Before the espresso-fueled world domination and the Coachella headlining slots, Sabrina Carpenter was just a teenager trying to find a voice that didn't sound like a Disney carbon copy. She was fourteen. Imagine that. Most of us were struggling with algebra, but she was in a recording studio laying down the tracks for what would become the Eyes Wide Open Sabrina Carpenter album. Released back in April 2015 via Hollywood Records, it serves as a fascinating time capsule. It’s the sound of a girl caught between the folk-pop whimsy of Taylor Swift’s early days and the powerhouse vocal ambitions of someone who clearly spent too much time listening to Etta James.
It's weird. People talk about Emails I Can't Send like it was her debut. It wasn't.
If you go back and listen to the record now, you’ll notice something immediately: her voice was already massive. Usually, when child stars release an album, the production does the heavy lifting. Not here. On tracks like "We'll Be the Stars," you can hear her pushing against the edges of the folk-pop genre. It’s raw, it’s a bit unpolished in places, but it’s undeniably her. The album didn't just appear out of nowhere; it followed the Can't Blame a Girl for Trying EP, and it peaked at number 43 on the Billboard 200. Not a chart-topper by today’s standards, but for a Disney Channel star in 2015? That’s a solid start.
The Sound of the Eyes Wide Open Sabrina Carpenter Album
Honestly, the genre-hopping on this record is kind of wild. You’ve got the title track, "Eyes Wide Open," which feels like a mid-2010s anthem meant for a coming-of-age movie montage. Then you have "Can't Blame a Girl for Trying," which leans so heavily into the acoustic-guitar-and-ukulele vibe that you can practically smell the Hollister perfume.
The songwriting credits are a "who's who" of that specific era of pop. You have Meghan Trainor—before she was a household name—co-writing "Can't Blame a Girl for Trying." You have production from the likes of Brian Malouf and Steven Solomon. These weren't just throwaway tracks. They were calculated attempts to see what "Sabrina Carpenter" actually sounded like.
Why the Folk-Pop Influence Mattered
Back then, Hollywood Records had a bit of a formula. They liked the "girl with a guitar" aesthetic. It worked for Miley, it worked for Demi, and they wanted it to work for Sabrina. But Sabrina brought a specific soulfulness. If you listen to "Seamless," there’s a lyrical maturity that feels a bit beyond a freshman in high school.
- "Two Words" is a piano ballad that sounds like it belongs on a Broadway stage.
- "Right Now" is pure, unadulterated bubblegum pop but with a surprisingly complex vocal run.
- "White Flag" shows a hint of the sass that would eventually define her later career.
The mix was eclectic. Some might even say messy. But it was the necessary messiness of an artist figuring out if they wanted to be the next Colbie Caillat or the next Christina Aguilera.
👉 See also: Don’t Forget Me Little Bessie: Why James Lee Burke’s New Novel Still Matters
Moving Past the Disney Channel Shadow
At the time of this release, Sabrina was starring as Maya Hart in Girl Meets World. That’s a heavy shadow to live in. For many fans, the Eyes Wide Open Sabrina Carpenter album was just an extension of the show’s wholesome brand. But if you look at the lyrics of "Eyes Wide Open," there’s a persistent theme of autonomy. She sings about being "at the edge of the world" and "making her own mistakes."
It’s easy to dismiss teen pop. We do it all the time. We call it manufactured. We call it shallow. Yet, there’s a specific kind of bravery in a 15-year-old singing about the terrifying prospect of the future while the entire world expects her to just be a sitcom character.
The Critics vs. The Reality
Most critics at the time gave it a shrug. Common Sense Media and other outlets viewed it through the lens of "safe for kids." They weren't wrong, but they missed the nuance. They missed the fact that Sabrina was already out-singing her peers. She wasn't using Auto-Tune as a crutch; she was using it as a stylistic choice of the era.
Interestingly, the album has aged better than most of its contemporaries. While other Disney-era albums from that time sound dated because of heavy EDM influences, the acoustic leanings of Eyes Wide Open give it a certain timelessness. You could play "Your Love's Like" in a coffee shop today and nobody would bat an eye.
