You’re standing right in the middle of it. If you’ve ever been to Gettysburg, you know the spot. It’s that massive, brick-and-stone anchor sitting right on the circle where all the roads meet. People call it the Gettysburg Hotel Lincoln Square, and honestly, it’s hard to imagine the town without it. It isn't just a place to crash after a long day of hiking through Devil’s Den or Culp’s Hill. It’s a literal piece of the timeline.
Most hotels brag about "history" because they bought some old-looking lamps at an estate sale. This place is different.
The hotel dates back to 1797. Think about that for a second. When this building first opened its doors as a tavern, John Adams was the President of the United States. It has survived the Civil War, the rise of the automobile, and millions of tourists. If these walls could actually talk, they wouldn't just tell stories; they’d probably give you a lecture on American endurance.
The Reality of Staying at the Gettysburg Hotel Lincoln Square
Let’s get the geography straight. Lincoln Square is the "Diamond." That’s what locals call the center of town. Staying here means you are roughly zero feet away from the action. You walk out the front door and you're surrounded by boutiques, pubs, and that specific brand of Gettysburg energy that feels half-solemn and half-tourist-trap.
It’s convenient. Really convenient.
But there’s a trade-off. Because you’re at the intersection of Business Route 15 and Route 30, it gets loud. If you’re looking for a silent, secluded retreat in the woods, this isn't it. You’ll hear the rumble of motorcycles and the chatter of people grabbing ice cream across the street. But for most people, that’s the draw. You’re in the thick of it. You feel like you’re part of the town’s pulse rather than just an observer watching from a chain hotel out by the highway.
What the Rooms are Actually Like
Rooms here aren't cookie-cutter. Since the building is old—very old—the layouts can be a bit quirky. You might find a room that’s massive with high ceilings, or you might end up in a cozy corner that feels a bit more tucked away.
They’ve modernized, obviously. You get the Wi-Fi. You get the flat screens. But they kept the crown molding and that heavy, traditional furniture that reminds you where you are. It’s "historic-lite." You aren't sleeping on a straw mattress from 1863, thank God, but you also aren't in a sterile, white-box Marriott.
Some people complain about the elevators being a bit slow. Honestly? They are. It’s an old building. Take the stairs if you’re in a rush—they’re gorgeous anyway.
💡 You might also like: Why Molly Butler Lodge & Restaurant is Still the Heart of Greer After a Century
The Lincoln Connection: More Than Just a Name
People always ask if Abraham Lincoln stayed here. The short answer is: sort of, but not really.
Lincoln famously stayed at the David Wills House, which is literally right next door. You can see it from the hotel. While Lincoln was finishing the Gettysburg Address in his room at the Wills House, the Gettysburg Hotel Lincoln Square (then known as the McClellan House) was bustling with reporters, politicians, and soldiers. It was the nerve center of the town during the most famous three days in American history.
The 1955 Presidential Era
Fast forward about 90 years. President Dwight D. Eisenhower and his wife, Mamie, basically lived here. While Ike was recovering from a heart attack at his farm nearby, his staff moved into the hotel. They set up a temporary White House.
If you go into the ballroom today, you can see where the national press corps used to sit and wait for updates. There’s a specific kind of weight to a place when you realize that world-altering decisions were being debated over coffee in the same lobby where you’re checking your email.
Eating and Drinking on the Square
You don't have to go far for food. One of the staples of the hotel is One Lincoln. It’s the on-site restaurant.
Is it the best food in Pennsylvania? Maybe not. But is it good? Yeah, it really is. Chef Joey shrugs off the "hotel food" stereotype by leaning into comfort stuff. The crab cakes are the big seller. They don't filler them up with a bunch of breading, which is a rare win.
- The Vibe: Casual but upscale enough that you don't feel weird wearing a nice shirt.
- The Crowd: A mix of ghost tour groups, history buffs in reenactment gear, and locals.
- The Pro Tip: Sit by the window. Watching the chaos of the square while eating a burger is peak Gettysburg entertainment.
If you want something more "authentic" and grittier, you walk three minutes down the road to any of the local taverns. But for a reliable breakfast before a 6-hour battlefield tour, One Lincoln hits the spot.
Addressing the Ghost in the Room
We have to talk about it. It’s Gettysburg. Everyone wants to know if the hotel is haunted.
