Shojo manga is usually pretty predictable. You get the girl, the nice guy, and the guy who acts like he needs a hug but settles for being a jerk. But then there’s The Black Devil and the White Prince—or Kurosaki-kun no Iinari ni Nante Narai if you're being proper about it. It basically took every trope we knew and dialed the intensity up to eleven. Honestly, looking back at Makino’s massive hit, it’s kinda wild how much it dominated the scene.
You’ve got Yu Akabane. She’s just trying to reinvent herself. New school, new vibe, new life. She wants the "White Prince," Shirakawa-kun. He’s the dream, right? Perfect hair, perfect manners, perfect everything. But then she runs into Kurosaki. The "Black Devil." He’s not just "moody." He’s genuinely difficult. He cuts her hair. He treats her like a servant. And for some reason, the series became an absolute juggernaut in Bessatsu Friend.
The Problem with the "Perfect" Prince
Most people think the appeal of The Black Devil and the White Prince is just the toxic bad boy trope. That’s a bit of a surface-level take. The real hook is the subversion of the White Prince. Shirakawa isn't just a background character. He’s the personification of what every shojo protagonist is supposed to want.
In many ways, he's the safe bet. He represents social standing and the "ideal" romance. But as the story progresses, you start to see the cracks. Being the "White Prince" is a performance. It’s exhausting. Kurosaki, for all his aggressive flaws, is the only one being 100% authentic. He doesn't have a mask. If he’s angry, you know it. If he’s—in his own twisted way—interested, you know it too.
This dynamic is why the manga ran for nearly a decade. It wasn't just about a love triangle; it was about Yu trying to figure out if she wanted a fairy tale or something that felt messy and real.
👉 See also: New Movies in Theatre: What Most People Get Wrong About This Month's Picks
Why the Live-Action Version Actually Worked
Usually, live-action adaptations of manga are... let's say, hit or miss. Mostly miss. But the 2016 film and the preceding special starring Nana Komatsu, Kento Nakajima, and Yudai Chiba actually captured the chaotic energy of the source material.
Kento Nakajima as Kurosaki was a stroke of genius. He’s a literal idol, someone known for being the "Prince" type in real life with Sexy Zone. Seeing him flip the script to play a sadistic, borderline-unhinged teen was a meta-narrative that Japanese fans loved. Nana Komatsu also brought a specific kind of groundedness to Yu. She wasn't just a weeping willow. She fought back, even when she was losing.
The film didn't try to make it "precious." It leaned into the melodrama.
Breaking Down the Power Dynamics
It's uncomfortable. Let's be real. The "slave" contract Kurosaki forces on Yu hasn't aged perfectly in the eyes of modern Western discourse. However, in the context of The Black Devil and the White Prince, this power struggle is the primary engine of character growth.
✨ Don't miss: A Simple Favor Blake Lively: Why Emily Nelson Is Still the Ultimate Screen Mystery
- Yu's Agency: She starts as a blank slate. By the end, she’s the one making the demands.
- The Shared Secret: Most of their interaction happens away from the prying eyes of the school.
- The Emotional Shift: Kurosaki's "Black Devil" persona is a defense mechanism against his own family trauma and isolation.
You see this a lot in other works by Makino, but never as sharply as here. The tension is thick. It’s the kind of "will-they-won't-they" that makes you want to throw the book across the room while immediately reaching for the next volume.
The Cultural Footprint of Kurosaki-kun
Why does this specific story matter years later? Because it paved the way for the "extreme" shojo trend. Before this, things were a bit more polite. After The Black Devil and the White Prince, we saw a surge in stories that weren't afraid to have a protagonist who was actually kind of a jerk.
It’s about the thrill of the "un-tameable" character. People love the idea of being the exception to the rule. If Kurosaki is mean to everyone but marginally less mean to Yu, that feels like a victory in the warped logic of high school romance manga.
But there's also the art. Makino’s art style is incredibly distinctive. The way she draws eyes—sharp, piercing, and often shadowed—perfectly mirrors the psychological weight of the story. The contrast between the bright, airy panels featuring Shirakawa and the heavy, black-inked scenes with Kurosaki tells the story even if you aren't reading the dialogue.
🔗 Read more: The A Wrinkle in Time Cast: Why This Massive Star Power Didn't Save the Movie
Common Misconceptions About the Ending
People often complain that the ending was rushed or that Yu "chose wrong."
Honestly? The ending was the only one that made sense. If she had chosen the White Prince, the story would have been a lie. The entire point was that she was attracted to the intensity, not the image. The manga’s final chapters really drive home that Kurosaki isn't going to suddenly become a "nice guy." He’s just going to be her guy.
It’s a subtle distinction, but it’s what keeps the series from being a total cliché. It respects the characters' established personalities instead of forcing a "happily ever after" that feels like a different genre entirely.
What to Do If You're New to the Series
If you’re just diving in, don’t start with the movie. Go for the manga first. The pacing is much better, and you get to see the slow burn of Yu’s internal monologue. The live-action is great for the vibes, but the manga is where the actual character development lives.
Check out the official Kodansha releases. They’ve done a solid job with the translation, keeping the bite in Kurosaki's dialogue without making it sound too dated.
Actionable Steps for Fans:
- Read the Manga First: The 19-volume run allows for a level of nuance that the 90-minute movie simply cannot touch.
- Watch the 2-Episode Special: Before the 2016 movie, there was a TV special. It sets up the school dynamics and is essential for understanding the trio's history.
- Compare the Spin-offs: Makino has other works that touch on similar themes. If you liked the "bad boy" dynamic, look into L-DK or Wolf Girl and Black Prince (though that's by Ayuko Hatta, it shares the same DNA).
- Analyze the Visual Cues: Pay attention to how the "Black" and "White" motifs aren't just names. Look at the shading in the manga panels; the lighting literally changes depending on which boy is on screen.
The legacy of The Black Devil and the White Prince isn't just about a girl caught between two guys. It's about the shift in how shojo handles desire, power, and the messy reality of teenage feelings. It's loud, it's dramatic, and it's exactly what it needs to be.