You've probably seen them on Instagram. Those tiny, candy-colored cottages with the ornate woodwork that look like they were pulled straight from a Hansel and Gretel fever dream. Most people call them the gingerbread houses in Oak Bluffs, but if you want to sound like a local—or at least someone who's done their homework—you should call them the Martha’s Vineyard Camp Meeting Association (MVCMA). They aren't just cute. They're basically a living museum of a very specific, very weird moment in American religious history.
It’s honestly kind of wild how they started.
Back in the 1830s, this wasn't a vacation spot. It was a place for Methodists to get together and yell about Jesus in the woods. They called them "camp meetings." People would take the ferry over, pitch a heavy canvas tent on a platform, and spend a week or two praying and singing. It was gritty. It was buggy. But over time, people got tired of the wind whipping through the canvas. They wanted something more permanent. By the 1860s and 70s, those tents started evolving into the wooden cottages we see today. They kept the exact same footprint as the original tents, which is why they’re so narrow and close together. You can literally reach out your window and touch your neighbor’s house in some spots.
The Architecture of the Gingerbread Houses in Oak Bluffs
The style is officially called Carpenter Gothic. Think of it as a DIY version of those massive stone Gothic cathedrals in Europe, but made with local pine and a jigsaw. In the mid-19th century, the steam-powered scroll saw became a big deal. Suddenly, every carpenter on the island could churn out "gingerbread" trim—technically called vergeboards or bargeboards—without spending years carving by hand.
It was the 1800s version of a home renovation trend gone viral.
Once one person added some fancy lace-like trim to their porch, everyone else had to do it too. It was a weird mix of religious devotion and "keeping up with the Joneses." Today, there are about 312 of these cottages left. At the peak of the movement, there were over 500. Some were lost to fires, some were torn down, but the ones that remain are protected with a level of intensity that would make a suburban HOA look chill.
📖 Related: Food in Kerala India: What Most People Get Wrong About God's Own Kitchen
Why the Colors Are So Bright
If you walked through the Campgrounds in 1880, you wouldn’t see the neon pinks and teals you see today. Back then, they were mostly earthy tones—browns, tans, maybe a dark green. The "technicolor" phase didn't really kick in until later in the 20th century. Now, the MVCMA has strict rules about colors, but they definitely lean into the whimsical side of things.
The color palettes are meant to highlight the detail. If you paint the whole thing one color, you lose the "gingerbread" effect. You need the contrast. You need that cream-colored filigree to pop against a lavender or seafoam green background. It’s part of the charm, sure, but it’s also a massive pain to maintain. The salt air on Martha’s Vineyard eats wood for breakfast. Owners are constantly scraping, priming, and painting just to keep the rot at bay.
Life Inside the Campground
Living in one of these houses isn't for everyone. Honestly, it's a bit like living in a fishbowl.
During the summer, thousands of tourists wander the narrow brick paths. They peer into your windows. They take photos of your front door while you’re trying to eat your cereal. Most of the cottages don't have heat, so they're strictly seasonal. The walls are paper-thin. If your neighbor is snoring three houses down, you’re probably going to hear a muffled version of it.
The Tabernacle: The Heart of the Community
Right in the center of the cottages sits the Tabernacle. Built in 1879, it’s this massive wrought-iron structure that looks like a cross between a circus tent and a cathedral. It’s one of the largest examples of iron-work architecture of its kind.
👉 See also: Taking the Ferry to Williamsburg Brooklyn: What Most People Get Wrong
It’s still the soul of the place.
They hold services there, but they also host community sings, concerts, and graduations. It’s where the "camp meeting" vibe lives on. Even if you aren't religious, sitting in the Tabernacle on a warm July evening feels like stepping back into a different century. The acoustics are surprisingly good for a building that’s basically open to the air.
Grand Illumination Night: The One Event You Can't Miss
If you're planning a trip to see the gingerbread houses in Oak Bluffs, you have to know about Grand Illumination Night. It usually happens on the third Wednesday in August, though they keep the exact date a bit of a "secret" until the season starts to keep the crowds manageable (it doesn't work; it's always packed).
The tradition started in the late 1860s.
Basically, every cottage hangs dozens of ornate paper lanterns from their porches. At a specific moment in the evening, after a sing-along at the Tabernacle, the lights go out and then thousands of lanterns are lit all at once. It’s magical. There’s no other word for it. It feels like the entire town is glowing. Some of the lanterns are genuine antiques, passed down through families for generations. You’ll see hand-painted silk lanterns from the 1800s alongside newer ones.
✨ Don't miss: Lava Beds National Monument: What Most People Get Wrong About California's Volcanic Underworld
It’s a private event for the residents that the public is allowed to watch. That’s an important distinction. The people living there aren't actors; they're families who have often owned these homes for over a hundred years.
Common Misconceptions About the Area
A lot of people think these are tiny houses for poor people. Actually, they’re some of the most sought-after real estate on the island. While they might be small—some are under 700 square feet—they sell for hundreds of thousands of dollars, sometimes more if they’ve been meticulously restored.
Another big mistake? Thinking you can just drive through.
The Campground is mostly a pedestrian zone. The "streets" are narrow paths. If you try to bring a rental car in there, you’re going to have a bad time and probably annoy a lot of people. Park on the outskirts and walk in. It’s the only way to actually see the details on the gables.
Also, don't call them "dollhouses." The residents find it a bit condescending. These are homes. They have histories. Many of them are named—look for the little wooden signs above the doors with names like "Patti's Playhouse" or "The Snuggle Inn."
How to Respectfully Visit the Gingerbread Houses
Look, the people who live here are generally very nice, but they deal with a lot. Imagine if 5,000 people walked through your front yard every day.
- Stay on the paths. Don't walk up onto the porches unless you're invited. It seems obvious, but you'd be surprised.
- Keep the noise down. Sound carries in the Campground.
- Visit the Museum. There’s a small cottage museum near the Tabernacle. It’s cheap to enter and gives you a look at what the inside of a "typical" 1800s cottage looked like, complete with period furniture.
- Check the schedule. The MVCMA website usually has a list of events. If there's a concert at the Tabernacle, it's worth timing your walk to coincide with it.
The gingerbread houses in Oak Bluffs represent a specific slice of Americana that just doesn't exist anywhere else. They’re a reminder of a time when people prioritized community and ornamentation over square footage and privacy. Whether you're a history nerd, an architecture buff, or just someone who likes pretty colors, it's a place that actually lives up to the hype.
Actionable Steps for Your Visit
- Book the Ferry Early: If you're coming from the mainland (Woods Hole or Hyannis), boat reservations fill up months in advance, especially for August.
- Timing is Everything: Arrive in Oak Bluffs before 10:00 AM if you want photos without a hundred other tourists in the shot. The morning light hits the eastern-facing cottages perfectly.
- Visit the Cottage Museum: Spend the $5 or so to go inside the museum at 8 Trinity Park. It provides the context you need to understand why the houses are built the way they are.
- Walk Beyond the Front Row: Most people just see the houses facing the Tabernacle. Some of the best "gingerbread" is tucked away on the side paths like Commonwealth Ave or Moss Haven Ave.
- Check for "Illumination" Gear: If you're there in August, local shops sell paper lanterns. Buy one as a souvenir—it’s more authentic than a generic Vineyard t-shirt.