You think you're ready for the Sinnoh League. You’ve cruised through the gyms, stomped Team Galactic, and your team is sitting comfortably in the mid-sixties. Then you walk into the Brilliant Diamond Elite Four chambers and get your teeth kicked in by a Cricketune or a Sudowoodo. It's jarring. Honestly, it’s probably the most "disrespectful" difficulty spike in the entire franchise because it preys on your nostalgia.
If you played the original 2006 games, you remember Cynthia being tough. But ILCA—the developers behind the remakes—decided to dial the intensity up to eleven for the 1.1.1 version and beyond. They didn't just give the NPCs better levels; they gave them competitive-grade builds. We’re talking Max EVs, perfect IVs, and held items that make you feel like you’re playing in the Master Ball tier of Ranked Battle rather than a casual playthrough.
The Competitive Math Behind the Madness
Most Pokemon games are a breeze because NPC AI is predictable and their stats are "flat." In most entries, gym leaders and the Elite Four have zero Effort Values (EVs). In Brilliant Diamond, every single Pokemon used by the Elite Four and Cynthia has a custom 510 EV spread.
That matters. A lot.
It means Aaron’s Heracross isn’t just "strong." It has maximum Attack and Speed investment, likely with a Flame Orb to trigger the Guts ability. If you don't outspeed it, it will sweep your entire team. This is a fundamental shift in how Game Freak (and by extension ILCA) treats the end-game. They stopped treating the Elite Four as a victory lap and started treating it as a gatekeeper.
Why Aaron is a Total Trap
Aaron is the first hurdle, and he’s a bug-type specialist. Usually, that’s a joke. You bring a Staraptor or a Houndoom and press the "A" button until he’s gone. Not here. His Drapion is a defensive nightmare with the Battle Armor ability, meaning you can't land a lucky critical hit to bypass its bulk.
He leads with Dustox, which seems harmless until it starts stalling you out with Light Screen or Moonlight. If you take too long to clear his lead, the rest of his team—specifically that Guts Heracross—will punish you. It’s a lesson in momentum. If you lose it early, the Brilliant Diamond Elite Four will not give it back.
Bertha and the Art of the "Check"
Bertha is the second member, and she’s the reason you need a solid Water or Grass type that isn't just a "one-trick pony." Her team is built to survive. Her Whiscash is annoying, sure, but it’s her Golem and Rhyperior that usually end runs.
👉 See also: Nancy Drew Games for Mac: Why Everyone Thinks They're Broken (and How to Fix It)
She uses "Sturdy" and "Solid Rock" to ensure her Pokemon never die in one hit. You click Surf, expecting a one-shot, and they survive with a sliver of health thanks to a Focus Sash or natural bulk. Then they hit you back with an Earthquake or a Stone Edge that levels your lead.
Honestly, the most frustrating part of Bertha isn't her offense. It's her Quagsire. It has Recover. It has Toxic. It has Unaware (sometimes, depending on the rematch tier). It’s designed to waste your PP and chip away at your sanity. You have to play aggressively, or she will simply outlast you.
Flint’s "Non-Fire" Fire Team
Flint is a weird one. Since the Sinnoh Pokédex is notoriously thin on Fire-types, his initial team is a motley crew of "things that look like they might enjoy a campfire."
- Lopunny (Normal)
- Steelix (Steel/Ground)
- Drifblim (Ghost/Flying)
Don't let the lack of Fire-types fool you. This team is built for "Burn." His Lopunny is a Mirror Coat/Charm machine. His Drifblim uses Minimize and Strength Sap. It’s infuriating. If you can’t hit a Drifblim because it’s boosted its evasion three times, you’re going to burn through your best moves while it slowly leeches your health.
Then comes Infernape. It’s fast. It’s holding a Focus Sash. It has Close Combat and Flare Blitz. It is a glass cannon that almost always takes one of your Pokemon down with it. The Brilliant Diamond Elite Four thrives on these "one-for-one" trades, because they have five members and a champion, and you only have six slots.
Lucian and the Mental Game
Lucian is the final wall before the Champion. Psychic types are traditionally frail, but Lucian’s Mr. Mime sets up Reflect and Light Screen immediately. This halves the damage you deal for five turns.
