You’re staring at your phone at 7:30 AM on a Tuesday. The waiver wire is a mess. You’ve got three guys on IR, and your "sleeper" wide receiver just got arrested for something involving a motorized scooter. It’s a disaster. Most people just panic-scroll through Twitter—or X, or whatever it's called now—but the smart players just hit play on the CBS Fantasy Football Podcast. It’s basically the comfort food of the fantasy industry. It isn't just about stats; it’s about the chemistry between Adam Aizer, Jamey Eisenberg, Dave Richard, and Heath Cummings.
Honestly, it’s a lot like sitting at a sports bar with friends who happen to have access to advanced tracking data and years of professional scouting experience. They argue. They yell. They talk about "The Bachelor" way more than you’d expect from a football show. But when the dust settles, they give you the exact logic you need to win your league.
The Dynamic That Makes It Work
Most podcasts are dry. You get a guy reading a spreadsheet for forty minutes, and by the end, you want to fall asleep at your desk. The CBS Fantasy Football Podcast avoids this because of the friction. You have Jamey and Dave, who have been doing this since the early 2000s, often clashing over player evaluations. Dave is the "Film Room" guy; he watches the tape, looks at the route running, and tells you why a player passed the eye test even if the box score was trash. Jamey is the "Big Picture" guy. He knows the trends and the history.
Then you have Heath Cummings. Heath is the math guy. He’s the one bringing the projections and the efficiency metrics to the table, often acting as the voice of reason when Dave or Jamey get too high on a specific "gut feeling." Adam Aizer, the host, is the glue. He’s the one who represents the average fan, asking the questions we actually want to know—usually while trying to keep the other three from spending twenty minutes arguing about a backup tight end in Jacksonville.
It’s this specific mix of personalities that keeps people coming back. You aren't just getting a ranking; you're getting a debate. And that’s important because fantasy football isn't a solved science. It's an exercise in probability. Seeing three experts disagree helps you realize that there isn't always a "right" answer, just a better process.
👉 See also: Why the 2025 NFL Draft Class is a Total Headache for Scouts
Why Five Days a Week Matters
Fantasy moves fast. A Friday afternoon practice report can change everything. One of the biggest reasons the CBS Fantasy Football Podcast stays at the top of the charts is their sheer volume of content. They are there every single day during the season.
- Monday: The recap. They go through every single game, looking for the "lies" in the box scores. Maybe a running back had 100 yards, but 80 of them came on one lucky broken tackle against a prevent defense. They'll tell you to sell high.
- Tuesday: Waiver wire day. This is the most important episode of the week. They prioritize which players you should burn your FAAB (Free Agent Acquisition Budget) on.
- Wednesday: Trade talk and rankings updates.
- Thursday: Starts, sits, and the Thursday Night Football preview.
- Friday: The "Bold Predictions" and final injury updates.
If you skip a day, you feel like you've missed a beat. It’s part of a routine. You listen while you’re at the gym or during your commute. Because they produce so much, they can go deep into the weeds on things like "expected touchdowns" or "target share percentage" without it feeling rushed.
Breaking Down the "Big Three" Strategies
The show doesn't just give you a list of names. They teach you how to think. Over the years, the CBS Fantasy Football Podcast crew has popularized several strategies that have changed how people draft.
The Anchor RB vs. Zero RB Debate
Heath Cummings is often the one pushing for a more analytical approach, sometimes leaning into Zero RB (ignoring running backs early) if the value isn't there. Dave, conversely, often looks for those "workhorse" guys who can carry a team. Listening to them debate the merits of taking a wide receiver in the first round versus a reliable back is like a masterclass in game theory. They don't just say "take this guy." They explain that if you take a receiver early, your mid-round strategy must pivot to high-upside pass-catching backs.
✨ Don't miss: Liverpool FC Chelsea FC: Why This Grudge Match Still Hits Different
The "Streaming" Philosophy
One thing the CBS crew excels at is teaching people not to overvalue certain positions. They were early adopters of streaming quarterbacks and defenses. Instead of drafting Patrick Mahomes in the second round, they might suggest waiting and playing the matchups. They provide the data to back it up, showing how a middle-of-the-pack QB against a terrible secondary often outperforms an elite QB against a top-tier defense.
