Sam Wilson didn’t want the shield. Honestly, that's the most honest thing about the whole show. When we first sat down to watch The Falcon and the Winter Soldier episodes back in 2021, most of us expected a standard buddy-cop romp with some cool wings and vibranium arms. What we actually got was a messy, uncomfortable, and deeply human look at what it means to inherit a legacy that wasn't built for you. It’s been years, and the conversation around these six chapters hasn't really cooled off. If anything, with Sam’s big-screen debut as Cap finally on the horizon, these episodes feel more like essential reading than ever.
The show is a weird beast. It’s got these massive, cinematic action set pieces that look like they cost a billion dollars, but then it spends twenty minutes talking about boat loans and systemic racism in the military. That friction is exactly why it works. It isn't just "Marvel content" to be consumed and forgotten. It’s a series that forced the MCU to look in the mirror.
The Weight of the Shield in Every Episode
You can't talk about this show without talking about the trauma. Bucky Barnes is a man out of time, literally haunted by a notebook full of names of the people he murdered while brainwashed. Sebastian Stan plays him with this sort of twitchy, quiet desperation that makes you want to give the guy a sandwich and a hug. Then you have Sam. Anthony Mackie brings a level of charisma that’s undeniable, but he anchors it in the reality of a Black man in America being asked to represent a country that hasn't always represented him.
Episode 1: New World Order
It starts with a bang. That canyon chase? Incredible. But the real hook is the ending. Sam gives up the shield because he feels it belongs to Steve, not him. He thinks he’s doing the right thing. Then, the government turns around and hands it to John Walker. It’s a gut-punch. It sets the tone for the entire series: things are rarely as simple as "good guys versus bad guys."
We see Bucky in therapy, and it’s painful. He’s trying to make amends, but he’s basically just apologizing to people whose lives he’s already ruined. It’s a heavy start for a superhero show. It told us right away that The Falcon and the Winter Soldier episodes weren't going to be all jokes and quips.
The Problem With John Walker
Wyatt Russell deserves an Emmy for what he did here. He made John Walker the most punchable man on television, yet you almost—almost—feel bad for him. He’s a soldier trying to live up to an impossible standard. He doesn't have the Super Soldier Serum (at first), and he’s clearly cracking under the pressure. When he finally loses it in "The Whole World is Watching," it’s one of the darkest moments in MCU history. Seeing that shield covered in blood? That changed everything. It stripped away the last bit of innocence the Captain America mantle had left.
📖 Related: Ashley Johnson: The Last of Us Voice Actress Who Changed Everything
Why the Flag Smashers Divide Fans
Karli Morgenthau is a polarizing villain. Some people think she was too radical; others think the show didn't go far enough in explaining her side. The "One World, One People" mantra makes a lot of sense if you think about the millions of people displaced after the Blip. They were the ones who kept the world running when half the population was gone, and then they were just tossed aside when everyone came back.
The show struggles a bit with Karli's arc, mostly because she starts blowing up buildings and killing innocent people, which makes it hard to keep her as a "sympathetic" antagonist. But the core of her grievance is real. It’s about borders and who gets to decide who belongs where. It’s a very 2020s problem wrapped in a superpowered package.
Isaiah Bradley and the Secret History
This is the heart of the show. Carl Lumbly’s performance as Isaiah Bradley is staggering. For those who don't know the comics (specifically Truth: Red, White & Black), Isaiah was a Black Super Soldier who was treated like a lab rat and then thrown in prison while Steve Rogers became a global icon.
When Sam visits Isaiah, the air in the room changes. This isn't just about superheroes anymore. It’s about the Tuskegee Syphilis Study. It’s about the actual history of how Black men have been used and discarded by the state. Isaiah telling Sam that "no self-respecting Black man would ever want to be Captain America" is the most powerful line in the entire series. It’s the hurdle Sam has to clear.
Breaking Down the Action and the "Buddy Cop" Energy
Despite the heavy themes, there’s still plenty of that classic Marvel DNA. The chemistry between Mackie and Stan is what keeps the show moving when the plot gets a bit bogged down in Madripoor.
👉 See also: Archie Bunker's Place Season 1: Why the All in the Family Spin-off Was Weirder Than You Remember
- The Prison Break: Seeing Zemo back was a highlight. Daniel Brühl turned a generic revenge villain from Civil War into a dancing, fur-coat-wearing icon.
- The Dora Milaje: When Ayo and the Wakandans show up to take Zemo, they absolutely wreck John Walker. It’s a reminder that being "Captain America" doesn't mean you're the toughest person in the room.
- The Final Fight: Sam finally suiting up in the comic-accurate wings and the white, red, and blue suit? Chills. Every time.
The show moves fast. Sometimes too fast. There are rumors that a whole subplot about a virus was cut because it hit too close to home during the pandemic, which might explain why the Flag Smashers' motivations feel a bit choppy in the middle episodes. But even with those pacing issues, the character work is solid.
Legacy and What Comes Next
What do The Falcon and the Winter Soldier episodes leave us with? A new Captain America. Not a guy with super-strength, but a guy with wings and a lot of heart. Sam’s monologue to the GRC in the finale is the thesis statement of the show. He tells them they have to do better. He doesn't just punch the problem away; he calls out the people in power.
It’s an ending that feels earned. Sam didn't just pick up the shield because it was his turn; he picked it up because he realized he could change what it represents. He chose to be the version of Cap the world needs now, not the version it had in the 1940s.
The Sharon Carter Twist
Okay, we have to talk about the Power Broker. The reveal that Sharon Carter is actually a high-level international arms dealer was... a choice. It’s a bit jarring for fans of the character, but in the context of the show, it makes sense. She was branded a traitor, hunted by her own government, and left to rot in Madripoor while the Avengers were off fighting Thanos. Of course she’s cynical. Of course she’s looking out for herself. It’ll be interesting to see how that plays out in Brave New World.
Practical Takeaways for Your Next Rewatch
If you’re planning to dive back into these episodes before the next movie, keep a few things in mind to get the most out of the experience.
✨ Don't miss: Anne Hathaway in The Dark Knight Rises: What Most People Get Wrong
Watch the eyes, not just the action.
Sebastian Stan does more with a lingering look than most actors do with a page of dialogue. Pay attention to how Bucky reacts when people mention Steve. It’s pure grief.
Pay attention to the color palette.
Notice how the colors shift when we’re in Madripoor versus when we’re in Sam’s hometown in Louisiana. The show uses visual cues to separate the "superhero" world from the "real" world.
Listen to the score.
Henry Jackman’s music for this show is fantastic. He blends the classic Captain America themes with modern, grittier sounds that reflect the transition from Steve to Sam.
Don't skip the credits.
The end credits sequence is full of Easter eggs and documents that flesh out the world-building, specifically regarding the Global Repatriation Council.
Actionable Next Steps
- Read the Source Material: If you want to understand Isaiah Bradley better, go find the trade paperback of Truth: Red, White & Black. It’s a heavy read but provides essential context.
- Contrast with Civil War: Re-watch the scene in Civil War where Sam and Bucky are sitting in the car while Steve talks to Sharon. The dynamic there is pure comedy, which makes their growth in the series even more impactful.
- Track the Shield: Follow the actual physical shield through all six episodes. Who holds it? Who drops it? When is it used as a tool, and when is it used as a weapon? It tells a story all its own.
Ultimately, this isn't a show about who can hit the hardest. It’s a show about who gets to tell the story of a nation. Sam Wilson decided that he was going to be the one to write the next chapter, regardless of who told him he couldn't. That’s why these episodes stick with you. They aren't just about saving the world; they're about fixing it.