Let’s be real for a second. If you mention Beverly Hills Cop III to a hardcore Eddie Murphy fan, you’re usually met with a wince or a long, frustrated sigh. It’s the "theme park one." By 1994, the high-octane, R-rated energy of the first two films had been sanded down into something... weirdly PG-13 and sanitized. But if you look past the giant mechanical spiders and the Wonder World setting, the cast of Beverly Hills Cop III is actually a bizarrely fascinating time capsule.
It’s a mix of returning legends trying to keep the spark alive and some of the most "wait, they were in this?" cameos in cinema history.
The Axel Foley Problem and Eddie’s Mid-90s Pivot
Eddie Murphy was in a weird spot. By the time production rolled around, he didn't want to be "funny Axel" anymore. He wanted Axel Foley to be a mature, seasoned detective. This created a strange tension on screen. You have Eddie Murphy—the guy who literally redefined big-screen charisma in the 80s—playing it straight while surrounded by cartoonish villains and a theme park backdrop.
It’s jarring.
Honestly, seeing the cast of Beverly Hills Cop III navigate this tonal shift is like watching a jazz band try to play a heavy metal set. They’re talented, but the sheet music is all wrong. Murphy still has that smirk, but it’s dialed back. He’s more focused on the action, which, let's face it, isn't why we fell in love with Axel in the first place. We wanted the "banana in the tailpipe" energy. Instead, we got Axel fighting guys in security uniforms.
Judge Reinhold: The Last Man Standing
Judge Reinhold returned as Billy Rosewood, and thank goodness he did. Without him, the movie would have lost its only tether to the original chemistry. By this third installment, Rosewood has been promoted to Deputy Director of Joint Operations Inter-Agency Task Force. It’s a mouthful. It also signifies how much the character had grown from the bumbling, plant-loving rookie of 1984.
Reinhold plays Rosewood with a palpable sense of weariness that actually works. He’s still got that "let's go get 'em" spirit, but you can tell he’s seen some stuff. It’s the most authentic performance in the film. He’s the bridge. He’s the guy reminding us that this is still technically the same universe where Axel tricked a whole hotel staff into giving him a suite.
Where Was John Taggart?
The biggest hole in the cast of Beverly Hills Cop III was undeniably the absence of John Ashton. The Taggart and Rosewood dynamic was the engine of the first two movies. The grumpy, by-the-book veteran versus the over-eager kid.
📖 Related: Big Brother 27 Morgan: What Really Happened Behind the Scenes
So, where was he?
In the world of the movie, Rosewood mentions that Taggart retired to Phoenix to play golf. In reality, Ashton reportedly didn't like the script and chose to sit this one out. It was a massive blow to the film's DNA. To fill that void, the producers brought in Hector Elizondo as Jon Flint. Now, Elizondo is a legend. He’s fantastic in Pretty Woman. He’s a pro’s pro. But he wasn't Taggart. The chemistry with Murphy felt respectful rather than brotherly. It felt like Axel was working with a nice uncle instead of his old partner-in-crime.
The Villains: From Art Dealers to Corporate Thugs
The first Beverly Hills Cop had Steven Berkoff as Victor Maitland—a man who radiated pure, upper-class menace. The second had Jürgen Prochnow. They were heavy hitters.
In the third movie, we get Timothy Carhart as Ellis DeWald.
DeWald is a high-ranking security head at Wonder World who is secretly running a massive counterfeiting ring. Carhart plays him with a cold, smug arrogance that makes you want to see him get punched, but he lacks the "final boss" energy of the previous villains. He feels more like a mid-level manager who got caught skimming off the top.
Then there’s Alan Young. Yes, Mr. Ed himself. He plays Dave Thornton, the "Walt Disney" stand-in who owns Wonder World. It’s a bittersweet bit of casting. Young is incredibly likable, and his presence adds a layer of genuine sadness to the plot when his park is being used for evil, but it further cements the movie's shift away from the gritty streets of Detroit and towards a family-friendly adventure vibe.
The Cameo Hall of Fame
If the main plot feels a bit thin, the cameos are where the cast of Beverly Hills Cop III gets truly legendary. Director John Landis basically called every director friend he had and asked them to show up for a day.