What Most People Get Wrong About This Era
People think Sabrina’s "growth" was sudden. It wasn't. The seeds were planted here.
One major misconception is that she had no creative control. While she didn't have the same pen-to-paper dominance she has now, she was heavily involved in the vibe of the record. She has spoken in interviews later about how she wanted the album to feel like a "dream," hence the title. She wanted people to see that she was looking at the world with her eyes open—not just following a script.
✨ Don't miss: Donnalou Stevens Older Ladies: Why This Viral Anthem Still Hits Different
Another thing? The vocal production. If you listen to the title track, the layering of her harmonies is incredibly dense. That’s a Sabrina staple that started here and moved all the way through to Short n' Sweet. She’s always been obsessed with the way voices stack on top of each other.
The Numbers That Actually Mattered
- Billboard 200: Peak position 43.
- US Top Tastemaker Albums: Peak position 14.
- Radio Disney Music Awards: She won "Best Anthem" for "Eyes Wide Open."
These aren't just trivia points. They represent a footprint. She was building a base of "Carpenters" (her fans) before the term was even widely used. Without the modest success of this album, Hollywood Records might not have funded the more experimental sounds of Evolution a year later.
The Evolution from Eyes Wide Open to Short n' Sweet
It’s a long road from "Can't Blame a Girl for Trying" to "Please Please Please."
On Eyes Wide Open, the romance is innocent. It’s about crushes and "the boy who might like me." By the time we get to her later work, the romance is messy, sexual, and often self-deprecating. But you can't have the latter without the former. The Eyes Wide Open Sabrina Carpenter album was her learning how to tell a story.
If you're a new fan who joined the fandom during the Emails I Can't Send era, going back to this debut is like looking at a childhood photo album. You recognize the eyes, you recognize the smile, but the person is completely different.
The production on the debut is very "mid-2010s radio." It has that bright, compressed sheen. Today, her music is much more atmospheric and bass-heavy. But the core—the ability to sell a melody—hasn't changed a bit.
🔗 Read more: Donna Summer Endless Summer Greatest Hits: What Most People Get Wrong
How to Revisit the Album Today
If you’re going to dive back into this record, don't go in expecting Nonsense. Go in expecting a time machine.
Start with "Eyes Wide Open." It’s the strongest track on the record and the most representative of where she was headed. It has a drive to it that the other songs lack. Then, listen to "Two Words." It’s probably the most "underrated" song in her entire discography. It’s a sweeping, cinematic ballad that showcases her lower register, which she rarely used in the Disney years.
- Listen for the vocal runs in the bridge of "Right Now."
- Pay attention to the storytelling in "Seamless"—it’s surprisingly clever for a teen record.
- Compare the acoustic version of "Can't Blame a Girl for Trying" to the studio version to see how much of her talent is just her and a guitar.
Honestly, it’s a better album than it has any right to be. Most debut albums from child stars are a chore to sit through ten years later. This one? It’s actually quite pleasant. It’s a reminder that talent is a baseline, but longevity is built on the willingness to start somewhere and keep moving.
Actionable Steps for the Modern Listener
To truly appreciate the journey Sabrina has taken, don't just stream the hits. You need to map the progression.
- Create a "Sabrina Growth" Playlist: Put "Eyes Wide Open" next to "Skinny" and "Thumbs." Listen to how her lyrical perspective shifts from external observation to internal monologue.
- Watch the Old Live Performances: Search for her 2015-2016 tours. You’ll see a performer who was still finding her stage legs but already had the "it" factor.
- Read the Lyrics Without the Music: You’ll find that even at 15, her team (and herself) were avoiding the most egregious "baby" tropes of teen pop.
- Check the Credits: Look up the songwriters like Audra Mae and Dan Book. Seeing who she worked with early on explains why she has such a strong grasp of pop structure now.
The Eyes Wide Open Sabrina Carpenter album isn't just a relic of the past. It’s the foundation. It’s the moment a young girl from Pennsylvania decided she wasn't going to just be an actress who sings, but a singer who happens to act. That distinction made all the difference. If you want to understand why she is the biggest pop star in the world right now, you have to look at where she opened her eyes for the first time.