If you walked into a Southern Italian household on December 24th and asked for a slice of ham, you’d probably get kicked out. Or at the very least, you’d get a very confused look from a grandmother holding a wooden spoon. That’s because, for millions of Italian-Americans, Christmas Eve belongs to the Feast of the Seven Fishes. It is loud. It is chaotic. It smells intensely of garlic and frying oil. And honestly? It’s arguably the most misunderstood food holiday in the United States.
Most people think this is some ancient Roman decree. It isn't. You won't find many people in Milan or Florence who have even heard of "La Vigilia" being called the Feast of the Seven Fishes. In reality, this is a beautiful, messy hybrid—a tradition born in the rugged landscapes of Southern Italy and perfected in the tenement kitchens of New Jersey, New York, and Philadelphia. It’s about more than just eating seafood until you can’t breathe; it’s a story of immigration, religious fasting, and the sheer audacity of trying to cook seven different courses on a four-burner stove.
The Weird History of Why We Eat Fish
The "why" behind the Feast of the Seven Fishes is actually pretty simple: the Catholic Church. For centuries, the Church mandated "lean days" (magro) where meat and dairy products were strictly forbidden. Since Christmas Eve is the vigil before the birth of Christ, it was a day of abstinence. No steak. No pork. No chicken.
But Italians aren't exactly known for their love of deprivation.
They looked at the "no meat" rule and saw an opportunity to show off. Since Southern Italy—places like Sicily, Calabria, and Campania—is basically one big coastline, fish was the natural pivot. What started as a humble meal of salted cod (baccalà) or fried eels eventually morphed into a marathon of culinary excess. When these families moved to America in the late 19th and early 20th centuries, they brought the tradition with them. In the U.S., seafood was relatively affordable and abundant, allowing the meal to grow into the seven-course (or nine, or eleven, or thirteen) spectacle we know today.
Does it actually have to be seven?
Actually, nobody can agree on the number. The number seven is deeply symbolic in Catholicism—the seven sacraments, the seven days of creation, the seven deadly sins—but if you ask five different Italian grandmothers how many fishes you need, you’ll get six different answers.
👉 See also: The Gospel of Matthew: What Most People Get Wrong About the First Book of the New Testament
Some families insist on nine (for the Trinity times three). Others go for eleven (the apostles minus Judas and Peter). Some wild households go for thirteen to include Jesus and all twelve apostles. But seven is the gold standard. It’s the number that looks best on a menu and feels the most "official," even though the "seven" part of the name didn't really gain mainstream popularity until the mid-20th century.
The Essential Menu: What You’re Actually Eating
If you're attending a Feast of the Seven Fishes for the first time, brace yourself. This isn't a "pick one entree" situation. You are eating all of them.
The star of the show is almost always Baccalà. This is salt-cured cod that has to be soaked in water for days—literally days—to draw out the salt. If you don't soak it long enough, it’s like eating a salt lick. If you soak it too long, it turns to mush. It's a delicate balance. It’s usually served fried, stewed with tomatoes and capers, or whipped into a spread.
Then you’ve got the fried course. Smelts are a big deal here. These are tiny, whole fish that are battered and fried. You eat the whole thing—head, tail, everything. It’s crunchy, salty, and goes perfectly with a cold beer or a crisp white wine.
- Calamari: Usually fried in rings or stuffed with breadcrumbs and baked.
- Scungilli: This is sea snail. It has a bit of a "chew" to it, usually served in a cold salad with lots of lemon and parsley.
- Clams and Mussels: Often served "posillipo" style (with tomatoes) or over linguine.
- Shrimp: Scampi, cocktail, fried—take your pick.
- The Eel: Capitone (female eel) is the traditional centerpiece in Naples. It’s often sold live in tubs, which leads to some hilarious/terrifying stories of eels escaping into kitchen sinks on December 23rd.
The Pasta Problem
Every family has "The Pasta." It’s usually linguine with white clam sauce or a spicy fra diavolo. The trick to a successful Feast of the Seven Fishes is pacing. If you eat three bowls of pasta at the start, you’re never going to make it to the lobster tails. You have to be strategic. You’ve got to treat it like an endurance sport.
✨ Don't miss: God Willing and the Creek Don't Rise: The True Story Behind the Phrase Most People Get Wrong
Why This Tradition is Secretly Dying (and How to Save It)
Let’s be real: cooking seven types of fish is a nightmare. It’s expensive. Your house smells like a pier for three days. And younger generations aren't always thrilled about cleaning squid guts on their day off.
