Some movies just stick. You know the ones. They aren't necessarily cinematic masterpieces that win Oscars or change the course of film history, but they possess a weird, magnetic pull that brings you back every single December. The Christmas Card, a 2006 Hallmark Channel original, is the poster child for this phenomenon. If you haven't seen it, the premise sounds like a dozen other holiday flicks you’ve scrolled past on a Sunday afternoon. But there is something about Alice Evans and John Newton’s chemistry—and that specific mid-2000s cozy aesthetic—that makes it feel less like a "TV movie" and more like a comfort blanket.
It’s about a soldier. It’s about a card. Honestly, it’s about the idea that someone, somewhere, is thinking of you when you're at your lowest.
The story follows Sergeant Cody Cullen, played by John Newton, who is serving in Afghanistan. He receives a Christmas card from a woman he’s never met, Faith Spelman (Alice Evans), who lives in the picturesque town of Nevada City, California. He’s so moved by her words that, once he’s on leave, he decides to visit the town just to see the place the card came from. He doesn't go there to stalk her—it’s more of a pilgrimage to a piece of peace he found in a war zone. Of course, he ends up meeting her, and things get complicated because, well, she has a boyfriend.
✨ Don't miss: Daniel Radcliffe David Copperfield: What Most People Get Wrong
The Nevada City Factor
Most people don't realize that Nevada City isn't a Hollywood backlot. It’s a real place. The production team didn't just build a set; they utilized the actual Victorian-era architecture of this Gold Rush town. This authenticity is probably why the movie feels so grounded. When you see the snowy streets and the local church, you aren't looking at CGI or spray-on foam. You’re looking at a town that actually celebrates a "Victorian Christmas" every year.
Ed Asner is in this. Let that sink in for a second. Having a legendary actor like Asner play Faith’s father, Luke Spelman, gave the movie a weight that many Hallmark films lack. He wasn't just a background character; he represented the moral compass of the story. His performance reminds us that the movie isn't just a romance—it’s a family drama. Luke is a Vietnam veteran, and his immediate bond with Cody provides the film’s most emotional substrate. They share a language that Faith can’t quite speak, a silent understanding of what it means to serve and then come home to a world that hasn't changed while you have.
Why Cody Cullen Isn't Your Average Protagonist
Cody is quiet. Really quiet.
In most modern rom-coms, the lead guy is a fast-talking architect or a high-powered executive who needs to "learn the meaning of Christmas." Cody already knows the meaning. He’s seen the alternative. John Newton plays him with a stoicism that feels earned. There’s a specific scene where he’s just sitting in the Spelman wood shop, working with his hands, and you can see the gears turning. He isn't trying to win Faith over with grand gestures. He’s just there, being helpful, being steady.
✨ Don't miss: Joyce Kim Big Bang Theory: Why This Minor Character Matters More Than You Think
Compare this to Paul, Faith’s boyfriend. Paul is basically the "urban antagonist." He’s a wine merchant from the city who doesn't understand why anyone would want to stay in a small town. He isn't a villain, exactly. He’s just wrong for her. The tension in The Christmas Card doesn't come from a huge misunderstanding or a fake dating trope. It comes from the very real realization that Faith’s life is heading in a direction that doesn't fit her soul anymore.
Factual Nuances and the Production Legacy
Directed by Stephen Bridgewater, the film was a massive hit for Hallmark. In fact, when it premiered, it was the highest-rated cable movie in the network's history at that time. It snagged an Emmy nomination—not for the acting or the script, but for Ed Asner as Outstanding Supporting Actor in a Miniseries or Movie. That’s a big deal for a made-for-TV holiday flick.
The movie was written by Joany Kane. She has a knack for writing these kinds of stories, but this one felt personal. Maybe it was the timing. In 2006, the pulse of the country was very much tuned into the lives of soldiers overseas. Seeing a story that treated the military experience with genuine respect, rather than using it as a cheap plot device, resonated with audiences.
The film's impact on Nevada City was actually pretty significant. To this day, fans of the movie visit the town to see the National Hotel or the church where the final scenes take place. It put that location on the map for "Christmas tourism" in a way that hasn't really faded.
The Complexity of the "Card" Itself
The card isn't some poetic masterpiece. Faith wrote it as part of a church project. She didn't know who would receive it. This is a crucial detail because it removes the "destiny" element that usually makes these movies feel cheesy. It was a random act of kindness that happened to land in the hands of a man who needed it.
When Cody finally tells her he’s the one who got the card, it’s not some big "Ta-da!" moment. It’s awkward. It’s vulnerable.
Alice Evans plays Faith with a lot of nuance. She’s caught between the life she thought she wanted (the sophisticated city life with Paul) and the life that feels like home. You can see her struggle. She’s loyal to Paul, which makes her a likable protagonist. She isn't looking to cheat; she’s looking for clarity.
Practical Insights for the Modern Viewer
If you’re planning to revisit The Christmas Card this season, or if you're watching it for the first time, keep a few things in mind to get the most out of it:
- Watch for the Woodworking: The scenes in the Spelman lumber mill and wood shop are surprisingly accurate. They used real tools and real sawdust. It adds a tactile, "smell-o-vision" quality to the film.
- Pay Attention to Ed Asner: His performance is a masterclass in subtlety. Watch his eyes when he looks at Cody. He’s seeing his younger self, and it’s heartbreakingly beautiful.
- Check the Backdrop: Research the "Victorian Christmas" in Nevada City. Knowing that the town actually looks like that in real life makes the viewing experience feel much more authentic.
- Look for the Themes of Grief: The movie subtly deals with the loss of Cody’s friend in the opening sequence. This grief colors his entire journey and explains why he’s so desperate for the stability the Spelman family offers.
The movie ends exactly how you think it will. There are no shocking twists. But that’s the point. It’s a story about finding your way back to a place you didn't know you belonged. It’s about the fact that a simple piece of stationary and a postage stamp can, in the right circumstances, save a life.
To experience the film's legacy today, consider looking into the real-life Nevada City Victorian Christmas festival. Many of the filming locations, including the iconic downtown area, remain largely unchanged since 2006. If you are a fan of the genre, comparing this film to more modern Hallmark productions reveals a shift in tone; newer films often prioritize high-gloss visuals, whereas this movie leans heavily into texture, shadows, and a slower, more deliberate pace. Identifying these stylistic choices can deepen your appreciation for how holiday storytelling has evolved over the last two decades. For those interested in the craft, studying Joany Kane's script structure shows how to balance a romance with a heavy subplot regarding veteran affairs without letting the mood become too somber for a holiday audience.