You’re sitting in a posh Amsterdam restaurant. The kind where the manager explains the provenance of the organic free-range lamb for ten minutes and the portions are roughly the size of a postage stamp. Across from you is your brother—a man currently leading the polls to become the next Prime Minister. You hate him. Or maybe you're just jealous. But that's not the problem tonight. The problem is that your teenage sons have done something unspeakable, and now you have to decide how far you’ll go to keep them out of prison.
That is the jagged, vibrating heart of The Dinner a novel by Herman Koch.
It’s a book that makes you want to wash your hands after reading it. When it first hit the international scene, translated from Dutch by Sam Garrett, it became an instant sensation because it dared to ask a question most parents are too terrified to answer: Is a "good" parent someone who protects their child from the law, or someone who holds them accountable to it?
🔗 Read more: Why Zedd Stay the Night Still Hits Harder Than Most Modern EDM
The Architecture of a Slow-Motion Train Wreck
Herman Koch doesn't do "nice." He doesn't do likable characters. If you go into this book looking for a hero, you’re going to be hungry. The story is structured around the courses of a single meal: Aperitif, Appetizer, Main Course, Dessert, Digestif. It’s a clever gimmick, but it works because the tension rises with every "tasting" of the menu.
Our narrator is Paul Lohman. Paul is... complicated. At first, he sounds like a relatable guy—a cynical former history teacher who sees through the pretension of his brother Serge, the politician. But as the wine flows, Paul’s internal monologue begins to fray. You realize the narrator isn't just unreliable; he might be dangerous. This isn't just a book about a crime. It’s a psychological study of how "civilized" people justify savagery.
The plot centers on an ATM vestibule. A homeless woman. A match. A video on YouTube. Koch based the central horrific act on a real-life incident in Barcelona in 2005, where three young people from "good families" set a homeless woman on fire. By grounding the fiction in a reality that actually happened, Koch strips away the comfort of the "it's just a story" defense.
Why Serge and Paul Represent a Broken Society
Serge Lohman is the public face. He’s the one who stands for "values" and "policy." Paul is the private reality. The friction between them drives the narrative forward even more than the mystery of the crime itself. Honestly, the book spends a lot of time mocking the upper-middle-class obsession with status.
Koch spends pages describing the manager’s "pinky finger" pointing at the food. It’s hilarious until it isn't. The juxtaposition of the trivial—the price of the wine, the garnish on the plate—with the gravity of their sons’ violence creates a sickening contrast. It suggests that our manners and our gourmet meals are just a thin veneer over something much darker and more primal.
The Genetic Excuse and the "Happily Ever After" Fallacy
One of the most controversial aspects of The Dinner a novel by Herman Koch is the suggestion that violence might be hereditary. Paul struggles with a "condition" that leads to outbursts. When he sees his son, Michel, exhibiting similar traits, he doesn't see a criminal. He sees himself.
This brings up a massive ethical debate that literary critics like Janet Maslin and Claire Messud have chewed on for years: Is Paul’s loyalty to his son an act of love or an act of narcissism? If you protect your child because they are "part of you," are you really protecting them, or just your own legacy?
Many readers find the ending of the novel deeply unsatisfying or even offensive. Why? Because there is no moral reckoning. There’s no moment where a character realizes the error of their ways and turns themselves in to the police. Koch refuses to give the reader that catharsis. He leaves you sitting at the table with the bill, wondering if you’d be any different if it were your kid’s face on that security footage.
The International Impact and Why it Works
The book was a bestseller in Europe before it even touched American soil. It has been adapted into multiple films—a Dutch version, an Italian version (I nostri ragazzi), and a 2017 American version starring Richard Gere and Steve Coogan.
Interestingly, the adaptations often struggle to capture the coldness of Koch’s prose. On screen, we want to empathize with the actors. In the book, Koch prevents that. He keeps you at a distance. He makes sure you know that these people are, in many ways, monsters. But they are monsters who look exactly like the people you see at a nice restaurant on a Saturday night.
- The Dutch Original: Titled Het diner, published in 2009.
- The Translation: Sam Garrett captured the biting, sarcastic tone perfectly for the 2013 English release.
- The Controversy: It sparked endless book club debates about "unlikable characters"—a term Koch famously finds boring.
How to Actually Process This Book
If you're planning to read it—or re-read it—don't look for the "message." There isn't a neat moral at the bottom of the coffee cup. Instead, look at the way the environment influences the characters. Notice how the presence of the wives, Claire and Babette, shifts the power dynamic.
Claire, in particular, is a fascinating character. While Paul is the one talking to us, Claire is often the one making the chess moves. She is the "lioness" protecting her cub, and her calm acceptance of the situation is perhaps the most chilling part of the entire novel. It’s a masterful subversion of the "nurturing mother" trope.
Practical Next Steps for Readers and Book Clubs
If you want to get the most out of your experience with this story, stop reading reviews that summarize the plot and start looking at the ethics.
🔗 Read more: Degrassi The Next Generation Theme Song: Why You Still Can’t Get It Out of Your Head
Watch the 2005 Barcelona CCTV footage. Researching the real-world inspiration for the crime in the ATM vestibule changes your perspective on the boys' actions. It moves the conversation from "literary device" to "harsh reality."
Compare the adaptations. If you have the time, watch the Italian film I nostri ragazzi alongside the American version. The cultural differences in how the families handle the crisis—one with fiery emotion, the other with cold, litigious calculation—reveals a lot about how different societies view the concept of "family first."
Audit your own morality. Ask yourself: What is the specific "line" your child would have to cross before you stopped protecting them? Is it theft? Assault? Murder? The power of The Dinner a novel by Herman Koch isn't in the story it tells about the Lohmans; it's in the mirror it holds up to you while you're trying to enjoy your dessert.
Read it with a glass of wine, but don't expect it to go down easy. It’s meant to stick in your throat. This is a book that demands you take a side, even when both sides are wrong.