David Cronenberg didn't just make a movie in 2005. He basically deconstructed the American dream using a coffee pot and a shotgun. If you haven't seen it in a while, or if you’re just now looking into the cast of A History of Violence, you might expect a standard "man with a past" thriller. You'd be wrong. It’s way weirder than that. It’s a movie that feels like a cold sweat, mostly because the actors involved aren’t playing characters—they’re playing archetypes that are slowly rotting from the inside out.
Viggo Mortensen is the anchor. Honestly, coming off The Lord of the Rings, he could have done anything. He chose to play Tom Stall, a small-town diner owner in Millbrook, Indiana, who might actually be Joey Cusack, a mid-level Philadelphia mobster with a penchant for gouging eyes out.
Viggo Mortensen and the Art of the Double Life
Viggo’s performance is a masterclass in stillness. You see him at the start of the film, pouring coffee, being the "perfect" dad. He’s soft-spoken. He’s gentle. Then, these two guys walk into his diner—bad guys, real predators—and something in Viggo’s eyes just... clicks. It’s not a hero moment. It’s a survival reflex.
The way the cast of A History of Violence handles the shift from domestic bliss to visceral gore is what makes the film stay with you. Mortensen reportedly spent time in the Midwest, buying props for the Stall house himself to make the setting feel lived-in. He didn't want a Hollywood version of Indiana; he wanted the real thing. When he finally "becomes" Joey again, he doesn't just change his voice. His entire posture shifts. He looks heavier, meaner. It’s a terrifying transformation because you realize Tom Stall was just a mask, but maybe Joey is too.
Maria Bello and the Complexity of Edie Stall
Most "wife" roles in crime thrillers are thankless. They cry, they get kidnapped, they stand in the background looking worried. Maria Bello did something different. As Edie Stall, she is the moral center of the movie, but she’s also deeply complicit in the fantasy.
There is a specific scene on the stairs—it’s famous, or maybe infamous—where the violence of Tom’s secret past leaks into their marriage. It’s uncomfortable to watch. Bello plays it with this mix of horror and undeniable attraction that feels messy and human. She’s not just a victim of Tom’s lies; she’s someone who has to decide if she loves the man she knew or the monster who saved her family.
Edie’s Arc
It’s easy to overlook how much Bello carries the emotional weight. While Viggo is busy being an enigma, Edie is the one dealing with the fallout in the community. She’s a lawyer. She’s smart. Watching her realize that her entire life has been built on a lie is more painful than any of the physical fights in the movie. The cast of A History of Violence needed someone who could stand toe-to-toe with Viggo's intensity, and Bello basically redefined her career with this role.
👉 See also: Cuatro estaciones en la Habana: Why this Noir Masterpiece is Still the Best Way to See Cuba
Ed Harris and the Face of the Past
Then we get Ed Harris. Man, Ed Harris is scary.
He shows up as Carl Fogarty, a man with one eye and a very long memory. Fogarty is the one who cracks the shell of Millbrook. He walks into the diner and calls Tom "Joey," and the movie suddenly stops being a western and starts being a noir. Harris plays Fogarty with a quiet, menacing politeness. He’s not screaming. He’s just stating facts.
The makeup for Harris’s eye injury was intentionally grotesque. It serves as a physical reminder of the violence that Joey Cusack is capable of. Harris has this way of looking at Viggo that makes you feel like the walls are closing in. It’s a performance that doesn’t need a lot of screen time to leave a scar.
William Hurt: The Shortest Best Supporting Actor Nominee?
We have to talk about William Hurt. He’s on screen for, what, maybe ten minutes? But he walked away with an Oscar nomination for it. He plays Richie Cusack, Joey’s older brother, who is still living the mob life in Philadelphia.
Richie is a trip. He’s theatrical, slightly unhinged, and strangely needy. He’s the personification of the "history" in the title. While the rest of the cast of A History of Violence plays things grounded and gritty, Hurt goes a bit larger than life. It works because it highlights how ridiculous the world of organized crime actually is compared to the quiet life Tom/Joey tried to build.
