You’re staring at the Scrapped Watchman’s soul—the Broken Hero's Ergo—and you have a choice. You could take the Etiquette umbrella, which looks cool but feels like poking enemies with a wet noodle if your build isn't perfect, or you can grab the extreme modification amulet lies of p players often overlook until they’re hitting a wall in NG+.
It's a heavy trade-off. Literally.
Lies of P is a game about weight management and resource hoarding, and this specific amulet sits right at the intersection of both. If you’ve played any Soulslike, you know the "hoarder mentality." You keep your Fable Slots full because you’re "saving them for the right moment," which usually means you die with a full meter. This amulet turns that bad habit into a massive damage buff.
How the Extreme Modification Amulet Actually Works
Most people read the description and get confused. It says it increases weapon ATK in proportion to the number of Fable Slots filled.
Sounds simple. It isn't.
Basically, the more blue bars you have glowing at the top of your screen, the harder you hit with every single light and heavy attack. You don’t need to use the Fable Arts. In fact, the whole point is not using them. This creates a weirdly tense playstyle where you’re rewarded for ignoring your coolest moves.
How much of a boost are we talking? At base level, with five Fable Slots filled, you're looking at a roughly 20% damage increase. That is massive. Most other amulets give you a measly 5% or 10% under very specific conditions, like the Conqueror’s Amulet which requires a perfect guard. The extreme modification amulet lies of p offers just rewards you for existing with a full meter.
The Math of the Slots
The scaling isn't linear. If you only have three slots, the amulet is okay. It’s "fine." But once you start dumping points into the P-Organ to unlock that fourth and fifth slot, the scaling kicks into high gear.
- 3 Slots: About 12% boost.
- 4 Slots: About 16% boost.
- 5 Slots: The golden 20%.
If you’re running a Motivity build and swinging a wrench head on a police baton handle, 20% extra damage is the difference between a boss phase-transitioning or just flat-out dying before it can scream.
✨ Don't miss: Finding Every Bubbul Gem: Why the Map of Caves TOTK Actually Matters
Why You Might Hate This Amulet (At First)
Weight. It’s always about the weight.
In Lies of P, your weight threshold determines your stamina regen and your roll speed. This amulet is heavy. It’s one of the heaviest items in the game, coming in at over 10 units. Early on, when your Capacity stat is low, putting this on might shove you into the "Slightly Heavy" or "Heavy" category.
Don't do that.
If you're fat-rolling, no amount of damage is worth it. You’ll get clipped by Laxasia’s lightning or the Nameless Puppet’s second-phase dashes, and you’ll be dead before that 20% damage boost matters. This is a late-game item. You need to have invested heavily in Capacity. Honestly, Capacity is the most important stat in the game anyway, but this amulet makes it mandatory.
Comparing it to the Arm of God Amulet
You’ll hear a lot of chatter about the Arm of God Amulet being the "best" for damage. It increases damage with successive attacks.
Sure. If you’re using a fast weapon like the Tyrant Murderer’s Dagger.
But if you’re using a heavy, slow weapon, you aren't getting "successive attacks" often enough to keep that buff active. The extreme modification amulet lies of p fans swear by is better for heavy hitters because the buff is always there. You don't have to build it up. You just walk into the arena, and you’re already at max power.
The Strategy: To Burn or To Hoard?
Here is where the nuance comes in.
🔗 Read more: Playing A Link to the Past Switch: Why It Still Hits Different Today
Playing with this amulet changes your "internal clock." Usually, when a boss is staggered, you might want to dump a Fable Art for massive burst damage. But if you do that, you lose your 20% buff for the rest of the fight until you build those slots back up.
It creates a "risk vs. reward" loop.
- The Hoarder Path: You never use Fable Arts. You rely entirely on your raw weapon damage. This is the most consistent way to play and makes the amulet a permanent, static buff.
- The Burst Path: You keep your slots full until the boss is at 20% health, then you dump everything in one go to finish them off.
I’ve found that the best way to use the extreme modification amulet lies of p provides is to pair it with the "P-Organ" upgrade that automatically charges Fable on successful guards. That way, even if you do use a slot to pull off a quick defensive move or a minor buff, you’re back at 100% capacity within thirty seconds of aggressive play.
Making the Build Work
If you want to actually use this thing, you need a specific setup.
First, get your Capacity to at least 30. Maybe 40. You want to stay under 60% total weight while wearing your best defensive parts.
Second, focus on the P-Organ nodes that increase your Fable Slot count. You start with three. You can get to five. There is a massive leap in utility once you hit that fifth slot.
Third, pick a weapon with a high base "Attack/Damage" stat. Since the amulet works on a percentage, the higher your base damage, the more "bonus" points you get. Adding 20% to a dagger is cool; adding 20% to the Holy Sword of the Ark is a godsend.
Real Talk on Boss Souls
You get this amulet from Alidoro (or Hugo, later on) by trading the Broken Hero’s Ergo. This is the Ergo you get from the Scrapped Watchman in Chapter 2.
💡 You might also like: Plants vs Zombies Xbox One: Why Garden Warfare Still Slaps Years Later
Most new players see the Etiquette weapon and think, "Ooh, a fancy umbrella."
Don't be that guy.
Etiquette is a niche Technique weapon that requires a very specific playstyle. The Extreme Modification Amulet is a universal power-up that stays relevant through New Game Plus, New Game Plus 2, and beyond. In the late game, when bosses have health bars that take up half the screen, you aren't going to care about a fancy umbrella. You’re going to care about why your heavy attacks are hitting like a freight train.
Actionable Next Steps for Your Run
If you’re currently playing and wondering if you should pull the trigger on this item, follow this checklist:
- Check your Capacity: If you are already struggling with weight, stash the amulet in your bag for now. Don't equip it if it makes you "Heavy."
- Count your Slots: If you only have 3 Fable Slots, the buff is decent but not game-breaking. Prioritize the P-Organ upgrades to hit 4 or 5 slots as soon as possible.
- Audit your Fable Arts: Do you actually use them? If you find yourself forgetting Fable Arts exist, this is the best amulet in the game for you. It literally rewards your forgetfulness.
- Pair with the Blue Guardianship Amulet: This will help with your weight and stamina if you're finding the Extreme Modification Amulet too taxing on your equipment load.
The reality is that Lies of P is a game about efficiency. This amulet is the definition of efficient. It takes a resource you might be sitting on anyway and turns it into the most valuable currency in Krat: raw, unadulterated damage.
Stop worrying about the umbrella. Take the soul to Alidoro, grab the amulet, and start dumping points into Capacity. Your late-game self will thank you when you're shredding through the Cathedral and the Malum District with power to spare.
Final Insights
The Extreme Modification Amulet remains one of the few items in the game that scales with your character's progression through the P-Organ rather than just your raw stats. While other amulets fall off in utility as you reach the soft caps for Motivity or Technique, this one only gets stronger as you unlock more Fable capacity. It is a staple of "meta" builds for a reason. Keep your meter full, keep your weight managed, and the toughest bosses in the game will suddenly feel a lot more manageable.