If those screens stay up, his Alakazam will rip you apart. His Alakazam has a Life Orb and the Magic Guard ability. It hits like a freight train and takes no recoil damage. You need a fast Dark-type or a priority move-user like Scizor with Bullet Punch. Without priority, Lucian’s team is simply too fast for most "in-game" teams to handle.
✨ Don't miss: Magic Thread: What Most People Get Wrong in Fisch
His Bronzong is the anchor. It’s incredibly bulky and carries Trick Room. If you’ve built a fast, agile team, Lucian will flip the turn order and let his slow, heavy hitters move first. It's a classic competitive strategy that catches casual players completely off guard.
The Cynthia Problem
Cynthia is the peak. There is no other way to put it. Her Garchomp is the stuff of nightmares, and in Brilliant Diamond, it’s perfected.
It has a Yache Berry. This is a held item that weakens a super-effective Ice-type move. For years, the strategy was "just Ice Beam the dragon." In this game, Garchomp eats the Ice Beam, survives, and hits you with a Swords Dance-boosted Earthquake.
Game over.
Her Milotic is equally painful. It has the Flame Orb / Marvel Scale combo. By burning itself, Milotic boosts its Physical Defense by 50%. It then uses Recover and Scald (which has a 30% burn rate) to slowly melt your team. It’s a professional-grade stall tactic used by one of the most iconic AI trainers in history.
How to Actually Win
You can't just out-level this. Well, you can, but it takes forever because of the way EXP scaling works in Sinnoh. The better way is to fight fire with fire.
1. Held Items are Mandatory
Stop leaving your Pokemon "naked." Give someone a Leftovers (found in the Grand Underground or on wild Munchlax). Give your heavy hitter a Life Orb. Use Choice Specs on your fastest special attacker. If you aren't using items, you’re playing at a massive disadvantage.
🔗 Read more: Is the PlayStation 5 Slim Console Digital Edition Actually Worth It?
2. Set-Up Moves are Your Best Friend
The AI will swap Pokemon, but it won't always stop you from using Dragon Dance, Swords Dance, or Nasty Plot. If you can get two Dragon Dances off with a Gyarados while Aaron’s Dustox is busy setting up Light Screen, you can sweep his entire team. The same goes for Cynthia. If you don't set up, she will.
3. Use the Grand Underground
If your team feels weak, head below ground. You can find high-level encounters with "Egg Moves" that aren't available through normal leveling. A Roserade with Leaf Storm or a Gallade with Night Slash can change the entire dynamic of the Elite Four run.
4. Friendship Mechanics (The Safety Net)
This is controversial among "hardcore" fans, but the friendship mechanic in Brilliant Diamond—where your Pokemon survives on 1 HP or dodges a move because they "love you"—is often the only reason players beat Cynthia on their first try. Don't feel bad about it. Use it. Feed them Poffins. Walk with them. You’re going to need that "lucky" dodge when Garchomp goes for the kill.
5. Tactical Sacrifices
Sometimes, you have to let a Pokemon fainted. If Cynthia’s Garchomp is out and you need a "safe switch" to get your Ice-type in, send out a Pokemon that is already low on health. Let it take the hit so your heavy hitter comes in fresh without taking damage on the switch-in.
Actionable Strategy Checklist
- Check your Natures: Use Mints from the Battle Tower if your Alakazam has a "Modest" nature but you really need "Timid" for speed.
- EV Train: You don't need to be perfect, but feeding your Pokemon 26 Proteins or Carbos will give them a massive stat boost that the AI is already utilizing.
- Move Reminder: Visit the guy in Pastoria City. Make sure your Pokemon have their best possible movesets, not just the ones they learned while leveling up.
- Types Matter: Ensure you have a Fairy-type or a strong Ice-type specifically for Garchomp. Togekiss is a phenomenal choice for this because of its natural bulk and Special Attack.
- Priority Moves: Pack moves like Sucker Punch, Bullet Punch, or Extreme Speed. When the AI has 1 HP left because of a Focus Sash, priority moves save you from taking a massive counter-hit.
The Brilliant Diamond Elite Four isn't unfair, it's just a different kind of challenge. It demands that you stop playing like a kid and start playing like a strategist. Once you crack the code of their held items and EV spreads, the victory feels significantly more earned than in any other Pokemon remake.
Get your team to at least level 63. Optimize your moves. Buy plenty of Full Restores. Good luck—you'll need it when that Garchomp music starts.