You’ve seen them. You might even live in one. That distinctive, barn-like roofline that looks like it belongs on a farm in the Netherlands but sits perfectly comfortably on a tree-lined street in New Jersey or Ohio. It’s the Dutch Colonial Revival home. While other architectural trends come and go with the speed of a TikTok fashion cycle, this specific style has maintained a vice-grip on American residential tastes for over a century. It’s practical. It’s a bit quirky. Honestly, it’s one of the smartest ways to get more house for your money without building a massive, looming box that annoys your neighbors.
The real magic is in the roof. That "gambrel" shape isn't just for show.
By curving the roof outward, architects basically hacked the building codes of the early 20th century, allowing for a full second floor of living space while technically remaining a one-and-a-half-story structure. It was the ultimate loophole. But before we get into the nuts and bolts of why these houses are so enduring, we need to clear something up. Most people think these are "authentic" Dutch houses from the 1600s. They aren't. They’re a tribute act—a very successful one—that took off between 1890 and 1940.
The Roof That Changed Everything
If you’re looking at a house and you can’t tell if it’s a barn or a cottage, you’re probably looking at a Dutch Colonial Revival home. The defining feature is the gambrel roof. Think of it as a roof with two slopes on each side. The lower slope is steep, almost vertical, while the upper slope is much flatter.
Why bother?
In the early 1900s, as the American middle class started moving to the suburbs, they wanted space. But they didn't want the massive heating bills or the tax assessments associated with full two-story Victorian mansions. The gambrel roof allowed for high ceilings and nearly vertical walls in the bedrooms upstairs. You get the headward room of a second floor with the cozy, ground-hugging aesthetic of a cottage.
Flare and Overhang
Early Dutch settlers in the Hudson Valley—the real ones from the 17th century—often extended their eaves out past the walls. This wasn't just for style; it protected the clay mortar in the stone walls from rain. When the Revival era kicked in, architects kept this "flare." It gives the house a sort of grounded, wide-stanced look. You’ll often see these homes with massive full-width porches tucked under that overhanging eave. It’s the perfect spot for a porch swing, and it’s one of those details that makes these houses feel like "home" the second you see them.
A Story of American Identity
It’s weird to think about, but architectural styles are often reactions to politics. In the late 1800s, America was undergoing massive industrialization. People were stressed. There was a huge influx of immigrants. In response, the "Colonial Revival" movement exploded. People wanted to connect with a "simpler" American past.
💡 You might also like: Human DNA Found in Hot Dogs: What Really Happened and Why You Shouldn’t Panic
While the British-inspired Georgian and Adam styles were popular, they felt a bit stiff. Formal. A little too "Old Money."
The Dutch Colonial Revival home offered an alternative. It felt rural and egalitarian. It felt like the American dream before it got complicated. Architects like Aymar Embury II—who literally wrote the book on this stuff back in 1913—championed the style as the ideal American suburban dwelling. He argued it was the most "picturesque" of the colonial types. He wasn't wrong.
Spotting the Real Deal vs. the Revival
There is a huge difference between an original 1700s Dutch farmhouse and the revival versions you see in Sears, Roebuck & Co. catalogs from 1925.
- Originals: Usually made of stone or massive timber. They were often lopsided, added onto over generations, and had very small windows.
- Revivals: These are symmetrical. You’ll usually see a centered front door, often a "Dutch door" (where the top and bottom halves open independently), flanked by balanced windows.
The revival version also loved dormers. To get even more light into those second-floor bedrooms, architects would cut massive "shed dormers" into the roof. Sometimes a single dormer will run almost the entire length of the house. It’s a dead giveaway that you’re looking at a 20th-century interpretation.
Why They Are a Nightmare (and a Dream) to Renovate
If you buy a Dutch Colonial Revival home today, you’re stepping into a specific set of challenges. I’ve talked to contractors who both love and loathe them.
The "kneewalls" are the main culprit. Because of the roof shape, the walls in the upstairs bedrooms often meet the floor at an angle or stop early. This creates "dead space" behind the walls. It’s great for hidden storage or running modern HVAC ducts, but it makes placing furniture a total pain. You can't just shove a tall armoire against a wall that's only four feet high.
Then there’s the insulation.
📖 Related: The Gospel of Matthew: What Most People Get Wrong About the First Book of the New Testament
Older Dutch Colonials were notoriously drafty at the "elbow" of the gambrel roof. Modern spray foam has fixed a lot of this, but if you’re looking at an unrenovated 1920s model, prepare to spend some money on making it airtight.