👉 See also: The Lil Wayne Tracklist for Tha Carter 3: What Most People Get Wrong
Check this out:
- George Lucas: Yes, the Star Wars creator appears as "Disappointed Man" who gets cut in line at a ride. It’s a blink-and-you’ll-miss-it moment, but it’s wild.
- Martha Coolidge: The director of Valley Girl and Real Genius plays a woman in the park.
- Joe Dante: The man behind Gremlins is a jailer.
- Barbet Schroeder: Another acclaimed director, just hanging out in the background.
- Arthur Hiller: He was the President of the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences at the time!
Why so many directors? Landis had a habit of doing this, but in this movie, it feels like a secret "Where's Waldo" game for film nerds. It doesn't necessarily make the movie better, but it makes it a great trivia piece.
Bronson Pinchot: The Return of Serge
The undisputed highlight of the film is the return of Serge.
When Axel walks into that boutique/survivalist shop and hears that thick, indeterminate accent, the movie finally breathes. Bronson Pinchot is a comic genius. His transition from an art gallery assistant to a high-end arms dealer selling the "Annunciator" (a weapon that also plays music and dispenses items) is pure gold.
"Axel? Is that you, Axel?"
The brief moments between Murphy and Pinchot are the only times we see the "old" Axel Foley come out to play. It’s the improvisation, the riffing, and the genuine laughter. Pinchot reportedly improvised a huge chunk of his dialogue, and it shows. He’s operating on a completely different frequency than the rest of the movie, and thank God for that.
Why the Casting Matters for the 2024 Sequel
You can’t talk about the 1994 cast without looking at how it shaped Beverly Hills Cop: Axel F on Netflix. The reason fans were so hyped for the 2024 return was specifically because it "corrected" the cast list.
✨ Don't miss: Songs by Tyler Childers: What Most People Get Wrong
They finally got the band back together.
- John Ashton (Taggart) returned.
- Judge Reinhold (Rosewood) returned.
- Paul Reiser (Jeffrey Friedman) returned.
- Bronson Pinchot (Serge) returned.
The third movie felt like a fractured family. The newest one felt like a homecoming. It proves that the cast of Beverly Hills Cop III failed not because the actors were bad, but because the central trio—Axel, Taggart, and Rosewood—was the heart of the franchise. You can't just swap out a vital organ and expect the body to run the same way.
Is it worth a rewatch?
If you’re a completionist, yeah. Watching the cast of Beverly Hills Cop III is a lesson in 90s studio filmmaking. It shows how a franchise can lose its way by trying to appeal to everyone and ending up appealing to no one.
However, there is a weird, kitschy charm to it now. The 90s aesthetic of Wonder World, the practical effects of the rides, and the sheer audacity of having George Lucas stand in a line for a ride called "The Spider" is worth the price of admission.
Actionable Insights for Your Next Movie Night
If you're planning to dive back into this franchise, here’s how to handle the third installment without getting frustrated:
- Watch it as a spinoff: Don't view it as the "grand finale" of the trilogy. Treat it like a weird, high-budget TV special. It lowers the stakes and lets you enjoy the silliness.
- Spot the Directors: Make a game of it. Every time you see a famous director in the background, take a note. It turns a mediocre action movie into a scavenger hunt.
- Focus on Serge: Seriously, skip to the Serge scenes if you have to. Pinchot is the MVP here.
- Compare the Rosewood Arc: Look at how Judge Reinhold plays Billy here versus the first movie. It’s actually a very consistent piece of character acting. He goes from a guy who doesn't know what a "banana in the tailpipe" is to a guy who is basically a tactical expert.
The movie isn't a masterpiece. We all know that. But the cast of Beverly Hills Cop III worked with what they had. They were pros in a production that was struggling to find its identity. Whether it was Gilbert R. Hill (Inspector Todd) giving Axel one last legendary yelling-at before his character's untimely demise, or Theresa Randle trying to bring some grounded energy to the role of Janice, the talent was there. It just needed a better script and a few more bananas in tailpipes.
If you haven't seen the 2024 sequel yet, go watch that immediately after. It’s the palate cleanser you’ll definitely need after spending two hours in Wonder World. It brings back that Detroit grit and, most importantly, it brings back the chemistry that this 1994 cast was desperately missing.