Ever looked at a ballot and wondered why we’re represented by a circus animal and a farm beast? It's kinda weird. Most countries use flags, torches, or abstract shapes. We use a donkey and an elephant. These aren't just random stickers. They’ve been stuck to the Republican and Democratic parties for over 150 years. They were born from insults, satire, and a very grumpy cartoonist named Thomas Nast.
The Donkey Started as a Mean Joke
Democrats didn't choose the donkey. It chose them. Well, technically, their opponents did.
Back in the 1828 presidential campaign, Andrew Jackson's critics called him a "jackass." They thought he was stubborn and stupid. Jackson, being the kind of guy who fought duels for fun, leaned into it. He actually put the donkey on his campaign posters. He figured a donkey was hardworking and humble, unlike the "aristocratic" people trying to run the country.
But the image didn't really stick to the whole party until much later. It took a civil war and a lot of ink.
Thomas Nast is the guy you should blame—or thank. He was a cartoonist for Harper's Weekly. In the 1870s, he started drawing the Democratic Party as a donkey to show what he thought was their "stubbornness" or "clumsiness" in post-war politics. He wasn't trying to be nice. He was trying to make them look ridiculous. Somehow, the Democrats just... kept it.
Why the Donkey Still Works
Even though it started as a roast, the symbol evolved. Modern Democrats often view the donkey as a sign of being "of the people." It’s a beast of burden. It’s tough. It’s relatable. It’s not a fancy lion or a crown.
The Republican Elephant: A Panic in the Zoo
The elephant came about in a much stranger way. In 1874, Nast drew a cartoon called "Third Term Panic."
💡 You might also like: Wisconsin Judicial Elections 2025: Why This Race Broke Every Record
He was poking fun at the New York Herald, which was spreading rumors that President Ulysses S. Grant (a Republican) was going to run for a third term and become a dictator. In the cartoon, Nast drew various interests as animals. He drew the Herald as a donkey in a lion’s skin, scaring away all the other animals in the zoo.
And there, in the corner, was a massive, clumsy elephant labeled "The Republican Vote."
It was meant to represent a giant, lumbering creature that was easily spooked and about to walk off a cliff. Not exactly a glowing endorsement. But Republicans eventually saw something else in it. They saw strength. They saw dignity. They saw a creature that was smart and hard to push around. By the time the 1880s rolled around, the elephant was the official mascot.
The Man Behind the Ink: Thomas Nast
We can’t talk about the elephant and donkey without talking about Nast. He was basically the king of 19th-century memes.
He didn't just invent these mascots. He gave us the modern version of Santa Claus and the "Uncle Sam" we know today. Nast was a staunch Republican who used his pen like a weapon. He hated corruption, especially Tammany Hall in New York.
His drawings were incredibly detailed. People who couldn't read well could look at a Nast cartoon and immediately know who the "bad guys" were. That's power. It’s why these symbols lasted. They were easy to understand in a time when mass media was just starting to explode.
📖 Related: Casey Ramirez: The Small Town Benefactor Who Smuggled 400 Pounds of Cocaine
Why Haven't We Changed Them?
Think about how much branding has changed since the 1870s. Coca-Cola has changed its look. Every tech company updates its logo every five years to look "sleeker."
Politics is different.
The elephant and donkey have survived because they represent a deep-seated tradition. They are "legacy brands." If the GOP tried to change to a wolf or the Democrats tried to switch to a hawk, it would feel fake. It would feel like a corporate rebrand that nobody asked for.
Honestly, the symbols have become a sort of shorthand. You don't need to read a platform to know which side a yard sign is on if it has a red elephant or a blue donkey. They are baked into the American identity.
The Color Shift
It’s actually a common misconception that the colors were always Red and Blue for these animals. That’s a total myth. For most of the 20th century, there was no standard.
During the 1976 election, NBC used a light-up map where Republicans were blue and Democrats were red. It stayed that way for some networks for years. It wasn't until the 2000 election—the Bush vs. Gore showdown—that the media collectively decided "Red States" were Republican and "Blue States" were Democrat. It was purely for visual clarity on TV during a long, drawn-out recount. Now, it’s permanent.
👉 See also: Lake Nyos Cameroon 1986: What Really Happened During the Silent Killer’s Release
The Nuance of Modern Symbolism
Today, you’ll see the symbols used in very specific ways.
- Campaigning: Candidates use stylized versions that look modern and patriotic.
- Protest: Cartoonists still use the "stubborn donkey" or "forgetful elephant" tropes to critique leadership.
- Merchandise: It’s a billion-dollar industry. Hats, shirts, bumper stickers.
There’s a tension here, though. Some younger voters find the animals outdated. They feel like these caricatures from the 1800s don't represent the complexities of modern policy. But symbols aren't meant to be complex. They’re meant to be sticky.
What This Means for You
When you see these animals, remember they were born out of a very specific, very heated political moment in the 19th century. They weren't handed down by the Founding Fathers. They were the result of a guy in a messy office in New York making fun of politicians.
Understanding the history helps take some of the "mystique" out of the two-party system. It reminds us that these parties are human institutions, prone to the same mockery and branding struggles as anything else.
If you want to understand American politics better, stop looking at the mascots and start looking at the history of the eras that created them. The Reconstruction era, which gave us the elephant and donkey, still echoes in our debates today about federal power, civil rights, and the role of the press.
Next Steps for Deepening Your Knowledge:
- Check out the Harper's Weekly archives. Look for "Third Term Panic" (1874) to see the original elephant in its natural habitat of political chaos.
- Compare international political symbols. Look at the UK's Labour Party (a red rose) or the Conservative Party (a tree). Notice how those symbols convey different values than our animals.
- Study the 2000 Election Map. Research how the "Red vs. Blue" color scheme became solidified during the 36-day Florida recount, changing how we visualize the elephant and donkey forever.