Science fiction fans love to argue. Put ten Trekkies in a room and you'll get twelve different opinions on which captain had the best hair or which warp drive physics actually make sense. But usually, the room goes quiet when you bring up "The City on the Edge of Forever." It’s basically the gold standard. Airing in 1967 as the penultimate episode of Star Trek: The Original Series’ first season, it didn't just win a Hugo Award; it fundamentally changed how people looked at televised sci-fi.
Most people remember the broad strokes. McCoy goes crazy, jumps through a giant glowing donut in space, and Kirk has to let the woman he loves die to save the future. Simple, right? Not really. Behind the scenes, the production was a literal nightmare that almost didn't happen.
The Script That Nearly Broke Gene Roddenberry
Harlan Ellison wrote the original draft. If you know anything about Ellison, you know he was brilliant, famously litigious, and possessed a temper that could melt lead. He turned in a script that was, honestly, way too big for a 1960s television budget. It had drug dealing, it had massive crowds, and it had a version of the Guardian of Forever that looked like a group of hooded giants.
Roddenberry hated it. He thought Ellison’s version made the crew look like criminals. In the original draft, a crewman named Beckwith is the one who changes history by selling "Sound" (a futuristic drug) and fleeing through the portal. Roddenberry wanted the mistake to be an accident, not a crime. He wanted his heroes to be heroes, even when they were failing.
This sparked a decades-long feud. Ellison was so pissed off that he tried to use his pseudonym "Cordwainer Bird" on the credits, which was basically his way of saying "this script is trash now." Roddenberry refused. The resulting episode was a Franken-script, stitched together by several writers including Dorothy Fontana and Gene L. Coon. Despite the chaos, the core of Ellison’s tragedy survived.
What Actually Happens in The City on the Edge of Forever
Let's look at the mechanics. Dr. McCoy accidentally injects himself with an overdose of cordrazine. He’s paranoid. He’s manic. He beams down to a planet that houses the Guardian of Forever, a sentient gateway to any time and place.
McCoy jumps through.
🔗 Read more: Love Island UK Who Is Still Together: The Reality of Romance After the Villa
Suddenly, the Enterprise is gone. By saving a woman named Edith Keeler in 1930s New York, McCoy has inadvertently allowed the Nazis to win World War II. It’s the ultimate butterfly effect. Kirk and Spock have to go back to "the depression" (as Spock calls it) to find McCoy and stop him.
Joan Collins plays Edith Keeler. She’s not some damsel. She runs the 21st Street Mission. She’s a visionary who believes in a future where man reaches for the stars. That’s the irony. Kirk falls for her because she shares his vision of the future, but her very existence—her pacifism—is what destroys that future. If she lives, she leads a peace movement that delays the United States' entry into the war. Germany develops the atomic bomb first. Everything ends.
The Gut-Punch Ending
There’s a specific shot that defines the series. Kirk is standing on the street. He sees Edith walking toward McCoy. He knows he has to stop McCoy from saving her. Spock is there, a cold reminder of logic, whispering "He must be stopped, Jim."
Kirk physically restrains McCoy. Edith is hit by a truck. It’s fast. It’s brutal. There’s no last-minute save. There’s no technobabble solution where they find a third way. Kirk has to choose between the woman he loves and the lives of billions. He chooses the billions, and the look on William Shatner's face—arguably his best acting ever—is one of pure, unadulterated devastation.
"Let's get the hell out of here."
That’s how it ends. No happy music. No bridge banter. Just a broken man returning to a ship that shouldn't exist.
💡 You might also like: Gwendoline Butler Dead in a Row: Why This 1957 Mystery Still Packs a Punch
Why the Ethics Still Hold Up Today
Ethicists and philosophy students have been tearing this episode apart for over fifty years. It’s a classic "Trolley Problem." Is the life of one innocent person worth the survival of the species?
Most TV shows of that era would have found a loophole. They would have saved Edith and the timeline. But "The City on the Edge of Forever" refused to blink. It established that in the Star Trek universe, the needs of the many really do outweigh the needs of the few, a theme that would be hammered home again in The Wrath of Khan.
The Historical Context
You have to remember what was happening in 1967. The Vietnam War was escalating. People were questioning whether "good" intentions always led to good outcomes. Edith Keeler represents the best of humanity—kindness, peace, hope. And yet, in the context of the 1930s, her virtues were a death sentence for the world. It’s a dark, cynical take for a show that was usually so optimistic.