- The Contrast: Richie lives in a literal mansion that looks like a tomb.
- The Dialogue: He has these lines that sound like they're from a Shakespearean tragedy, but delivered with a Philly accent.
- The Violence: Even in his limited time, he shows that the Cusack bloodline is fundamentally broken.
Ashton Holmes and the Generational Curse
A lot of people forget about Jack Stall, played by Ashton Holmes. He’s the son. His storyline is maybe the darkest part of the whole film.
✨ Don't miss: Cry Havoc: Why Jack Carr Just Changed the Reece-verse Forever
There’s a subplot involving a bully at school. Early on, Jack handles it with humor. But after he sees his dad kill those men in the diner, something changes. He stops using his brain and starts using his fists. It’s a terrifying look at how violence is a virus. You see it pass from the father to the son, almost like an inheritance. Holmes plays that transition perfectly—from a sensitive kid to someone who realizes he has a "talent" for hurting people.
Why This Cast Worked Under Cronenberg
David Cronenberg is known for "body horror," but this movie is "soul horror." He took a graphic novel by John Wagner and Vince Locke and stripped away the pulp. He needed a cast that could handle the silence.
Most movies feel the need to over-explain. This one doesn't.
When you look at the cast of A History of Violence, you see actors who are comfortable with ambiguity. The ending of the film is one of the most debated in cinema history. No spoilers, but it doesn't wrap things up in a neat bow. It relies entirely on the expressions of Viggo Mortensen and Maria Bello across a dinner table. If they hadn't built that chemistry and that tension over the previous 90 minutes, the ending would have fallen flat.
The Supporting Players
Even the smaller roles matter. Peter MacNeill as the local Sheriff Sam Carney provides the perspective of the "normal" world. He wants to believe Tom. He wants to protect his friend. But you can see the doubt eroding his confidence. It’s a subtle performance that represents the audience’s own desire to believe in the "hero" of the story.
Real-World Impact and Legacy
When A History of Violence premiered at Cannes, it got a standing ovation. Critics weren't just impressed by the gore—though there is plenty of it—they were stunned by the performances. It’s rare for a genre film to get that kind of respect.
🔗 Read more: Colin Macrae Below Deck: Why the Fan-Favorite Engineer Finally Walked Away
It changed Viggo Mortensen’s career path. He became Cronenberg’s muse, leading to Eastern Promises and A Dangerous Method. It also reminded everyone that Ed Harris is the king of the "menacing visitor" archetype.
What most people get wrong about this movie is thinking it's a celebration of a guy "protecting his own." It’s actually a warning. It asks if you can ever really change who you are, or if your past is just waiting for the right moment to catch up.
Moving Forward: How to Watch Like a Pro
If you’re planning a rewatch or seeing it for the first time, don't just watch the action. Focus on the hands. Cronenberg is obsessed with how the cast of A History of Violence uses their hands—pouring coffee, holding a gun, touching a spouse, or hitting a bully. It tells the whole story without a single word of dialogue.
To truly appreciate the depth of this ensemble, consider these steps:
- Watch the Diner Scene Twice: The first time, watch Viggo. The second time, watch the eyes of the attackers. The shift in power dynamics is a masterclass in blocking and acting.
- Compare Tom and Joey: Look for the specific moment in the forest where Tom’s voice drops an octave. That’s the exact second Tom Stall dies and Joey Cusack is reborn.
- Listen to the Score: Howard Shore’s music is subtle, but it tracks the psychological breakdown of the family perfectly.
The movie isn't just a classic because of the director; it’s a classic because every single actor understood that they weren't in a standard action movie. They were in a tragedy disguised as a thriller. Whether it's Maria Bello’s screams or William Hurt’s eccentricities, the performances are what make the "history" feel so heavy.