Holiday movies are weird. We watch them once a year, usually while half-asleep or covered in flour, and yet we hold them to these bizarrely high standards of "coziness." If the vibes are off, the whole thing fails. But then you have The Christmas List, a 2016 Hallmark Channel original that somehow managed to nail the formula so well it’s still getting heavy rotation a decade later. It stars Alicia Witt as Isobel Gray, a woman who is, quite frankly, a bit too obsessed with planning.
She’s a stylist. She’s precise. She has a life plan that looks like a Gantt chart.
The premise is simple, maybe even a little cliché if we're being honest, but it works. Isobel heads to a snowy town—because where else would a Hallmark movie take place?—with a literal list of "perfect" Christmas traditions she wants to tick off. She’s got the boyfriend, the career, and the itinerary. Then, naturally, the boyfriend gets delayed, things go sideways, and she ends up hanging out with a local contractor named Jamie (played by Gabriel Hogan).
It’s a classic setup. But why do people keep coming back to this specific one?
The Psychology of the Perfectionist’s Holiday
Most holiday movies focus on a "grinch" learning to love the season. The Christmas List takes a different path. Isobel already loves Christmas; she just loves it too much. Or rather, she loves the idea of it. She’s chasing a version of the holidays that doesn't really exist in the messy, cold, unpredictable real world.
We’ve all been there. You want the perfect tree. You want the house to smell like pine and cinnamon, not wet dog and burnt cookies. When Isobel’s carefully curated plans start falling apart, it hits a nerve for anyone who has ever felt the "holiday pressure."
Alicia Witt brings a specific kind of frantic energy to the role that feels grounded. She’s not a caricature. You actually feel her anxiety when the "perfect" tree isn't available or when the weather refuses to cooperate. It’s a movie about losing control, which is the one thing most of us are terrified of during the month of December.
📖 Related: Why American Beauty by the Grateful Dead is Still the Gold Standard of Americana
Why Isobel and Jamie Actually Work
Jamie isn't your typical brooding Hallmark lead. He’s just a guy. Gabriel Hogan plays him with a relaxed, almost lazy charm that acts as the perfect foil to Isobel’s high-frequency vibrating energy.
Their chemistry isn't about some grand, sweeping tragedy. It’s built on small moments. Fixing a roof. Grabbing a coffee. Walking through a town that looks like it was designed by a professional gingerbread architect. The movie understands that romance in these films isn't about the "big reveal"—it's about the comfort of being with someone who doesn't expect you to have a checklist for every hour of the day.
The Aesthetic of Fall River
Let’s talk about the setting. The movie was filmed in British Columbia, specifically around Fort Langley. It’s a frequent filming location for these types of productions, but in The Christmas List, the town feels like a character.
The production design leans heavily into the "classic" aesthetic. We're talking heavy knits, warm amber lighting, and enough fake snow to cover a small country.
- The color palette: Lots of deep reds and forest greens, avoiding the neon-bright tones that sometimes make modern TV movies look cheap.
- The pacing: It’s slow. Not boring-slow, but cozy-slow. It allows the scenes to breathe, which is rare for a made-for-TV flick that has to hit specific commercial break beats.
Honestly, the town of Fall River looks like the kind of place where debt doesn't exist and everyone has a 401k. It’s pure escapism.
Beyond the Script: Alicia Witt’s Hallmark Legacy
You can't talk about The Christmas List without mentioning Alicia Witt’s status in the genre. She’s a classically trained pianist and a child prodigy (she was in David Lynch’s Dune, for crying out loud). Bringing that level of talent to a holiday movie elevates the material.
👉 See also: Why October London Make Me Wanna Is the Soul Revival We Actually Needed
She often writes or performs music for her films, and that artistic sensibility bleeds into her acting. She doesn't "phone it in." In this movie, she handles the comedic beats of the "failed list" moments with a self-deprecation that makes Isobel likable instead of annoying. If a less capable actress played her, Isobel might have come across as a spoiled brat. Witt makes her feel like a friend who just needs to take a deep breath and a shot of eggnog.
Breaking Down the "List" Trope
The "list" is a common storytelling device. Think The Bucket List or 10 Things I Hate About You. In holiday cinema, it’s a way to gamify the season.
Isobel’s list includes:
- Finding the perfect Douglas Fir.
- Caroling (the awkward kind).
- The "official" town tree lighting.
- Making specific family recipes.
The irony, of course, is that by the end of the movie, she realizes the list was the barrier to her happiness, not the key to it. It’s a meta-commentary on how we consume Christmas. We spend so much time trying to "do" Christmas that we forget to "be" in it.
Does it hold up in 2026?
Actually, yeah. If anything, the movie feels more relevant now. We live in an era of Instagram-perfect holidays and Pinterest-board expectations. The pressure to have a "curated" life is way higher now than it was in 2016. Watching Isobel’s digital-perfect plans crumble in favor of a messy, unplanned romance feels like a necessary detox.
Common Misconceptions About the Movie
People often confuse this with The Christmas List (1997) starring Mimi Rogers. That one is a bit more "magical" in the literal sense—with a department store Santa who actually grants wishes.
✨ Don't miss: How to Watch The Wolf and the Lion Without Getting Lost in the Wild
The 2016 version is more grounded. There’s no North Pole magic here. The "magic" is just human connection and maybe a really well-timed snowstorm.
Another mistake? Thinking it’s a sequel to something else. It stands alone. While Hallmark often does trilogies or recurring series (The Nine Lives of Christmas, for example), this is a self-contained story. You get the beginning, the middle, and the sugary-sweet end all in one go.
Practical Takeaways for Your Next Rewatch
If you’re planning to dive back into The Christmas List this season, do it right. This isn't a movie you watch while scrolling on your phone. It’s a "background" movie that demands 70% of your attention while you do something tactile.
- Pair it with a project. This is the ultimate "wrapping gifts" movie. The rhythm matches the task perfectly.
- Watch for the background details. The set decorators for this film went overboard in the best way. Every shop window in the "town" scenes is packed with real vintage Christmas decor.
- Pay attention to the music. Witt’s influence on the soundtrack is subtle but makes the emotional beats land a bit softer.
The real takeaway from the movie isn't that lists are bad. It's that the list should be a suggestion, not a mandate. Isobel’s journey from a rigid stylist to someone who can handle a delayed flight and a missed tradition is basically a therapy session wrapped in tinsel.
When you finish the movie, take a look at your own holiday to-do list. Cross off at least two things you're only doing because you feel like you "should." If Isobel Gray can survive a Christmas without a perfect Douglas Fir, you can probably survive skipping the neighborhood cookie swap that you secretly hate attending. Put on the movie, grab a drink, and stop worrying about the schedule.