You drive over the causeway from Brunswick and the air just changes. It gets saltier, heavier, and somehow cleaner all at once. For a lot of people, the Georgia coast is just a blur of marshes on the way to Florida, but if you turn toward the marshes of Glynn, you hit something different. The Cloister at Sea Island isn't just a hotel. Honestly, calling it a resort feels like an understatement because it’s more like a private Mediterranean estate that somehow got lost and planted itself on a barrier island in the American South.
It’s been around since 1928. Think about that.
While most modern luxury resorts are busy trying to look like sleek glass boxes or minimalist concrete slabs, The Cloister leans hard into its Addison Mizner roots. Mizner was the guy who basically invented the Florida "Spanish Revival" look, and his fingerprints are everywhere here. Red-tile roofs. Towering palms. Exposed wood beams that look like they’ve seen a century of conversations. It’s grand, sure, but it’s not stiff. You’ll see guys in $4,000 suits walking past kids with sandy feet heading to the beach club. It’s a weird, beautiful mix of old-world formality and "I’m on vacation, leave me alone" energy.
The Architecture of The Cloister at Sea Island
Most people don't realize that the main building you see now isn't the original one from the twenties. The "New Cloister" opened in 2006, but they did something nearly impossible: they made it feel older than the original. They spent roughly $350 million to rebuild it. They brought in hand-painted ceilings, Turkish rugs that cost more than my first house, and stone carvings that feel like they belong in a European cathedral.
The Black Banks River sits right behind the main building. It's tidal, so the water moves in ways that make the marsh look like a living thing. If you stand on the terrace at sunset, the light hits the water and everything turns a deep, bruised purple. It’s quiet. You’ll hear the occasional clinking of a cocktail glass or the sound of a boat engine in the distance, but mostly, it’s just the wind in the spartina grass.
✨ Don't miss: Sani Club Kassandra Halkidiki: Why This Resort Is Actually Different From the Rest
The rooms are massive. We aren't talking about standard hotel "oversized" rooms. We’re talking about vaulted ceilings, deep soaking tubs that take twenty minutes to fill, and balconies where you can actually sit and spend three hours reading a book without feeling cramped. The design stays true to that Mediterranean-meets-Georgia aesthetic. Lots of dark wood, heavy fabrics, and ironwork. It feels substantial. You don't feel like you're staying in a temporary space; you feel like you've moved into a coastal manor.
Golf, Traditions, and the "Sea Island Way"
You can’t talk about Sea Island without talking about the golf. It’s basically the religion of the island. The Lodge and the Golf Performance Center are legendary. You’ve got Seaside, Plantation, and Retreat. Seaside is the big one—it’s a links-style course that hosts the PGA Tour’s RSM Classic every year.
The wind off the Atlantic makes Seaside a nightmare if your slice is acting up.
But it’s not just about the pros. There’s this specific culture here. It’s one of the few places left where people actually care about the dress code. You won’t see people in tattered gym shorts in the dining rooms. Is it elitist? Maybe a little. But for the people who come back year after year, that’s the draw. They like the fact that some things don’t change. They like the Sunday night bingo—which is a massive, high-stakes event for families—and they like the fact that the staff remembers their names from five years ago.
🔗 Read more: Redondo Beach California Directions: How to Actually Get There Without Losing Your Mind
The Beach Club is the social heart for families. It’s a five-minute bike ride from the main Cloister building. There are three pools, an ice cream shop that smells like sugar and salt, and access to five miles of private beach. You can walk for an hour and not see a single condo or high-rise. That’s the real luxury of Sea Island. In a world where every beach is crowded with neon umbrellas and kiosks, this is just dunes and sea oats.
Dining Without the Pretension
Eating at The Cloister at Sea Island can be as fancy or as low-key as you want. The Georgian Rooms is the "fancy" one. It’s the only Forbes Five-Star restaurant in the state. If you go there, you’re getting the tasting menu. You’re getting the wine pairings. You’re getting the gold-leaf service.
But honestly? Sometimes the best meal is just grabbing a burger at the Snack Shack or sitting at River Bar & Brasserie. The River Bar feels like an old English pub that somehow drifted into the marsh. It’s dark, moody, and they make a French Onion soup that could cure a cold. You sit there, watch the boats go by on the Black Banks River, and suddenly it’s 10:00 PM and you’ve forgotten you had a phone.
Why It Works When Others Fail
A lot of luxury resorts feel "manufactured." You know the feeling—everything is perfect but there’s no soul. The Cloister avoids this because it’s deeply rooted in the local ecology. They have a massive nature program. They have a resident naturalist. They take sea turtle nesting seriously. During the summer, you can go out with the patrol and see the nests. It reminds you that while you’re staying in a palace, you’re still on a wild barrier island.
💡 You might also like: Red Hook Hudson Valley: Why People Are Actually Moving Here (And What They Miss)
There is a specific kind of silence at Sea Island at night. Because there aren't many streetlights and the Atlantic is right there, the stars actually show up. It’s a place that forces you to slow down. You can’t rush here. The service is "Southern pace," which means it’s attentive but never hurried. If you’re used to the frantic energy of a New York or Vegas hotel, it takes about 24 hours to adjust. But once you do, you get it.
A Few Things to Keep in Mind
If you’re planning a trip, don't just stay in your room.
- Rent a bike immediately. It’s the only way to see the island. The paths are flat and they wind through these incredible tunnels of live oaks dripping with Spanish moss.
- Book your dinner reservations weeks in advance. Especially during the holidays or spring break. The island isn't huge, and the best tables go fast.
- Check the "Sea Island Life" magazine they put in the rooms. It sounds cheesy, but it lists the daily activities, like crabbing off the dock or falconry demonstrations. Yes, they have falconry. It’s exactly as cool as it sounds.
The Cloister at Sea Island is expensive. There’s no way around that. You’re paying for the privacy, the history, and the fact that you can leave your doors unlocked and feel totally safe. It’s a bubble. But it’s a bubble that has been meticulously maintained for nearly a century.
Practical Next Steps for Your Visit
If you're actually going to do this, don't just wing it. The resort is spread out, and knowing the layout helps.
- The Spa: It’s 65,000 square feet. Even if you aren't a "spa person," go for the garden atrium. It has a literal stream running through it and it's the most relaxing place on the property.
- The Shooting School: One of the best in the country. Even if you've never held a shotgun, the instructors are incredibly patient and focus heavily on safety.
- The Seasons: Fall is the sweet spot. The humidity drops, the gnats go away, and the marsh turns a golden-brown color that’s perfect for photos. Summer is beautiful but be prepared to sweat—Georgia heat is no joke.
- Getting There: Most people fly into Jacksonville (JAX) and drive up, which takes about an hour. You can also fly into Savannah, but Jacksonville is usually an easier straight shot.
Ultimately, the reason people keep coming back to The Cloister is the consistency. In a world that feels increasingly chaotic, there is something deeply comforting about a place where the tea is always sweet, the lawns are always manicured, and the ocean always sounds the same. It’s a slice of the past that’s been polished to a high shine, and it’s still one of the best experiences you can have on the American coast.