Jack Nicholson wasn't supposed to be Melvin Udall. Well, let me rephrase that—he wasn't the only choice. Can you imagine Kevin Kline or John Travolta playing that obsessive-compulsive, acid-tongued romance novelist? It almost happened. But looking back, it's basically impossible to see anyone else in that role. The cast of movie As Good as It Gets didn't just perform a script; they captured a very specific, lightning-in-a-bottle kind of chemistry that shifted how we view romantic comedies. It wasn't just "boy meets girl." It was "broken man meets exhausted woman while holding a tiny dog."
James L. Brooks has this way of finding the humanity in people who are, frankly, hard to like. When the film dropped in 1997, it was a massive gamble. You had a protagonist who threw a neighbor’s dog down a trash chute in the first ten minutes. That's a bold move. Most studios would've panicked. Yet, the ensemble managed to turn a story about mental illness, homophobia, and class struggle into a box-office smash that pulled in over $314 million.
The Nicholson Factor: Melvin Udall’s Sharp Edges
Jack Nicholson already had two Oscars when he took this on. He didn't need the work. But his portrayal of Melvin Udall is a masterclass in "the slow burn." Nicholson understood that Melvin wasn't a villain; he was a man trapped by his own brain. The OCD traits—the double-locking of doors, the refusal to step on cracks, the bringing of his own plastic silverware to the diner—weren't just quirks. They were his armor.
It’s the nuance. Nicholson uses his eyebrows like a weapon, sure, but the real magic is in the moments where he’s silent. You see the pain when he realizes he’s insulted Carol again. He can’t help it. It’s like a reflex.
Did you know Nicholson took a percentage of the profits instead of a massive upfront salary? He knew. He felt the script was special. His performance earned him his third Academy Award, making him one of the few actors to reach that summit. He balanced the "mean old man" trope with a vulnerability that felt earned, not forced. When he says, "You make me want to be a better man," it isn't a cheesy line. It's a confession. It's a surrender.
Helen Hunt and the Reality of Carol Connelly
People often forget how much heavy lifting Helen Hunt did in this movie. At the time, she was the "Mad About You" girl. Some critics wondered if she could hold her own against a titan like Nicholson. She didn't just hold her own; she often stole the scene. Carol Connelly is the heartbeat of the film. She’s a single mother dealing with a chronically ill son and a mother who lives in her pockets. She’s tired. You can see the exhaustion in her posture.
👉 See also: The Entire History of You: What Most People Get Wrong About the Grain
Hunt’s performance is grounded in a very specific kind of New York working-class grit. She isn't a "manic pixie dream girl" sent to save Melvin. She’s a woman who needs a break and happens to find an unlikely, albeit deeply annoying, benefactor.
The scene in the restaurant where she forces him to give her a compliment is legendary. It’s raw. She’s wearing a dress she clearly can't afford, feeling out of place, and she demands to be seen. Hunt won the Oscar for Best Actress for this, marking a rare occasion where both leads in a comedy/drama took home the top prizes. It hasn't happened often since.
Greg Kinnear’s Breakout as Simon Bishop
Then there’s Greg Kinnear. Before this, Kinnear was mostly known as the charming, smirking host of Talk Soup. Nobody expected him to deliver a performance that would make you weep. As Simon Bishop, the gay artist who loses everything after a brutal assault, Kinnear had to bridge the gap between Melvin’s bigotry and the film’s redemptive arc.
It's a tough role. Simon is the victim of a hate crime, a plot point that feels incredibly heavy for a "rom-com." But Kinnear plays it with a flickering hope. The relationship between Simon and Melvin is actually the most important one in the movie. It’s about two people who have been discarded by society—Melvin by choice/illness and Simon by circumstance—finding a weird, platonic tether.
Kinnear’s Oscar nomination was a massive turning point for his career. He proved he wasn't just a "TV personality." He showed that Simon’s journey from a successful artist to a man who literally has to ask his "enemy" for a ride to Baltimore was the soul of the story.
✨ Don't miss: Shamea Morton and the Real Housewives of Atlanta: What Really Happened to Her Peach
The Supporting Players and That Famous Dog
We have to talk about Cuba Gooding Jr. as Frank Sachs. He was coming off his Jerry Maguire win and brought this frantic, protective energy to the role of Simon's agent. He provides the necessary friction. He’s the only one who can stand up to Melvin without flinching.
And then, the real star. Verdell.
The dog was played primarily by a Brussels Griffon named Jill. There were actually six different dogs used, but Jill was the lead. It’s a testament to the cast of movie As Good as It Gets that a four-pound animal becomes the catalyst for a grown man's emotional evolution. Melvin hating the dog, then feeding the dog bacon, then eventually loving the dog is the most basic, effective storytelling there is. It works every time.
Why This Ensemble Still Works in 2026
Looking back from today's perspective, the movie isn't perfect. Some of the dialogue regarding Simon's sexuality is dated. It’s a product of the late 90s. However, the core of the film—the idea that people are messy, difficult, and worth the effort—still lands.
The film succeeded because it didn't try to "fix" Melvin. At the end, he still has OCD. He still struggles. But he’s trying. That’s the "as good as it gets" part. It’s not a fairy tale; it’s a slight improvement on a lonely life.
🔗 Read more: Who is Really in the Enola Holmes 2 Cast? A Look at the Faces Behind the Mystery
If you’re looking to revisit this classic or study how character-driven ensembles should work, pay attention to the pacing. The way Nicholson and Hunt talk over each other in the diner. The way Kinnear uses his bandages as a physical manifestation of his internal brokenness.
Practical Next Steps for Film Buffs and Rewatchers
To truly appreciate the depth of this cast, try these specific viewing lenses next time you hit play:
- Watch the Hands: Notice how Jack Nicholson uses his hands. Melvin’s fidgeting and the way he handles objects is a separate performance in itself. It’s consistent throughout the entire two-hour-plus runtime.
- Track the Wardrobe: Look at the color palette of Carol’s clothes compared to Melvin’s. She starts in muted, stressed tones and slowly shifts as the Baltimore trip approaches.
- Listen for the "Overlap": James L. Brooks encouraged naturalistic, overlapping dialogue. Instead of waiting for their "turn" to speak, the actors cut each other off, mimicking real-life frustration.
- Compare to the Script: If you can find the original screenplay, see how much of the "Melvin-isms" were improvised. Nicholson added several of the sharpest stings during rehearsals.
The movie is currently streaming on several platforms like Netflix and Amazon Prime (depending on your region), and it remains one of the best examples of how a perfectly calibrated cast can turn a simple premise into a timeless character study.