We’re seeing a shift. Some people are moving toward "The One-Pot Feast," which is basically a giant Cioppino or Bouillabaisse that contains seven types of seafood. It’s a bit of a cheat code, but it keeps the spirit alive without requiring a professional cleaning crew.
Another big change is the sourcing. In the 1950s, you went to the local fishmonger who knew your name. Today, people are increasingly worried about sustainability. According to the Monterey Bay Aquarium Seafood Watch, some traditional staples like certain types of eel or overfished shrimp are becoming harder to justify. Modern "Seven Fishes" hosts are swapping out the old-school stuff for sustainable scallops or farm-raised mussels. It’s a necessary evolution.
The Logistics: How to Actually Host This Without Losing Your Mind
If you're crazy enough to want to host a Feast of the Seven Fishes, you need a plan. You can't just wing it.
First, do as much as possible in advance. Cold salads like scungilli or octopus can be made the night before—in fact, they taste better after marinating. Second, don't be a hero. Buy the shrimp already peeled. Get the clams already scrubbed. Your time is worth more than the three dollars you'll save doing it yourself.
🔗 Read more: Kiko Japanese Restaurant Plantation: Why This Local Spot Still Wins the Sushi Game
Also, consider the "Fry Station." Frying fish is the most stressful part because it has to be done last minute to stay crispy. If you can, set up a frying station outside or in the garage with a portable burner. It keeps the grease out of your kitchen and prevents your Christmas sweater from smelling like a Long John Silver’s.
The Cultural Weight of the Meal
There's a specific kind of magic in the Feast of the Seven Fishes that you don't get with a standard turkey dinner. It’s messy. You’re cracking shells with your hands. You’re passing bowls of lemon wedges. There’s a level of interaction required that forces people to actually talk to each other.
In a world where everything is becoming sanitized and "curated," this meal is refreshingly raw. It’s a middle finger to the "perfect" Christmas aesthetic. It’s about heritage, even for people who haven't stepped foot in Italy in three generations. It reminds us that we come from somewhere—usually somewhere where people had to work hard, fast from meat, and make do with whatever the sea gave them.
Common Myths vs. Reality
- Myth: It’s an ancient Italian national holiday.
Reality: It’s largely an Italian-American invention. In Italy, it’s just called "The Vigil" and the dishes vary wildly by region. - Myth: You must have exactly seven.
Reality: Most families lose count by the third bottle of wine. If you have a seafood salad with four types of fish in it, many people count that as four fishes. It’s called "creative accounting." - Myth: It has to be expensive.
Reality: It was originally a "poor man's" meal. Canned clams, frozen smelts, and salted cod are all traditionally budget-friendly.
Making it Your Own
You don't have to be Italian to do this. You just have to like seafood and have a high tolerance for chaos. The best part about the Feast of the Seven Fishes is its flexibility. If you hate eel (and honestly, most people do), don't make eel. Swap it for seared ahi tuna or a crab cake. The "rules" are more like suggestions.
The goal isn't perfection; it's the process. It's the steam on the windows, the pile of shrimp tails on a paper plate, and the collective food coma that hits right around 9:00 PM.
Actionable Steps for Your First Feast
- Start Small: If seven sounds daunting, do three. Call it the "Feast of the Three Fishes." Nobody will call the police.
- The 3-Cold, 4-Hot Rule: Serve three cold seafood appetizers (shrimp cocktail, octopus salad, smoked salmon) and four hot dishes. This keeps you from being stuck at the stove all night.
- Focus on the Baccalà: If you want authenticity, this is the one dish you can't skip. Buy it early, as Italian markets often sell out weeks in advance.
- Prep the "Holy Trinity": Garlic, parsley, and lemon. Buy three times more than you think you need. You will use every bit of it.
- Wine Pairing: Go for high-acid whites. Vermentino, Gavi, or even a dry Prosecco. You need something to cut through the fried oil and the heavy garlic.
The Feast of the Seven Fishes is a marathon, not a sprint. It’s a celebration of survival, family, and the ocean’s bounty. Whether you’re a lifelong practitioner or a newcomer looking to spice up a boring Christmas Eve, lean into the madness. Get your hands dirty. Eat the smelts.
To host a successful feast, begin your prep at least three days out by soaking the salt cod and finalizing your seafood orders with a local monger. Focus on variety over volume—small portions of seven dishes are much more manageable than seven full-sized entrees. Ensure you have plenty of crusty bread on hand to mop up the sauces, as that is often the best part of the night. Finally, remember that the "feast" is as much about the noise and the company as it is about the seafood itself.