heavy dose of grief. The result was a film that felt like two different movies fighting for the steering wheel. One was a neon-soaked romantic comedy; the other was a grim, tragic horror story centered on a father who lost everything.
The tragic origin that actually worked
Honestly, the opening scene is probably the strongest part of the entire film. It’s quiet. It’s desperate. We see Gorr wandering a barren, sun-scorched wasteland, clutching his dying daughter, Love (played by India Rose Hemsworth). When he finally finds the lush oasis of his god, Rapu, he doesn't find salvation. He finds a jerk.
Rapu is arrogant, dismissive, and cruel. He laughs at Gorr’s suffering. It’s this moment that triggers the Necrosword—a weapon designed to kill immortals—to bond with Gorr. This isn't just a guy who decides to be evil because the script says so. He’s a victim of divine neglect. That’s a heavy theme for a movie that later features screaming goats and a sentient axe feeling jealous of a hammer.
Bale plays this with a terrifying intensity. His performance is mostly whispers and sudden, jerky movements. He feels like a silent film monster dropped into a modern blockbuster. Some people loved the contrast. Others felt like the "God Butcher" part of the Gorr the God Butcher movie was sidelined for the sake of jokes.
What the movie changed from the comics (and why it matters)
If you’ve read the source material, you know the comic version of Gorr is a multi-millennium threat. He doesn't just kill one or two gods; he enslaves them across time. He fights three different versions of Thor—young Thor, Avenger Thor, and Old King Thor—at the same time.
In the film, the scale is much smaller. He’s more of a serial killer than a cosmic conqueror.
💡 You might also like: Ashley My 600 Pound Life Now: What Really Happened to the Show’s Most Memorable Ashleys
- The Necrosword's origin is kept vague. In the comics, it's linked to Knull, the god of the symbiotes (think Venom). For legal and narrative reasons, Marvel Studios skipped that.
- Gorr’s appearance is vastly different. Comic Gorr has no nose and strange head-tentacles. Movie Gorr looks like a very pale, very scarred Christian Bale. Waititi reportedly changed the look to avoid comparisons to Voldemort from Harry Potter.
- The goal changed. Comic Gorr wanted to detonate a "Godbomb" to kill every god in history. Movie Gorr wants to reach Eternity, a cosmic entity that grants a single wish, to wipe them all out in one go.
There's a specific irony in the film's title. Love and Thunder. Gorr represents the death of love, which turns him into a monster. But by the end, he chooses love again. It’s a poetic arc, sure, but it felt rushed to a lot of people who wanted to see him actually "butcher" more gods on screen. We see the aftermath of him killing Falligar the Behemoth (a massive, dog-like deity), which looks incredible, but we don't get the fight. We're told he's a threat, but we don't see the rampage.
The problem with the "God Butcher" screen time
Here is a cold, hard fact: Gorr is only in the movie for about 25 minutes.
That’s a tiny window for an actor of Bale's caliber to establish a legendary villain. Because the movie clocks in at just under two hours, a lot of Gorr’s "butchering" ended up on the cutting room floor. Peter Dinklage (Eitri) and Jeff Goldblum (The Grandmaster) reportedly had scenes that were deleted. Bale himself mentioned in interviews that they filmed much creepier, more R-rated sequences that didn't make the final cut because they didn't fit the PG-13 "family adventure" vibe.
This is where the disconnect happens. When you call a character "The God Butcher," the audience expects to see some butchering. Instead, we spent a lot of time in Omnipotence City—a sequence that was visually stunning but played entirely for laughs. Russell Crowe’s Zeus was a hoot, but he made the "threat" of Gorr feel less urgent. If the gods are just bumbling idiots in skirts, why should we care if Gorr kills them?
It’s a tonal tightrope.
On one hand, you have the Shadow Realm sequence. This part of the film is brilliant. It’s shot in stark black and white, making Gorr’s world feel drained of life and color. It’s creepy. It’s atmospheric. It shows what the movie could have been if it leaned further into the horror elements. But then, we're back to the colorful Bifrost and the jokes.
