You’re heading to Gettysburg. You want the history, the spooky ghost tours, and the somber reflection of the battlefield, but you definitely don't want the 19th-century plumbing. It's a common dilemma. Staying right in the heart of downtown Gettysburg sounds romantic until you're trying to find a parking spot at 9:00 PM or realize your "charming" historic inn has walls as thin as parchment paper. That’s usually when people start looking just a few miles down the road at the Fairfield Inn Fairfield PA.
Except, there's a catch.
If you search for a Marriott-branded "Fairfield Inn" specifically located in the borough of Fairfield, Pennsylvania, you're going to run into a bit of a geographical identity crisis. This is where most travel blogs get it wrong. They conflate the famous Historic Fairfield Inn 1757—a landmark building with deep ties to the Civil War—with the modern Marriott Fairfield Inn & Suites located on the edge of Gettysburg. Knowing which one you’re actually booking is the difference between sleeping in a room where Confederate soldiers once retreated and sleeping in a room with a reliable ergonomic desk and a microwave.
The Tale of Two Fairfields
Let’s clear the air. The Historic Fairfield Inn 1757 is the soul of Fairfield, PA. Located at 15 West Main Street, it’s one of the oldest continuously operating inns in America. It’s rugged. It’s authentic. It’s where you go for the famous chicken pot pie. On the flip side, many travelers use "Fairfield Inn Fairfield PA" as a shorthand search for the Fairfield Inn & Suites by Marriott Gettysburg, which is actually situated on the Highway 15 corridor.
Why does this matter? Because Fairfield, PA is a quiet, picturesque village about eight miles west of the Gettysburg battlefield. It’s the "scenic route." If you stay in the actual town of Fairfield, you’re trading the tourist bustle for mountain views and a much slower pace of life.
👉 See also: Flights from San Diego to New Jersey: What Most People Get Wrong
Staying at the Historic Fairfield Inn 1757
If you’re a history buff, the 1757 property is non-negotiable. This isn't just a hotel; it’s a time capsule. Built originally as a plantation house for Squire Miller, it eventually became a stagecoach stop. During the retreat from Gettysburg, General Robert E. Lee’s troops passed right by these doors. Some accounts suggest the building even served as a field hospital.
The rooms here aren't cookie-cutter. They’re filled with antiques. You might find a four-poster bed that requires a small step-stool to climb into. The floors creak. Honestly, that’s the point. You aren't paying for high-speed fiber-optic internet—though they have Wi-Fi—you’re paying to feel the weight of three centuries of Pennsylvania history.
The dining room is the real draw. People drive from Maryland just for the ham and those aforementioned pot pies. It’s heavy, traditional colonial fare. If you’re on a keto diet, maybe just look at the pictures. For everyone else, it’s a mandatory stop.
The Marriott Alternative: Fairfield Inn & Suites Gettysburg
Now, if you actually meant the Marriott version when you searched for Fairfield Inn Fairfield PA, you’re looking for the property at 1 Gettysburg Village Drive. It’s located right next to the Gettysburg Outlets.
✨ Don't miss: Woman on a Plane: What the Viral Trends and Real Travel Stats Actually Tell Us
Is it historic? No. Is it convenient? Absolutely.
This is for the traveler who spent ten hours hiking Culp’s Hill and just wants a hot shower with consistent water pressure and a bed that feels exactly like the one they have at home. You get the free breakfast—the classic waffles and scrambled eggs—and a pool. It’s the "safe" bet. It’s also strategically placed right off Route 15, making it a breeze to get down to Frederick or up to Harrisburg.
Why Location in Fairfield Matters for Your Itinerary
Most people treat Fairfield as a pass-through, but that’s a mistake. The area surrounding the Fairfield Inn Fairfield PA (the town) is home to the Liberty Mountain Resort. In the winter, this is the hub for skiing and tubing in Southern Pennsylvania.
If you stay in Fairfield during the autumn, the drive between the inn and the battlefield is arguably more beautiful than the battlefield itself. You’ll pass through the Millerstown Road area, seeing apple orchards that have been there for generations. It’s a different side of the Adams County experience. It’s less about the tragedy of 1863 and more about the enduring agricultural beauty of the region.
🔗 Read more: Where to Actually See a Space Shuttle: Your Air and Space Museum Reality Check
Breaking Down the Logistics
- Distance to Battlefield: From Fairfield proper, you're about 10-15 minutes from the Visitor Center.
- Noise Level: Virtually zero. Unlike downtown hotels near Steinwehr Avenue, Fairfield is silent after dark.
- Food Options: Limited in the immediate village. You have the Inn’s restaurant and maybe a local pizza shop. For variety, you’re heading back to Gettysburg.
Common Misconceptions About Booking in This Area
Don't assume "Fairfield" means "far." In big-city terms, 8 miles is a 45-minute crawl in traffic. In Adams County, 8 miles is a 10-minute cruise past cows and cornfields.
Another big one: thinking the historic inn is "haunted" in a scary way. While there are plenty of ghost stories associated with any building that saw the Civil War, the vibe at the Fairfield Inn is generally peaceful. It’s more "hospitable spirit" than "horror movie."
Practical Steps for Your Trip
Before you lock in your reservation, decide what kind of traveler you are this weekend.
- Choose the Historic Fairfield Inn 1757 if you want an anniversary dinner, a creaky floorboard, and a deep sense of place. Call ahead for dinner reservations even if you aren't staying there; the dining room fills up fast on weekends.
- Choose the Fairfield Inn & Suites (Marriott) if you have kids who need a pool, you’re collecting Marriott Bonvoy points, or you plan on doing some serious shopping at the outlets.
- Check the Calendar: If it’s the annual Apple Harvest Festival in October, expect everything in Fairfield and Gettysburg to be booked six months in advance.
- Transport: You need a car. There is no Uber or Lyft reliability out in Fairfield. If you’re flying into BWI or Dulles, a rental is your only realistic path to seeing the sites.
The beauty of the Fairfield Inn Fairfield PA area lies in that choice. You can have the modern comforts of a reliable chain or the grit and glory of a 260-year-old landmark. Both put you within arm's reach of one of the most important historical sites in the world. Just make sure you know which one you're putting into your GPS.