Sergio Leone didn’t even want to make a third movie. He felt he’d said everything he needed to say about the American West with two movies and a handful of cigars. But United Artists dangled money, a lot of it, and so we ended up with the definitive spaghetti western. When people talk about the cast of the Good the Bad and the Ugly, they usually just think of Clint Eastwood squinting into the sun.
That’s a mistake.
The chemistry between the three leads wasn't just some lucky accident of 1960s casting directors. It was a friction-filled, multi-lingual, and occasionally dangerous collision of egos and styles. You had a TV star from America, a method actor from Brooklyn, and a refined Italian character actor who barely spoke English. Somehow, it worked. It more than worked; it rewrote the rules of cinema.
The Man with No Name (And a lot of grievances)
Clint Eastwood was already a star by 1966, but he wasn't the Clint Eastwood yet. He was actually quite annoyed during filming. Why? Because he felt he was being upstaged. In the script, the character of Tuco had most of the dialogue and most of the "colorful" moments. Eastwood actually delayed signing onto the film because he was worried about being the "straight man" to Eli Wallach.
He almost walked.
He eventually took the role of Blondie (The Good) for $250,000 and a percentage of the profits. If you watch his performance closely, you’ll notice he’s doing more with his eyes than his mouth. That wasn't just "cool" acting. It was a survival tactic. Eastwood knew that against Wallach’s high-energy theatrics, he had to be the anchor. He brought his own wardrobe from the previous Dollars films—the iconic sheepskin vest and the poncho that was never washed during the entire trilogy. He hated the cigars. He told Leone that the cigars put him in a foul mood, which, ironically, was exactly the look Leone wanted.
Eli Wallach and the chaos of Tuco
Eli Wallach was the heart of the cast of the Good the Bad and the Ugly. Hands down. Honestly, the movie belongs to him. Leone originally wanted Gian Maria Volonté for the role of Tuco (The Ugly), but Volonté lacked the comedic "spark" needed for a guy who is simultaneously a murderer and a buffoon.
✨ Don't miss: Why La Mera Mera Radio is Actually Dominating Local Airwaves Right Now
Wallach was a New York stage actor. He was trained in "The Method." When he got to the set in Spain, he had no idea how to play a bandit. He just leaned into his instincts.
He almost died. Multiple times.
There’s that scene where he’s at the train tracks, trying to break his chains by letting a train run over the links. That was real. No stunt double. The steps of the train passed inches from his head. In another scene, he accidentally drank acid that a film technician had left in a soda bottle. His mouth was burned, but he kept filming. That frantic, desperate energy you see in Tuco? That's not just acting; that's a man who survived several near-death experiences on a Sergio Leone set.
Lee Van Cleef: The villain who was actually a nice guy
Then there’s Lee Van Cleef. The Bad. Sentenza.
Van Cleef was a journeyman actor who had been struggling with a drinking problem and a career that was effectively dead before Leone cast him in For a Few Dollars More. He was so broke he was painting houses to make ends meet. Leone loved his "predatory" eyes. He looked like a hawk.
In real life? Van Cleef was remarkably soft-spoken and gentle. There is a famous story about the scene where he has to hit a woman. He couldn't do it. He told Leone he didn't hit women in real life and didn't want to do it on screen. They had to use a stunt double for the physical contact.
🔗 Read more: Why Love Island Season 7 Episode 23 Still Feels Like a Fever Dream
He brought a cold, calculating stillness to the cast of the Good the Bad and the Ugly that balanced out Wallach’s noise and Eastwood’s stoicism. He didn't need to shout to be terrifying. He just needed to stare.
The language barrier and the dubbed reality
You have to remember that this set was a tower of Babel.
Clint Eastwood, Eli Wallach, and Lee Van Cleef spoke English. Most of the supporting cast—guys like Luigi Pistilli (who played Tuco's brother, Father Pablo)—spoke Italian or Spanish. Sergio Leone spoke very little English.
