Edgar Allan Poe was obsessed with being buried alive. It wasn’t just a passing quirk or a bit of gothic flair; the man was legitimately terrified of the "premature interment." You can see it in almost everything he wrote, but nowhere is it more claustrophobic than in The Fall of the House of Usher. Published in 1839 in Burton's Gentleman's Magazine, this story basically invented the vibe we now call "dark academia" long before anyone had a TikTok account to post it on.
It’s a weirdly short story. Honestly, not much happens on the surface. A guy visits a childhood friend, the friend’s sister dies, they put her in a box, and then things go south. Fast. But there is a reason we are still talking about Roderick and Madeline Usher nearly two centuries later. It’s because Poe wasn’t just writing a ghost story; he was writing about how a family's history can literally rot the house they live in.
What People Get Wrong About the Fall of the House of Usher
Most people think the house is just haunted. Like there’s a ghost in the attic or a demon in the basement. That’s not really it. Poe uses this concept called "sentience," the idea that the physical stones of the house, the fungi growing on the walls, and the stagnant tarn (that’s just a fancy word for a mountain lake) surrounding the property are actually alive. They are conscious. They are feeding on the Ushers.
Roderick Usher isn’t just "sick." He’s suffering from "a morbid acuteness of the senses." Basically, every sound feels like a gunshot, every light is too bright, and he can only wear certain textures. It sounds a lot like what we’d call sensory processing disorder today, but in 1839, it was just "the Usher curse."
The real kicker is Madeline.
👉 See also: New Movies in Theatre: What Most People Get Wrong About This Month's Picks
She doesn’t have a single line of dialogue. Not one. She just drifts through the background like a glitch in a video game until she "dies." But as any Poe fan knows, "death" in these stories is usually just a temporary state of being. When Roderick and the narrator put her in that copper-lined vault, they’re essentially sealing their own fate. If you read the text closely, Poe drops hints that Roderick knows she’s still alive. He hears her scratching. He hears the hinges creak. He just... stays there. Watching the walls crack.
The Flanagan Effect: Modernizing the Rot
When Mike Flanagan brought The Fall of the House of Usher to Netflix in 2023, he did something pretty ballsy. He moved the setting from a crumbling 19th-century estate to a modern pharmaceutical empire. It’s basically Succession but with more blood and a deal with a literal devil named Verna (which is an anagram for Raven, by the way).
Flanagan realized that the "house" in the 21st century isn't just a building. It's a brand. It's a legacy built on the backs of people who died from opioid addiction. By turning the Usher kids into personifications of Poe’s other stories—like The Masque of the Red Death or The Tell-Tale Heart—he made the original story's themes of guilt and rot feel fresh again.
But here’s the thing.
✨ Don't miss: A Simple Favor Blake Lively: Why Emily Nelson Is Still the Ultimate Screen Mystery
The core remains the same. Whether it's the 1830s or the 2020s, the story is about the "physiognomy" of a home. Poe believed that the way a house looks reflects the soul of the people inside. If the house has a "barely perceptible fissure" running from the roof to the ground, you bet your life that the family inside is fractured too.
Why the ending still hits so hard
The ending is pure chaos. The narrator is reading a story called "The Mad Trist" to Roderick to calm him down during a storm. It’s a classic meta-fiction move. Every sound described in the book—a shield falling, a door breaking—happens in real life.
Madeline appears at the door. She’s bloody. She’s pissed. She falls on her brother, and they both die. The narrator runs out just in time to see the entire house split in half and sink into the lake.
Poof. No more Ushers. No more house. It’s the ultimate "the end."
🔗 Read more: The A Wrinkle in Time Cast: Why This Massive Star Power Didn't Save the Movie
Key Themes You Might Have Missed
- The Double: Roderick and Madeline are twins. In gothic literature, twins often represent two halves of one soul. When Madeline dies, Roderick can’t exist. He’s the mind, she’s the body. You can't have one without the other.
- The Environment: Notice how Poe describes the air around the house? It’s "leaden" and "spiritless." It’s not normal air. It’s a miasma. Scientists in Poe’s time actually believed bad air (malaria) caused diseases. He took that medical theory and turned it into a supernatural horror element.
- The Art: Roderick paints a picture of a long, narrow vault with no exit and an unnatural light. It’s literally a painting of where he’s going to put his sister. Talk about a red flag.
Dealing With Your Own "Usher" Moments
We all have houses we need to leave. Metaphorically, anyway. Poe’s story serves as a pretty grim reminder that staying in a toxic environment because of "tradition" or "family legacy" will eventually pull you under.
If you’re looking to dive deeper into the world of Poe or Flanagan’s adaptation, start by reading the original short story again. It’s only about 15 pages. Pay attention to the adjectives. Poe uses words like "insufferable," "dreary," and "ghastly" so often it starts to feel like a chant.
Next, check out the 1960 Roger Corman film starring Vincent Price. It’s campy, sure, but Price captures that "nervous agitation" of Roderick Usher better than almost anyone else.
Finally, look at your own surroundings. Poe’s biggest lesson is that our spaces reflect our internal states. If your "house" feels like it's cracking, it might be time to get out before the storm hits and the tarn swallows everything up. There is no shame in being the narrator who runs away at the end. In fact, that's the only way to survive.