It was supposed to be a celebration. A "tribute" to Chinese culture ahead of a massive "The Great Show" event in Shanghai. Instead, the 2018 Dolce and Gabbana advert featuring a Chinese model struggling to eat pizza and cannoli with chopsticks became perhaps the most expensive marketing blunder in the history of the fashion industry.
The fallout was instant. Within 24 hours, the show was canceled. Within 48 hours, every major Chinese e-commerce platform had scrubbed the brand from their listings. Even now, years later, the ghost of that campaign lingers over every luxury brand trying to crack the code of the Chinese market.
It wasn't just about the chopsticks. It was about the tone.
The Dolce and Gabbana Advert That Broke the Internet for All the Wrong Reasons
If you haven't seen the clips, they are objectively awkward. A young woman in a sequined D&G dress sits at a table. In front of her is a massive pizza. A narrator, speaking in a way that many viewers found condescending, gives her "instructions" on how to use "these small stick-like tools" to eat the "great traditional Pizza Margherita."
It felt patronizing. Honestly, it felt like a joke from a different century that somehow made it through a dozen corporate approval layers.
When people talk about the Dolce and Gabbana advert, they usually focus on the chopsticks. But the real fire started when Diet Prada—the Instagram watchdog of the fashion world—leaked screenshots of alleged direct messages from Stefano Gabbana. The messages were filled with insults toward China and its people. While the brand claimed their account was hacked, the damage was absolute.
Cultural insensitivity is one thing. Direct insults are a death sentence in a market that accounts for roughly a third of global luxury spending.
Why the Apology Failed to Land
Stefano Gabbana and Domenico Dolce eventually released a video apology. They looked somber. They sat at a wooden table and spoke about their love for China. They even ended the video by saying "Sorry" in Mandarin (Duibuqi).
👉 See also: Share Market Today Closed: Why the Benchmarks Slipped and What You Should Do Now
But the public wasn't buying it. Why? Because the apology felt reactive rather than reflective. By the time the video went live, celebrities like Zhang Ziyi and Chen Kun had already publicly cut ties. The brand’s ambassadors were gone. The "Great Show" was a pile of scaffolding in Shanghai.
Luxury isn't just about the product. It's about the dream. When a Dolce and Gabbana advert shatters that dream by making the customer the punchline of a joke, the brand value doesn't just dip—it evaporates.
The High Cost of Getting Culture Wrong
Let's look at the numbers. They’re staggering. Before the 2018 incident, D&G was a powerhouse in Asia. Afterward? Their sales in the region plummeted. According to various financial reports from the following years, while other luxury houses like LVMH and Kering were seeing double-digit growth in China, D&G was struggling to even keep their doors open in some cities.
This wasn't just a "social media moment." It was a structural collapse.
- The Retail Erasure: Platforms like Tmall, JD.com, and Secoo pulled D&G products immediately. In a digital-first economy like China, if you aren't on the apps, you don't exist.
- The Celebrity Blacklist: In China, "KOLs" (Key Opinion Leaders) drive the market. No major Chinese celebrity would touch the brand for years for fear of being labeled unpatriotic.
- The Long Tail of Search: Even today, searching for "Dolce and Gabbana advert" brings up a mountain of articles about racism and cultural tone-deafness rather than their latest collection.
Was It Truly Racism or Just a Bad Creative Choice?
This is where things get nuanced. Some defenders of the brand argued that the campaign was intended to be "tongue-in-cheek" or "kitsch," which is a core part of the D&G DNA. They've always loved the over-the-top, slightly caricatured Italian aesthetic.
The problem is that you can't apply an Italian "kitsch" lens to a culture you don't deeply understand. What looks like a playful stereotype in Milan can look like a colonial insult in Shanghai.
Experts in cross-cultural marketing often point to this as the "ethnocentric trap." D&G viewed Chinese culture through their own Italian lens rather than hiring local creatives to vet the message. If a single local strategist had been in that room, they probably would have said, "Hey, maybe don't make the narrator sound like he's explaining fire to a caveman."
✨ Don't miss: Where Did Dow Close Today: Why the Market is Stalling Near 50,000
What Brands Have Learned Since 2018
The Dolce and Gabbana advert serves as a permanent case study in business schools. It changed how marketing departments operate.
Nowadays, you’ll notice a huge shift in how brands like Dior, Chanel, or Gucci approach the Lunar New Year or Chinese-specific campaigns. They aren't just translating Western ads anymore. They are co-creating. They are hiring Chinese directors, Chinese photographers like Chen Man (though even she has faced her own controversies), and local writers who understand the "Gen Z" sentiment in Beijing and Shanghai.
The shift from "Global Branding" to "Hyper-Local Relevance" is the direct result of D&G’s failure.
The Era of "Cancel Culture" in Luxury
We have to talk about the power of the consumer. In the past, a brand could survive a bad ad. You’d run it, people would complain, and then you’d move on to the next season.
Not anymore. The 2018 Dolce and Gabbana advert proved that the "social license to operate" is fragile. In the age of social media, the consumer is the editor-in-chief. They have the power to organize boycotts that can wipe out millions in projected revenue in a single weekend.
Actionable Lessons for Navigating Global Markets
If you're running a business or a marketing team, the D&G saga offers a roadmap of exactly what not to do. It’s not enough to be "sorry" after the fact; you have to be intentional from the start.
Hire local experts with veto power.
It is useless to hire a local agency if their only job is to "check the boxes" of a campaign designed in Paris or New York. They need the authority to say "No, this will offend people" and actually be heard by the C-suite.
🔗 Read more: Reading a Crude Oil Barrel Price Chart Without Losing Your Mind
Audit your internal communications.
The leaked DMs were the nail in the coffin. A brand's internal culture will eventually leak into its external image. If the leadership doesn't respect the market they are selling to, it will show up in the creative work.
Understand the difference between "Appreciation" and "Caricature."
Appreciation highlights the beauty and complexity of a culture. Caricature relies on "sticks" and "exotic" music. If your ad relies on a stereotype to get a laugh, it’s probably a bad ad.
Prepare a "Crisis Day Zero" plan.
D&G’s initial response—claiming they were hacked—was widely disbelieved and only fueled the anger. Honesty and immediate accountability are the only ways to survive a PR firestorm.
The legacy of the Dolce and Gabbana advert isn't just a video of a girl eating pizza. It's a reminder that in the modern world, respect is the most valuable currency a brand has. Without it, the most beautiful clothes in the world are just expensive fabric that nobody wants to wear.
To truly move forward, brands must invest in cultural intelligence as much as they invest in aesthetic design. The price of ignorance is simply too high to pay.
Next Steps for Global Brand Strategy
- Conduct a Cultural Audit: Review all upcoming international campaigns through the lens of local historians or cultural consultants, not just marketing generalists.
- Diversify Your Creative Room: Ensure that the people creating the content reflect the demographics of the audience you are targeting.
- Monitor Sentiment Locally: Use social listening tools specifically tuned to the nuances of regional platforms like Weibo, WeChat, or Douyin to catch micro-aggressions before they scale.
- Develop Authenticity Protocols: Create a framework for "apology" and "correction" that prioritizes transparency over legalistic denials.