Lisa Kudrow didn’t just play a character in The Comeback. She basically invented a mirror for every aging star in Hollywood to look into and cringe. It’s been years since Valerie Cherish first tried to "get it!" and yet, we are still obsessed with the cast of The Comeback because they captured something so painfully authentic about the industry that hasn’t changed a bit. Honestly, if you watch it today, it feels more like a documentary than a sitcom.
The Brilliant Awkwardness of Valerie Cherish
Valerie is the heart of it. Obviously. Lisa Kudrow took the "ditzy" energy she perfected as Phoebe on Friends and twisted it into something deeply desperate and surprisingly empathetic. She’s a former A-list sitcom star who is willing to be humiliated just to stay in the frame. That’s the core of the show. It’s about the cost of relevance.
Kudrow didn't do this alone, though. She co-created the series with Michael Patrick King. They knew that for Valerie to work, she needed a foil. She needed people around her who were either enabling her delusions or actively trying to crush them.
Robert Michael Morris as Mickey Deane
We have to talk about Mickey. Robert Michael Morris, who sadly passed away in 2017, was the emotional glue. Mickey was Valerie’s hair stylist and her biggest cheerleader. He was also the only person who seemed to actually love her without an agenda. Their relationship is weirdly beautiful. It’s built on hairspray, secrets, and a shared history of Hollywood wars. Morris wasn't even a professional actor when he was cast; he was a former teacher of Michael Patrick King. That lack of "polished" acting is exactly why Mickey feels like a real human being instead of a caricature.
The Writers' Room Villains
The cast of The Comeback wouldn't be complete without the people who hated Valerie. Enter Paulie G. and Tom Peterman.
Seth Ruffin played Tom, the "nice" writer who eventually becomes part of the problem. But Lance Barber? He turned Paulie G. into a legendary TV antagonist. Paulie G. is the showrunner of IT and Girls (the show within the show), and he spends most of his time trying to write Valerie out of existence. He’s sweaty, he’s angry, and he represents that specific brand of mid-2000s toxic masculinity that plagued writers' rooms.
Watching Barber play Paulie G. is like watching a slow-motion car crash. You want to look away, but he’s so committed to being miserable that it’s magnetic.
Why the Dynamic Works
- Valerie wants to be loved.
- Paulie G. wants to be respected as an "artist."
- Mickey just wants Valerie to look good in her red tracksuit.
These competing desires create a friction that most sitcoms are too scared to touch. It’s not "zany." It’s uncomfortable. It’s the kind of TV that makes your skin crawl because you know someone, somewhere, is actually having these conversations in a trailer on a studio lot.
📖 Related: Isaiah Washington Movies and Shows: Why the Star Still Matters
The Evolution of the Cast in Season 2
When the show returned nine years later, the stakes shifted. The cast of The Comeback had to age in real-time. This is where the show moved from "funny satire" to "prestige drama masquerading as a comedy."
Valerie is no longer just trying to get a job; she’s trying to win an Emmy. The desperation is deeper. The lines on her face are more visible. Kudrow’s performance in the second season is, frankly, one of the best things ever broadcast. She captures the exhaustion of being a woman in an industry that prizes youth above all else.
Then there’s Jane.
Laura Silverman plays Jane, the deadpan producer of Valerie’s reality show. In the first season, Jane is a background player. In the second, she becomes Valerie’s conscience. Their relationship evolves into this strange sisterhood where Jane realizes that while Valerie is ridiculous, she’s also a survivor. Silverman’s minimalist acting is the perfect counterpoint to Kudrow’s high-frequency anxiety.
Supporting Players Who Stole the Scene
You can't overlook the younger actors who played the stars of IT and Girls. Kellan Lutz and Malin Åkerman were perfectly cast as the "hot young things" who were completely oblivious to Valerie’s legacy.
Kellan Lutz played Chris MacNess. He was the eye candy. But over time, the show actually gave him layers. He wasn't just a jock; he was someone navigating his own fleeting fame. Malin Åkerman as Juna Millken was even better. Juna could have been the "mean girl" trope. Instead, she was kind to Valerie. That kindness actually hurt Valerie more because it highlighted the massive power gap between the two women. Juna was the star, and Valerie was the "Aunt Sassy" character relegated to the background.
Realism Over Polish
Most "shows about shows" feel fake. They use bright lights and snappy dialogue. The Comeback chose a different path. By using the "found footage" and reality TV camera style, the cast of The Comeback had nowhere to hide.