Communication was basically a series of hand gestures and shouting.
Because of this, the film was shot "silent" or with "guide tracks." The actors would speak their native languages, and everything was dubbed later in post-production. This is why the lip-syncing looks a bit "off" if you watch it today. It also allowed Leone to focus entirely on the visual composition. He treated the actors like moving parts of a painting rather than speakers of dialogue. This is a huge reason why the movie feels so operatic. It’s less about what is said and more about the look on their faces during those extreme close-ups.
The supporting players you probably missed
While the big three get the glory, the rest of the cast of the Good the Bad and the Ugly was filled with Leone regulars.
💡 You might also like: When Was Kai Cenat Born? What You Didn't Know About His Early Life
- Aldo Giuffrè: He played the alcoholic Union Captain at the bridge. His performance is actually one of the most grounded in the movie, providing a rare moment of genuine pathos amidst all the greed.
- Mario Brega: The big, burly guy who plays Corporal Wallace (the one who beats up Tuco). Brega was a former butcher and appeared in almost all of Leone’s films. He was notoriously strong and actually hit Wallach for real in a few takes to get the reaction Leone wanted.
- Antonio Casas: He played Stevens in the opening sequence. That tension-filled scene where Angel Eyes eats the soup? That's Casas selling the absolute terror of a man who knows he’s about to die.
Why the casting still works 60 years later
Most modern movies try to make their heroes "relatable." Leone didn't care about that. He wanted icons. He wanted archetypes.
The cast of the Good the Bad and the Ugly succeeded because each actor represented a different facet of the human condition under pressure. Wallach is the desperate animal (survival). Van Cleef is the predator (greed). Eastwood is the opportunist with a sliver of a soul (morality).
They weren't friends. Eastwood and Wallach got along okay, but there was a professional distance. Wallach was often annoyed that Eastwood was so quiet. Eastwood was annoyed that Leone took so long to set up shots. This tension bled into the film. When you see the three of them staring at each other during the final standoff at Sad Hill Cemetery, that isn't just movie magic. It’s the culmination of months of grueling work in the Spanish heat, language barriers, and a director who cared more about the light than the actors' comfort.
How to watch it with fresh eyes
If you're going to revisit the film, don't just look at the gunfights.
Watch Eli Wallach’s hands. He’s constantly moving, constantly fidgeting. Compare that to Lee Van Cleef, who remains almost perfectly still until he moves to kill. Then look at Eastwood, who is the "center" that doesn't hold.
The brilliance of the cast of the Good the Bad and the Ugly isn't just in the individual performances, but in how Leone edited them together. He used the "Kuleshov Effect"—placing a shot of a face next to a shot of something else (gold, a noose, a gun)—to make us project emotions onto the actors that they might not even have been feeling at the time.
Practical insights for film buffs
To truly appreciate the depth of this cast, you should look into the following:
- Check out the Extended Cut: It restores several scenes, including more dialogue between Tuco and Blondie, which gives their "friendship" a bit more weight.
- Compare to "The Magnificent Seven": Watch Eli Wallach as Calvera (the villain) in The Magnificent Seven right before watching him as Tuco. It’s a masterclass in how a "Method" actor adapts to the Western genre.
- The Sad Hill Pilgrimage: If you’re ever in Burgos, Spain, you can actually visit the restored Sad Hill Cemetery. It was rebuilt by fans and shows the massive scale the actors had to work within for that final scene.
- Listen to the Ennio Morricone Score separately: Morricone wrote the music before some scenes were finished, and Leone would play the music on set to help the actors get into the right "rhythm."
The reality of this film is that it was a messy, dangerous, and chaotic production. It shouldn't have been a masterpiece. But the specific combination of Eastwood’s silence, Wallach’s noise, and Van Cleef’s coldness created a lightning-in-a-bottle moment that no remake or sequel has ever been able to touch.