Tinker Hatfield was staring at a Mustang fighter plane from World War II when he decided the basketball world needed something a bit more violent. That’s how we got the shark teeth. If you look at the Black Metallic Air Jordan 5, you aren't just looking at a sneaker; you're looking at the exact moment Michael Jordan transitioned from a rising star into a global predator. It's mean. It's dark. It's got that reflective tongue that catches the light like a strobe lamp in a dark club.
Most people think they know this shoe. They think it's just another retro in the vault. They're wrong.
The 1990 Identity Crisis
Nineteen-ninety was a weird year for the NBA. The Pistons were still bruising everyone in sight, and MJ was tired of losing. He needed a gear shift. When the Black Metallic colorway dropped, it felt illegal. Most shoes back then were white-based with a few splashes of team colors. Then comes this nubuck-drenched silhouette that looked like it belonged on a stealth bomber rather than a hardwood floor.
It changed everything.
The "Metallic" nickname comes from that specific silver flake on the midsole teeth and the massive 3M tongue. Back in the day, photographers hated that tongue. Why? Because the flash from their cameras would hit the reflective material and wash out the entire shot. It was a literal middle finger to the media, unintentional or not.
That Nubuck Feel and Why It Matters
Let’s talk about the material. The Black Metallic Air Jordan 5 uses a specific durabuck or nubuck, depending on which release year you’re holding. It’s soft. It’s matte. It absorbs light while the rest of the shoe reflects it.
If you find an OG pair from 1990, the "Nike Air" on the back is embroidered in a way that modern retros sometimes struggle to replicate. The 2016 "OG" retro got close, but purists will tell you the shape of the heel has changed over three decades. The original had a more aggressive slope. Modern pairs feel a bit more padded, a bit more "stuffed," which is great for comfort but slightly different for the silhouette-obsessed.
✨ Don't miss: Williams Sonoma Deer Park IL: What Most People Get Wrong About This Kitchen Icon
You’ve probably noticed the clear outsole, too. It was the first time Jordan Brand (or Nike, at the time) used a translucent sole on a signature shoe. It looked incredible for exactly three days. Then, the oxygen hit it.
Yellowing is the enemy of the Metallic 5. But honestly? A little yellowing on a pair of 5s gives them a bit of soul. It shows they’ve actually touched pavement.
The Specs Most People Ignore
We focus on the looks, but the tech was wild for 1990.
- The lace locks. This was the first Jordan to feature a plastic toggle to keep your laces from slipping. MJ used to have a habit of checking his laces constantly. Tinker solved that with a piece of plastic that became an instant style icon.
- The asymmetrical collar. If you look closely, the ankle height isn't even. It's sculpted to follow the natural line of the human ankle bone. It’s ergonomic before "ergonomic" was a marketing buzzword.
- Side mesh panels. It wasn't just for breathability. It was about weight reduction.
People like Gentry Humphrey, a legend in Jordan Brand history, have often spoken about how the 5 was the bridge between the "flight" era of the 4 and the "supercar" era of the 6. It sits in this perfect middle ground. It's bulky but fast.
The Cultural Weight of the Black Metallic
You can’t talk about this shoe without mentioning The Fresh Prince of Bel-Air. Will Smith wore them without laces. It was a cultural reset. Suddenly, a performance basketball shoe was a high-fashion statement in West Philly and beyond. It broke the "sports-only" barrier.
But let’s be real for a second. Wearing them laceless is a nightmare for your arches.
🔗 Read more: Finding the most affordable way to live when everything feels too expensive
Then you have the 2011 release versus the 2016 release. The 2011 version had the Jumpman on the heel. People lost their minds. "It's not authentic!" they yelled. When the 2016 pair brought back the "Nike Air" branding, it was like a religious experience for sneakerheads. It’s funny how a few stitches of thread can change the resale value by three hundred dollars.
How to Tell if You’re Looking at a Fake
In 2026, the replica market is terrifyingly good. But they almost always mess up the "shark teeth." On a real pair of Black Metallic Air Jordan 5s, the silver paint is crisp. The speckling—those little black dots on the silver—should look random. Fakes often have a pattern that looks too "perfect" or "stamped."
Also, check the netting. The plastic mesh should be clear or slightly milky, never "blue." If it has a blue tint, someone tried too hard to make it look "icy" in the factory.
Maintaining the Stealth Look
Cleaning these is a chore. Since it's nubuck, you can't just wipe it with a wet rag. You’ll ruin the nap of the suede. You need a brass-bristle brush and a dry eraser. Honestly, if you get caught in the rain in a pair of Metallic 5s, just accept your fate. Or carry a plastic bag. I’ve seen people do it. It’s not pretty, but it works.
The mid-sole paint is another issue. It flakes. It's a rite of passage. If your 5s aren't flaking, you aren't walking in them enough.
Why it Still Outperforms Modern Retros
There is a weight to the Black Metallic Air Jordan 5 that modern basketball shoes lack. Everything now is knit, mesh, and "lightweight." The 5 feels like a boot. It feels substantial. When you lace them up, you feel locked in. It’s a psychological thing.
💡 You might also like: Executive desk with drawers: Why your home office setup is probably failing you
Maybe that’s why we keep coming back to it. It’s not just the nostalgia for 1990. It’s the fact that the shoe feels like it was built to last a century, even if the sole eventually crumbles into dust after 15 years.
Actionable Steps for Owners and Buyers
If you’re looking to pick up a pair now, specifically the 2016 or any potential future Reimagined series, here is the playbook.
Verify the 3M. Take a photo with the flash on. The reflection should be uniform. If there are "dead spots" where the light doesn't bounce back, the material is either cheap or worn out.
Store them with silica. The clear soles are porous. They drink moisture out of the air. If you live in a humid climate, your soles will turn orange-yellow in eighteen months if you don't use desiccant packs.
Check the "23" embroidery. Not every release has it. The 1990 OG didn't have the 23 on the side (except for MJ's PE). Some retros have it, some don't. Know which year you're buying so you don't think a "clean" side panel is a defect.
Go true to size. Unlike the Jordan 1 which can be narrow, the 5 is pretty forgiving. If you have wide feet, stay true to your size. The inner lining is plush enough to accommodate.
The Black Metallic Air Jordan 5 remains the toughest-looking shoe in the Jordan catalog. It doesn't need loud colors. It doesn't need a collaboration with a rapper. It just needs that silver tongue and a bit of attitude.