👉 See also: Temuera Morrison as Boba Fett: Why Fans Are Still Divided Over the Daimyo of Tatooine
If a joke didn't land, the camera stayed on Valerie's face for five seconds too long.
If Paulie G. was being a jerk, we saw it through a grainy lens from across the room.
This technical choice forced the actors to be incredibly disciplined. They couldn't "wink" at the audience. They had to live in the embarrassment. Damian Young, who played Valerie's husband Mark Berman, is the king of this. Mark is just a guy trying to live his life while his wife invites a film crew into their bedroom. Young plays him with a weary, resigned patience that feels incredibly grounded. He's the audience's surrogate.
The Legacy of the Ensemble
Why do we still talk about this specific group of actors? It’s because they represented the hierarchy of fame so accurately.
- The Washed-Up Star (Valerie)
- The Rising Star (Juna)
- The Reluctant Enabler (Mickey)
- The Tortured Creator (Paulie G.)
- The Exhausted Spouse (Mark)
Every person in the cast of The Comeback understands their place in that food chain. The show is essentially a study of power. Who has it? Who lost it? And what are they willing to do to get it back?
Valerie’s journey is ultimately a tragedy with a laugh track. She gets what she wants—the fame, the awards, the recognition—but she loses her dignity in the process. Or does she? That’s the debate. Some fans argue Valerie is the smartest person in the room because she knows exactly what she’s trading away. Others see her as a victim of a system that chews up women and spits them out.
What You Can Learn from the Cast's Performance
If you’re a student of acting or just a fan of great storytelling, there are a few "actionable" takeaways from how this cast handled the material.
First, look at the silence. The best moments in The Comeback happen when nobody is talking. Watch Lisa Kudrow's eyes when she's told she's not needed for a scene. That's where the real acting lives.
✨ Don't miss: Why Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy Actors Still Define the Modern Spy Thriller
Second, notice the lack of vanity. Every member of the cast of The Comeback was willing to look bad. Truly bad. Not "TV ugly," but emotionally ugly. Barber let himself be loathsome. Kudrow let herself be pathetic. This lack of ego is what makes the show immortal.
Key Takeaways for Fans and Creators:
- Commit to the Bit: Satire only works if the actors play it straight. If the cast had signaled that they were "in on the joke," the tension would have evaporated.
- Embrace the Cringe: Modern comedy (think The Office or Curb Your Enthusiasm) owes a massive debt to the way this ensemble handled discomfort.
- Character Over Plot: The "plot" of The Comeback is simple. It's the shifting power dynamics between the characters that keep you watching.
- Value the "Straight Man": Without characters like Mark and Jane to ground the reality, Valerie would be too much to handle. You need the "normal" people to make the "crazy" people pop.
The cast of The Comeback gave us a masterclass in nuanced performance. They didn't just play roles; they inhabited a very specific, very lonely corner of the entertainment industry. If you haven't revisited the show lately, go back and watch the scenes between Valerie and Mickey. It’s a reminder that even in the fake world of Hollywood, real human connection is the only thing that actually matters.
To really appreciate the depth here, watch the Season 2 finale again. Pay attention to how the camera moves. It stops being a reality show and starts being a cinematic experience, mirroring Valerie’s own transition from "content" to "actress." It’s a subtle shift, but it changes everything about how we perceive the characters we spent two seasons laughing at.
Stop looking for "perfect" characters. Start looking for the messy ones. That's where the truth is. That's why Valerie Cherish is still the most relevant woman on television, even if she's just a character in a red tracksuit.
Next time you're scrolling through a streaming service, don't look for the new hits. Go back to 2005 and 2014. Watch the way these actors handled the "behind the scenes" madness. It's better than any modern reality show because it's honest about how dishonest the industry is.
Keep an eye on the background actors, too. The "crew" members in the show were often actual crew members or actors who stayed in character for hours. That level of immersion is why the world feels so lived-in. You don't get that in standard multi-cam sitcoms. You only get it when a cast is fully committed to the vision of their creators.
Valerie Cherish would want you to watch it. She'd probably want you to tweet about it, too. Just make sure you use her "good side" in the thumbnail.
Actionable Next Steps:
- Watch the Season 1 and Season 2 finales back-to-back to see the character arc of Valerie and Paulie G.
- Track the "camera" as a character itself; notice how the "found footage" style changes based on Valerie's level of control.
- Compare the portrayal of the "writers' room" in The Comeback to other shows like 30 Rock to see the difference between parody and cutting satire.