📖 Related: 3000 Yen to USD: What Your Money Actually Buys in Japan Today
The hotel is a frequent stop on the local ghost tours. There are stories about a nurse named Rachel who supposedly wanders the halls, still looking for soldiers to tend to. Then there’s "James," a soldier who reportedly likes to mess with the electronics in the rooms.
Do I believe it? Personally, I think old buildings just make weird noises. Wind whistles through old window frames. Floorboards creak. But there is a specific atmosphere in the hallways late at night. Whether that’s "residual energy" or just the power of suggestion after hearing three hours of ghost stories is up to you. Even if you’re a total skeptic, the history is heavy enough to make you feel... something.
Logistics: The Boring But Necessary Stuff
Parking is the biggest headache. Since the hotel is right on the square, you can’t just pull up into a massive parking lot. You usually have to use the parking garage behind the hotel.
It’s a bit of a walk. If you have a ton of luggage, pull up to the front, let the valet or the bellhop handle it, and then go park. Don't try to navigate the square's traffic while looking for a spot on your own; you'll just end up frustrated and stuck in a one-way loop.
When to Visit
Gettysburg is a seasonal beast.
- Summer: Hot. Crowded. High energy. This is when the hotel is at 100% capacity.
- October: The best time. The leaves are changing, the air is crisp, and the ghost tours are in full swing.
- Winter: Quiet. The square is decorated for Christmas, and it looks like a Hallmark movie. Prices drop significantly.
Why Location Trumps Everything Else
You could stay out on Steinwehr Avenue. There are plenty of motels there. You could stay at a big resort closer to the bypass. But there is something fundamentally different about waking up at the Gettysburg Hotel Lincoln Square.
When you look out your window at 6:00 AM, before the tour buses arrive, the square is silent. You see the same view—minus the paved roads—that people saw 160 years ago. You’re looking at the same horizon. You’re standing where the town regrouped after the battle.
That’s the value. You aren't just visiting the history; you’re living in the middle of it.
👉 See also: The Eloise Room at The Plaza: What Most People Get Wrong
How to Get the Most Out of Your Stay
Don't just use the hotel as a bed. Spend twenty minutes in the lobby. Look at the old photos on the walls. Read the plaques. There’s a massive vault from the building’s time as a bank that’s still there.
If you’re planning a trip, here are a few things to keep in mind:
- Request a Square View: If you don't mind a little noise, the rooms facing Lincoln Square are much more atmospheric.
- Check the Event Calendar: The hotel hosts a lot of weddings. If you’re looking for a quiet weekend, call ahead and see if there’s a 200-person reception happening during your stay.
- Walk Everywhere: From this hotel, you can walk to the Shriver House, the Jenny Wade House, and the edge of the battlefield. Save the car for the actual auto tour of the park.
Gettysburg is a place that demands you pay attention. It’s easy to get lost in the stats—51,000 casualties, three days, 15,000 rounds of artillery. But when you stay at a place like this, the history becomes human. It’s about the people who ran the tavern, the reporters who wrote the stories, and the presidents who came here to find some perspective.
Actionable Steps for Your Visit
Ready to go? Don't just wing it.
Book directly through the hotel website if you can. Sometimes they have packages that include tickets to the Museum and Visitor Center or local tours that you won't find on the big travel booking sites.
Pack comfortable shoes. I cannot stress this enough. Even if you’re staying in the center of town, you will be walking miles. The brick sidewalks around the square are charming but unforgiving on your arches.
Plan your dining ahead. If you want to eat at One Lincoln or the nearby Dobbin House, make a reservation. During peak season, wait times can be two hours.
Take the National Cemetery walk. It’s about a 15-20 minute walk from the hotel front door to the spot where Lincoln gave the Address. Do it at sunset. It’s a completely different experience than driving there.
The Gettysburg Hotel Lincoln Square is a bridge between the past and the present. It isn't perfect, it isn't the quietest, and it certainly isn't the cheapest. But it is, without a doubt, the most "Gettysburg" experience you can have.
If you’re heading to the battlefield soon, make sure to check the local weather trends for Adams County; the humidity in July can be brutal, and the winds in January will cut right through a light jacket. Plan accordingly and enjoy the history.