But honestly? The bones are usually incredible. These houses were built during a period when old-growth timber was still accessible. The joists are often thicker than what you’d find in a modern McMansion. They don't creak the same way. They feel solid.
The Amityville Horror Connection
We can't talk about this style without mentioning the most famous (or infamous) Dutch Colonial Revival home in the world: 112 Ocean Avenue.
The "Amityville Horror" house is the quintessential example of the style, specifically the "Long Island" variation. With its gambrel roof and those two iconic quarter-round windows that looked like eyes, it cemented the Dutch Colonial in the American psyche. Unfortunately, it cemented it as "spooky."
For decades after the movie came out, real estate agents struggled with the "creepy" association. But look past the Hollywood ghost stories. The house itself—built in 1927—is a masterclass in the Dutch Colonial form. It’s large, stately, and perfectly symmetrical. It represents the peak of the style’s popularity before the Great Depression shifted tastes toward smaller, more economical Cape Cods.
Regional Variations You Should Know
Not all Dutch Colonials are created equal. Depending on where you are in the U.S., the style shifts to match the local vibe.
- The Hudson Valley Style: These stay truest to the roots. Lots of fieldstone, heavy wood shutters, and a very steep gambrel. They look rugged.
- The New England Variation: Often clad in cedar shingles. These lean into the "shingle style" aesthetic, looking more like a seaside cottage than a farmhouse.
- The Suburban "Kit" House: Between 1908 and 1940, Sears sold thousands of Dutch Colonial "Honor Bilt" homes through their catalogs. Models like "The Martha Washington" or "The Dutch Gray" were shipped by rail and assembled on-site. These are everywhere in the Midwest. They are usually more compact and have standardized layouts.
Living in a Dutch Colonial Revival Home Today
So, is it worth it?
👉 See also: God Willing and the Creek Don't Rise: The True Story Behind the Phrase Most People Get Wrong
If you value character over open-concept living, then yes. Modern floor plans are often just one giant room where you can hear the dishwasher while you're trying to watch TV. Dutch Colonials aren't like that. They are "cellular." They have distinct rooms.
There’s a dining room. There’s a library or a "sunroom" off to the side. There’s a kitchen that is its own separate kingdom. For people working from home, this is a godsend. You can actually close a door.
Maintenance Checklist for Owners
If you're currently scouting one of these beauties, keep your eyes on these specific spots:
- The Flashing: The "break" in the roof where the pitch changes is a prime spot for leaks. If the flashing is old, your ceilings will let you know.
- The Sills: Because many of these homes sit low to the ground (it’s part of the look), check for termite damage or rot in the wooden sills near the foundation.
- The Windows: Original wood windows in these homes are often beautiful—true divided lights—but they are energy sinks. Instead of replacing them with cheap vinyl, look into high-quality storm window inserts. It preserves the look and stops the breeze.
The Future of the Style
We’re seeing a weirdly high number of new builds mimicking the Dutch Colonial Revival home lately. Developers are realizing that people are tired of the "Modern Farmhouse" look (white siding, black windows). They want something that feels established.
The Dutch Colonial offers that. It has a "permanent" feel to it. It’s a style that suggests the family has been there for generations, even if they just moved in last Tuesday. It bridges the gap between formal history and casual modern living better than almost any other American architectural style.
Actionable Insights for Potential Buyers or Renovators
If you are looking to buy or fix up a Dutch Colonial, don't try to fight the architecture.
- Don't "Pop the Top": If you need more space, don't try to add a full second story on top of a gambrel roof. It ruins the proportions and looks like a hat on a hat. Expand outward or finish the basement instead.
- Embrace the Dutch Door: If your front door needs replacing, go for the split door. It’s functionally great for letting in a breeze while keeping the dog inside, and it’s the ultimate "nod" to the home's heritage.
- Color Matters: These houses look best in "earthy" tones. Cream, sage green, deep blues, or natural wood shingles. Avoid stark, high-contrast modern palettes that wash out the interesting shadows created by the roofline.
- Interior Trim: Most of these homes featured substantial crown molding and chunky baseboards. If a previous owner ripped them out to make the house look "modern," put them back. The house needs that weight to feel balanced.
The Dutch Colonial Revival home isn't just a relic of the 1920s. It’s a blueprint for how to build a house that is both spacious and intimate. It’s a reminder that sometimes, the best way to move forward is to look at what the Dutch were doing 300 years ago and give it a clever American twist.