The Legacy of the Guardian
The Guardian of Forever didn't just disappear after this episode. It became a staple of Trek lore. It showed up in the Animated Series, and it made a massive, plot-pivotal return in Star Trek: Discovery.
In Discovery, the Guardian (now going by "Carl") has evolved. It’s no longer just a stone archway on a desolate planet; it’s a witness to the temporal wars. The fact that modern writers keep coming back to this specific well shows how much gravity the original story had. It’s the ultimate "what if" machine.
Mistakes Modern Viewers Make
A lot of people think Ellison’s original script was objectively better just because it was "grittier." Honestly? I’m not so sure. Ellison's script was a masterpiece of prose, but the televised version is a masterpiece of character.
📖 Related: Why ASAP Rocky F kin Problems Still Runs the Club Over a Decade Later
Seeing McCoy—the heart of the trio—be the catalyst for the disaster makes it personal. Seeing Spock—the mind—have to force Kirk's hand makes it tragic. If it had just been some random crewman named Beckwith, we wouldn't care nearly as much. The rewrites, as messy as they were, centered the story on the friendship between Kirk, Spock, and McCoy. That’s why it hits so hard.
Production Trivia You Probably Missed
- The set for the 1930s street was actually the "RKO 40 Acres" backlot. It was used in The Andy Griffith Show and Gomer Pyle, U.S.M.C. * Joan Collins was actually one of the biggest stars they ever landed for the show. She took the role because her kids were fans of the series.
- The episode went over budget by about $50,000, which was a fortune back then. Desilu Studios was not happy.
- The "flashing light" effects for the Guardian were achieved through very low-tech means involving rotating prisms and manual light shifts.
The "City on the Edge of Forever" as a Cultural Touchstone
This story has been referenced everywhere from South Park to The Simpsons. It’s the blueprint for the "tragic time travel" trope. Think about Twelve Monkeys or Looper or even certain episodes of Doctor Who. They all owe a debt to the 21st Street Mission.
It teaches us that history is a fragile thing. We like to think we’re in control, but sometimes, the most "moral" choice is the one that causes the most personal pain. It’s a heavy lesson for a show that featured a man in a rubber Gorn suit just a few weeks prior.
How to Experience This Story Today
If you’re looking to dive deeper into this specific piece of history, don't just watch the episode. There are layers to this thing.
- Watch the Remastered Version: The CGI updates to the Guardian planet are actually pretty tasteful and help ground the scale of the ruins.
- Read the original Harlan Ellison Teleplay: It was published as a book. It’s vastly different. It’s angrier, more psychedelic, and features a very different ending.
- The IDW Comic Adaptation: There is a graphic novel that adapts Ellison’s original script faithfully. It’s the best way to see what he actually had in his head without the 1960s budget constraints.
- Listen to the Commentary: If you can find the Blu-ray sets, the commentary tracks with Dorothy Fontana and other Trek historians provide a blow-by-blow of the script battles.
Ultimately, "The City on the Edge of Forever" works because it’s not about time travel. It’s about the fact that love isn't enough to save the world. Sometimes, the hero has to be the person who lets the tragedy happen. That’s a bitter pill to swallow, but it’s what makes for great art.
If you want to understand why Star Trek survived its initial cancellation and became a global phenomenon, this is the episode you start with. It’s the one that proved sci-fi could be more than just monsters and lasers—it could be a mirror held up to the human soul.
Actionable Takeaways for Fans and Writers
- Analyze the Conflict: Study the contrast between Edith Keeler's pacifism and the necessity of WWII. It's a perfect example of "Right vs. Right" conflict where both sides have merit, but only one can survive.
- Compare the Drafts: Use the IDW comic and the aired episode as a masterclass in adaptation. Look at what was lost (the gritty realism) and what was gained (the emotional core of the main cast).
- Visit the Lore: If you're a Discovery or Strange New Worlds fan, re-watch this episode before diving into the "Temporal War" arcs. The context of the Guardian's origin makes the modern payoffs much more satisfying.
- Embrace the Ending: Note how the episode refuses a "coda." There is no scene of Kirk being okay. When writing your own stories, remember that sometimes leaving the wound open is more impactful than trying to heal it in the final two minutes.