📖 Related: Album Hopes and Fears: Why We Obsess Over Music That Doesn't Exist Yet
Why Bale’s performance saves the role
Despite the limited screen time and the tonal whiplash, Bale is captivating. He chose to play Gorr as a man who is literally rotting from the inside out. The Necrosword is a curse. It’s killing him as he uses it.
You can see it in his eyes. He’s not a cackling villain; he’s a grieving father who has let his rage turn into a terminal illness. When he interacts with the kidnapped Asgardian children, he isn't just scary; he’s weirdly pathetic. He tries to tell them a "scary story" by popping his own head off (a shadow trick), showing a man who has forgotten how to be human.
Understanding the "Shadow Realm" Mechanics
The movie introduces the Shadow Realm as Gorr's home base. It’s not just a place; it’s an extension of his power.
- Shadow Monsters: Gorr can summon "black berserkers" from the darkness. In the comics, these are constructs made of All-Black the Necrosword. In the movie, they function as his personal army, allowing him to fight groups of heroes at once.
- Color Siphoning: The realm physically removes color from anything that enters it. This was a stylistic choice by Waititi to emphasize Gorr’s perspective—a world without the "vibrancy" of the gods.
- The Necrosword's Toll: Every time he uses his power, the black veins on his face and body grow. It’s a literal representation of his soul being consumed.
The legacy of Gorr in the MCU
Was the Gorr the God Butcher movie a success? Financially, yes. Narratively? It’s a mixed bag.
It did something rare for Marvel: it gave a villain a definitive, emotional ending. Gorr doesn't die screaming for vengeance. He dies watching his daughter come back to life, realizing that he doesn't want to be remembered as a butcher, but as a father. It’s a soft landing for a hard character.
However, it also highlighted the "Marvel Formula" problem. By trying to please everyone—the kids who want the goats, the parents who want the romance, and the nerds who want the lore—the movie diluted the impact of one of the greatest comic book villains of the last decade.
👉 See also: The Name of This Band Is Talking Heads: Why This Live Album Still Beats the Studio Records
If you're looking to revisit the film, or if you're watching it for the first time, pay attention to the silence. Every time the music stops and Bale is allowed to just be Gorr without a quip following it up, you see the masterpiece that almost was. It’s a performance trapped in the wrong genre.
Actionable ways to dive deeper into Gorr's lore
If the movie left you wanting more of the character, there are specific things you can do to get the "full" experience that the 119-minute runtime couldn't provide.
Read the "God of Thunder" comic run
Specifically, read issues #1 through #11 of Thor: God of Thunder by Jason Aaron and Esad Ribić. This is the definitive Gorr story. It spans billions of years and shows the true scale of his war on the divine. The art by Ribić is sweeping and epic, looking more like a Renaissance painting than a standard comic book.
Compare the Necrosword to other Marvel artifacts
Research the history of "All-Black the Necrosword." While the movie keeps it simple, the comic lore connects it to the very beginning of the Marvel Universe. It was the first symbiote, forged by the deity Knull in the head of a dead Celestial. Knowing this context makes Gorr's weapon feel much more significant when you re-watch his fight scenes with Thor and Mighty Thor.
Watch the "deleted scenes" discussions
Search for interviews with Christian Bale regarding the deleted footage from Love and Thunder. Understanding what was cut—including more intense transformations and interactions with other gods—gives you a better appreciation for the "horror" version of the character that almost made it to the big screen.
Analyze the "Theology of Marvel"
Look at how other MCU projects like Moon Knight and Eternals handle gods. Gorr’s argument—that gods are selfish and don't deserve worship—actually holds some weight when you look at the wider MCU. Comparing Gorr's philosophy to the actions of the Egyptian Ennead or the Celestials adds a layer of intellectual depth to his "villainy."