Dynasty and Long-Term Value
While the daily show focuses on redraft, they have a massive presence in the dynasty community. They understand that a player's value isn't just about what they do this Sunday. They look at contract situations, coaching changes, and age curves. If a rookie receiver isn't producing in week 4, the CBS guys will look at his "air yards." If he's getting targets but just missing connections, they’ll tell you to hold steady. That nuance is what saves people from making emotional, league-losing trades.
The Role of the "Fantasy Cops"
One of the funniest and most relatable parts of the show is when they act as the "Fantasy Cops." They take emails from listeners who are dealing with league drama. Maybe a commissioner changed the rules mid-season, or a trade looks like collusion.
It sounds silly, but it’s actually a huge part of the community. Fantasy football is a social game. By addressing these "legal issues," the podcast helps set the standard for what a fair and fun league looks like. It builds a sense of belonging. You aren't just a listener; you're part of a global community of people who care way too much about a game involving men in spandex running into each other.
🔗 Read more: NFL Football Teams in Order: Why Most Fans Get the Hierarchy Wrong
Critical Nuance: Is It Always Right?
Look, no one is 100% accurate in fantasy football. If they were, they'd be betting millions in Vegas, not hosting a podcast. The CBS Fantasy Football Podcast has its misses. Sometimes they get "tunnel vision" on a certain player they loved in the pre-season. We’ve all been there—you draft a guy in every league because the "indicators" are there, and then he just... sucks.
What makes this show different is the accountability. They do "Grade the Guests" and "Recap the Picks" segments where they own their failures. If Dave Richard told you to start a guy who got zero points, he’s going to hear about it from Adam the next morning. That transparency is rare. A lot of "experts" just delete their old tweets and pretend they never liked the guy. The CBS crew leans into the pain. It makes them more trustworthy because you know they’re suffering right along with you when a "must-start" player flops.
How to Actually Use This Info to Win
If you want to get the most out of the CBS Fantasy Football Podcast, you can't just blindly follow their rankings. You have to listen to the why.
- Listen for the "Why," not the "Who": If Jamey Eisenberg says to start a specific receiver, listen to the reasoning. Is it because the opposing cornerback is out? Is it because the team’s lead running back is injured, forcing more passes? Use that logic to evaluate other players on your roster.
- Watch the Injury Reports: The crew is obsessive about practice participation. If a player is "Limited" on a Thursday, they’ll explain what that usually means for their Sunday outlook based on years of historical data.
- Use the CBS Tools: The podcast is just the tip of the spear. Their website has some of the best trade value charts in the industry. Dave Richard’s "Trade Value Chart" is basically the gold standard for many leagues. If you’re trying to pull off a 2-for-1 swap, check that chart first to make sure you aren't getting fleeced.
- Don't ignore the "Deep Sleepers": Sometimes they talk about a guy who is 1% rostered. Most people ignore that. But if you’re in a 14-team league, those are the tips that actually matter. They’ve called breakouts for guys like Puka Nacua or Kyren Williams long before they were household names.
Actionable Steps for Your Season
To turn these insights into a trophy, you need a system. Don't just listen to the podcast while you're half-asleep.
- Audit your roster every Tuesday morning. Before the waiver episode drops, identify your weakest link. Who is the "clog" on your bench? Be ready to drop them the second the guys mention a high-upside pickup.
- Check the "Start/Sit" column every Thursday. It’s the written companion to the podcast. It’s organized, easy to read, and gives you a quick baseline.
- Participate in the "Believe It or Not" segments. Mentally answer the questions before the experts do. It helps train your brain to spot trends versus flukes.
- Don't panic. The biggest takeaway from years of listening to Aizer and the crew is that fantasy football is a long game. One bad week doesn't end your season. Stay the course, trust the volume/usage data they provide, and the wins usually follow.
Success in fantasy isn't about knowing what will happen; it's about knowing the probability of what could happen. The CBS team gives you the math and the context to make those bets with confidence. Stop guessing and start listening. Your league mates probably already are.